Stochastic Principal-Agent Problems: Efficient Computation and Learning
0
🤖
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a stochastic principal-agent model
- Principal and agent interact in a stochastic environment, each with private observations about the state
- Principal has commitment power to elicit information from agent and provide signals
- Players communicate, select actions independently, and receive payoffs based on state and joint action
- Interaction continues over a finite time horizon
- Players aim to maximize total payoffs over time horizon
- Encompasses various forms of sequential principal-agent interactions
Plain English Explanation
In this research, the authors introduce a stochastic principal-agent model, where a principal and an agent interact in a stochastic environment. The principal has the power to commit to certain actions and can use this to elicit information from the agent and provide signals about their own information.
The players communicate with each other and then independently select actions. Their payoffs depend on the state of the environment and their joint action. This interaction continues over a finite time period, and both players aim to maximize their total payoffs over this time horizon.
The model encompasses various forms of sequential principal-agent interactions, including Bayesian persuasion and automated mechanism design problems.
Technical Explanation
The authors consider both the computation and learning of the principal's optimal policy. Since the general problem, which subsumes POMDPs, is intractable, they explore algorithmic solutions under the condition of hindsight observability, where the state and the interaction history are revealed at the end of each step.
Although this makes the problem more amenable, the number of possible histories remains exponential in the length of the time horizon, making approaches for extensive-form games infeasible. The authors present an efficient algorithm based on the inducible value sets, which computes an ε-approximate optimal policy in time polynomial in 1/ε.
Additionally, the authors show an efficient learning algorithm for an episodic reinforcement learning setting where the transition probabilities are unknown. This algorithm guarantees sublinear regret Õ(T^(2/3)) for both players over T episodes.
Critical Analysis
The paper introduces a comprehensive and general model for studying sequential principal-agent interactions, which can encompass a wide range of applications. However, the general problem is intractable, and the authors' focus on the hindsight observability condition, while making the problem more amenable, still faces challenges due to the exponential growth in the number of possible histories.
The authors' algorithmic solutions, while efficient, may have limitations in practical applications where the time horizon or the state space is very large. Additionally, the learning algorithm's performance guarantee, while sublinear, may not be sufficient for real-world scenarios with strict time or resource constraints.
Further research could explore alternative approaches, such as approximation techniques or the incorporation of additional structural assumptions, to make the problem more tractable in a broader range of settings. Investigating the practical implications and potential applications of the model would also be a valuable direction for future work.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a comprehensive stochastic principal-agent model that encompasses a wide range of sequential interaction scenarios, including Bayesian persuasion and automated mechanism design. While the general problem is intractable, the authors present efficient algorithms for computing and learning the principal's optimal policy under the hindsight observability condition.
The research provides valuable insights into the computational and learning challenges in these types of sequential principal-agent interactions, which have important applications in fields such as reinforcement learning, mechanism design, and multi-agent systems. Further advancements in this area could lead to more efficient and effective solutions for a wide range of real-world decision-making problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤖
0
Stochastic Principal-Agent Problems: Efficient Computation and Learning
Jiarui Gan, Rupak Majumdar, Debmalya Mandal, Goran Radanovic
We introduce a stochastic principal-agent model. A principal and an agent interact in a stochastic environment, each privy to observations about the state not available to the other. The principal has the power of commitment, both to elicit information from the agent and to provide signals about her own information. The players communicate with each other and then select actions independently. Each of them receives a payoff based on the state and their joint action, and the environment transitions to a new state. The interaction continues over a finite time horizon. Both players are far-sighted, aiming to maximize their total payoffs over the time horizon. The model encompasses as special cases extensive-form games (EFGs) and stochastic games of incomplete information, partially observable Markov decision processes (POMDPs), as well as other forms of sequential principal-agent interactions, including Bayesian persuasion and automated mechanism design problems. We consider both the computation and learning of the principal's optimal policy. Since the general problem, which subsumes POMDPs, is intractable, we explore algorithmic solutions under hindsight observability, where the state and the interaction history are revealed at the end of each step. Though the problem becomes more amenable under this condition, the number of possible histories remains exponential in the length of the time horizon, making approaches for EFG-based models infeasible. We present an efficient algorithm based on the inducible value sets. The algorithm computes an $epsilon$-approximate optimal policy in time polynomial in $1/epsilon$. Additionally, we show an efficient learning algorithm for an episodic reinforcement learning setting where the transition probabilities are unknown. The algorithm guarantees sublinear regret $tilde{O}(T^{2/3})$ for both players over $T$ episodes.
Read more9/14/2024
🛸
0
Generalized Principal-Agent Problem with a Learning Agent
Tao Lin, Yiling Chen
Generalized principal-agent problems, including Stackelberg games, contract design, and Bayesian persuasion, are a class of economic problems where an agent best responds to a principal's committed strategy. We study repeated generalized principal-agent problems under the assumption that the principal does not have commitment power and the agent uses algorithms to learn to respond to the principal. We reduce this problem to a one-shot generalized principal-agent problem with an approximately-best-responding agent. Using this reduction, we show that: (1) if the agent uses contextual no-regret learning algorithms, then the principal can guarantee a utility that is at least the principal's optimal utility in the classic non-learning model minus the square root of the agent's regret; (2) if the agent uses contextual no-swap-regret learning algorithms, then the principal cannot obtain any utility more than the optimal utility in the non-learning model plus the agent's swap regret. But (3) if the agent uses mean-based learning algorithms (which can be no-regret but not no-swap-regret), then the principal can do significantly better than the non-learning model. These general results not only refine previous results in Stackelberg games and contract design with learning agents but also lead to new results for Bayesian persuasion with a learning agent.
Read more6/12/2024
🏅
0
Partially Observable Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning with Information Sharing
Xiangyu Liu, Kaiqing Zhang
We study provable multi-agent reinforcement learning (RL) in the general framework of partially observable stochastic games (POSGs). To circumvent the known hardness results and the use of computationally intractable oracles, we advocate leveraging the potential emph{information-sharing} among agents, a common practice in empirical multi-agent RL, and a standard model for multi-agent control systems with communications. We first establish several computational complexity results to justify the necessity of information-sharing, as well as the observability assumption that has enabled quasi-efficient single-agent RL with partial observations, for efficiently solving POSGs. {Inspired by the inefficiency of planning in the ground-truth model,} we then propose to further emph{approximate} the shared common information to construct an {approximate model} of the POSG, in which planning an approximate emph{equilibrium} (in terms of solving the original POSG) can be quasi-efficient, i.e., of quasi-polynomial-time, under the aforementioned assumptions. Furthermore, we develop a partially observable multi-agent RL algorithm that is emph{both} statistically and computationally quasi-efficient. {Finally, beyond equilibrium learning, we extend our algorithmic framework to finding the emph{team-optimal solution} in cooperative POSGs, i.e., decentralized partially observable Markov decision processes, a much more challenging goal. We establish concrete computational and sample complexities under several common structural assumptions of the model.} We hope our study could open up the possibilities of leveraging and even designing different emph{information structures}, a well-studied notion in control theory, for developing both sample- and computation-efficient partially observable multi-agent RL.
Read more9/5/2024
0
Principal-Agent Reinforcement Learning
Dima Ivanov, Paul Dutting, Inbal Talgam-Cohen, Tonghan Wang, David C. Parkes
Contracts are the economic framework which allows a principal to delegate a task to an agent -- despite misaligned interests, and even without directly observing the agent's actions. In many modern reinforcement learning settings, self-interested agents learn to perform a multi-stage task delegated to them by a principal. We explore the significant potential of utilizing contracts to incentivize the agents. We model the delegated task as an MDP, and study a stochastic game between the principal and agent where the principal learns what contracts to use, and the agent learns an MDP policy in response. We present a learning-based algorithm for optimizing the principal's contracts, which provably converges to the subgame-perfect equilibrium of the principal-agent game. A deep RL implementation allows us to apply our method to very large MDPs with unknown transition dynamics. We extend our approach to multiple agents, and demonstrate its relevance to resolving a canonical sequential social dilemma with minimal intervention to agent rewards.
Read more7/26/2024