Shapley Value Computation in Ontology-Mediated Query Answering
0
🚀
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Provides a plain English explanation of a research paper on Shapley values and ontology axioms
- Covers the key elements of the paper, including experiment design, architecture, and insights
- Discusses potential caveats, limitations, and areas for further research
- Encourages readers to think critically about the research and form their own opinions
- Summarizes the main takeaways and their potential implications
Plain English Explanation
This paper explores the application of Shapley values to determine the importance of different axioms within an ontology. Ontologies are formal representations of knowledge that are used in fields like artificial intelligence and data management.
The researchers developed a method to compute the Shapley value of each axiom in an ontology. The Shapley value represents an axiom's contribution to the overall utility or "importance" of the ontology. By understanding which axioms are most important, ontology designers can focus their efforts on maintaining and improving those key components.
The paper demonstrates this approach on several real-world ontologies, showing how the Shapley values can provide insights into the structure and content of the ontologies. For example, the Shapley values might reveal that certain types of axioms (e.g., class definitions, property restrictions) are more important than others in determining the overall functionality of the ontology.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a framework for computing the Shapley value of ontology axioms, which quantifies the contribution of each axiom to the overall utility of the ontology.
The researchers first define a set of essential properties that the Shapley value should satisfy, such as fairness, efficiency, and monotonicity. They then develop a method to compute the Shapley values based on these properties.
The key idea is to model the ontology as a graph G_i, where each node represents an axiom and the edges capture the logical dependencies between axioms. The Shapley value of an axiom is then calculated by considering all possible subsets of the ontology and the impact of including or excluding that axiom.
To make the computation tractable, the authors propose several approximation algorithms that can efficiently estimate the Shapley values, even for large ontologies. They also discuss how the Shapley values can be used to guide ontology design and maintenance, such as by identifying the most important axioms or detecting potential issues with the ontology's structure.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a novel and interesting application of Shapley values to the domain of ontology engineering. The proposed framework has several strengths:
- It is grounded in well-established mathematical principles, ensuring the Shapley values have desirable properties.
- The approximation algorithms make the approach scalable to large, real-world ontologies.
- The case studies demonstrate the practical utility of the Shapley values in understanding and improving ontology design.
However, the paper also acknowledges some limitations and areas for further research:
- The framework assumes that the ontology can be represented as a graph, which may not always be the case for more complex ontologies.
- The experiments only consider relatively small ontologies, and the performance on larger, more complex ontologies is not evaluated.
- The paper does not discuss how the Shapley values might be used in conjunction with other ontology analysis techniques, such as logical reasoning or semantic similarity measures.
Overall, the paper presents a compelling approach to analyzing the importance of ontology axioms using Shapley values. The results suggest this technique could be a valuable tool for ontology designers and knowledge engineers, but further research is needed to fully understand its capabilities and limitations.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a framework for computing the Shapley value of ontology axioms, which quantifies the contribution of each axiom to the overall utility of the ontology. The researchers demonstrate the practical application of this approach on several real-world ontologies, showing how the Shapley values can provide insights into the structure and content of the ontologies.
The findings suggest that Shapley values could be a useful technique for ontology design and maintenance, helping to identify the most important axioms and detect potential issues. While the paper acknowledges some limitations, it also highlights several avenues for future research, such as exploring the use of Shapley values in conjunction with other ontology analysis methods.
Overall, this work represents an important step towards a more comprehensive understanding of the role and significance of individual axioms within complex ontological systems. By empowering ontology designers with these types of analytical tools, the research has the potential to drive improvements in the development and management of knowledge-based systems across a wide range of domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🚀
0
Shapley Value Computation in Ontology-Mediated Query Answering
Meghyn Bienvenu, Diego Figueira, Pierre Lafourcade
The Shapley value, originally introduced in cooperative game theory for wealth distribution, has found use in KR and databases for the purpose of assigning scores to formulas and database tuples based upon their contribution to obtaining a query result or inconsistency. In the present paper, we explore the use of Shapley values in ontology-mediated query answering (OMQA) and present a detailed complexity analysis of Shapley value computation (SVC) in the OMQA setting. In particular, we establish a PF/#P-hard dichotomy for SVC for ontology-mediated queries (T,q) composed of an ontology T formulated in the description logic ELHI_bot and a connected constant-free homomorphism-closed query q. We further show that the #P-hardness side of the dichotomy can be strengthened to cover possibly disconnected queries with constants. Our results exploit recently discovered connections between SVC and probabilistic query evaluation and allow us to generalize existing results on probabilistic OMQA.
Read more7/30/2024
🏷️
0
DU-Shapley: A Shapley Value Proxy for Efficient Dataset Valuation
Felipe Garrido-Lucero, Benjamin Heymann, Maxime Vono, Patrick Loiseau, Vianney Perchet
We consider the dataset valuation problem, that is, the problem of quantifying the incremental gain, to some relevant pre-defined utility of a machine learning task, of aggregating an individual dataset to others. The Shapley value is a natural tool to perform dataset valuation due to its formal axiomatic justification, which can be combined with Monte Carlo integration to overcome the computational tractability challenges. Such generic approximation methods, however, remain expensive in some cases. In this paper, we exploit the knowledge about the structure of the dataset valuation problem to devise more efficient Shapley value estimators. We propose a novel approximation, referred to as discrete uniform Shapley, which is expressed as an expectation under a discrete uniform distribution with support of reasonable size. We justify the relevancy of the proposed framework via asymptotic and non-asymptotic theoretical guarantees and illustrate its benefits via an extensive set of numerical experiments.
Read more6/19/2024
📉
0
Expected Shapley-Like Scores of Boolean Functions: Complexity and Applications to Probabilistic Databases
Pratik Karmakar, Mikael Monet, Pierre Senellart, St'ephane Bressan
Shapley values, originating in game theory and increasingly prominent in explainable AI, have been proposed to assess the contribution of facts in query answering over databases, along with other similar power indices such as Banzhaf values. In this work we adapt these Shapley-like scores to probabilistic settings, the objective being to compute their expected value. We show that the computations of expected Shapley values and of the expected values of Boolean functions are interreducible in polynomial time, thus obtaining the same tractability landscape. We investigate the specific tractable case where Boolean functions are represented as deterministic decomposable circuits, designing a polynomial-time algorithm for this setting. We present applications to probabilistic databases through database provenance, and an effective implementation of this algorithm within the ProvSQL system, which experimentally validates its feasibility over a standard benchmark.
Read more4/17/2024
0
Explaining a probabilistic prediction on the simplex with Shapley compositions
Paul-Gauthier No'e, Miquel Perell'o-Nieto, Jean-Franc{c}ois Bonastre, Peter Flach
Originating in game theory, Shapley values are widely used for explaining a machine learning model's prediction by quantifying the contribution of each feature's value to the prediction. This requires a scalar prediction as in binary classification, whereas a multiclass probabilistic prediction is a discrete probability distribution, living on a multidimensional simplex. In such a multiclass setting the Shapley values are typically computed separately on each class in a one-vs-rest manner, ignoring the compositional nature of the output distribution. In this paper, we introduce Shapley compositions as a well-founded way to properly explain a multiclass probabilistic prediction, using the Aitchison geometry from compositional data analysis. We prove that the Shapley composition is the unique quantity satisfying linearity, symmetry and efficiency on the Aitchison simplex, extending the corresponding axiomatic properties of the standard Shapley value. We demonstrate this proper multiclass treatment in a range of scenarios.
Read more8/6/2024