Structured Inverse-Free Natural Gradient: Memory-Efficient & Numerically-Stable KFAC
2312.05705
0
0
🌿
Abstract
Second-order methods such as KFAC can be useful for neural net training. However, they are often memory-inefficient since their preconditioning Kronecker factors are dense, and numerically unstable in low precision as they require matrix inversion or decomposition. These limitations render such methods unpopular for modern mixed-precision training. We address them by (i) formulating an inverse-free KFAC update and (ii) imposing structures in the Kronecker factors, resulting in structured inverse-free natural gradient descent (SINGD). On modern neural networks, we show that SINGD is memory-efficient and numerically robust, in contrast to KFAC, and often outperforms AdamW even in half precision. Our work closes a gap between first- and second-order methods in modern low-precision training.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Second-order methods like KFAC can be useful for training neural networks, but they often have limitations:
- They are memory-inefficient because their preconditioning Kronecker factors are dense.
- They can be numerically unstable in low precision, as they require matrix inversion or decomposition.
- These limitations have made such methods unpopular for modern mixed-precision training.
Plain English Explanation
Neural networks are powerful machine learning models that can learn complex patterns in data. Training these models can be challenging, as it requires optimizing a large number of parameters. Second-order optimization methods, like KFAC, can help speed up the training process by taking into account the curvature of the optimization landscape.
However, these methods have some drawbacks. They require storing and manipulating large matrices, which can be memory-intensive. Additionally, they rely on matrix inversions or decompositions, which can be numerically unstable, especially when using low-precision arithmetic, such as half-precision floating-point numbers.
These limitations have made second-order methods less popular for modern neural network training, which often uses mixed-precision techniques to improve efficiency.
Technical Explanation
The paper addresses the limitations of second-order methods like KFAC in two ways:
-
Inverse-free KFAC Update: The authors formulate an inverse-free version of the KFAC update, which avoids the need for matrix inversion or decomposition.
-
Structured Kronecker Factors: The authors impose additional structure on the Kronecker factors used in KFAC, resulting in a method called Structured Inverse-free Natural Gradient Descent (SINGD).
The authors show that SINGD is both memory-efficient and numerically robust, in contrast to KFAC. They demonstrate that SINGD often outperforms the popular AdamW optimizer, even when using half-precision floating-point numbers.
Critical Analysis
The paper addresses a relevant problem in the field of neural network optimization, namely the limitations of second-order methods like KFAC in the context of modern, low-precision training. The proposed SINGD method appears to be a promising solution, as it addresses the key issues of memory inefficiency and numerical instability.
However, the paper does not discuss potential drawbacks or limitations of SINGD. For example, it would be useful to know how the performance of SINGD compares to other recent second-order methods, such as H-FAC or Thermodynamic Natural Gradient Descent. Additionally, the authors do not provide a theoretical analysis of the convergence properties of SINGD, which could help assess its suitability for different types of neural network architectures and optimization problems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel second-order optimization method, SINGD, that addresses the limitations of traditional second-order methods like KFAC in the context of modern, low-precision neural network training. By formulating an inverse-free KFAC update and imposing structured Kronecker factors, the authors have developed a memory-efficient and numerically robust optimization algorithm that can outperform popular first-order methods like AdamW.
The work represents an important contribution to the field of neural network optimization, as it helps bridge the gap between first- and second-order methods in low-precision training settings. Further research is needed to fully understand the strengths and weaknesses of SINGD compared to other state-of-the-art optimization techniques, but this paper lays the groundwork for more efficient and stable second-order training of neural networks.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Inverse-Free Fast Natural Gradient Descent Method for Deep Learning
Xinwei Ou, Ce Zhu, Xiaolin Huang, Yipeng Liu
0
0
Second-order optimization techniques have the potential to achieve faster convergence rates compared to first-order methods through the incorporation of second-order derivatives or statistics. However, their utilization in deep learning is limited due to their computational inefficiency. Various approaches have been proposed to address this issue, primarily centered on minimizing the size of the matrix to be inverted. Nevertheless, the necessity of performing the inverse operation iteratively persists. In this work, we present a fast natural gradient descent (FNGD) method that only requires inversion during the first epoch. Specifically, it is revealed that natural gradient descent (NGD) is essentially a weighted sum of per-sample gradients. Our novel approach further proposes to share these weighted coefficients across epochs without affecting empirical performance. Consequently, FNGD exhibits similarities to the average sum in first-order methods, leading to the computational complexity of FNGD being comparable to that of first-order methods. Extensive experiments on image classification and machine translation tasks demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed FNGD. For training ResNet-18 on CIFAR-100, FNGD can achieve a speedup of 2.07$times$ compared with KFAC. For training Transformer on Multi30K, FNGD outperforms AdamW by 24 BLEU score while requiring almost the same training time.
4/30/2024
Kronecker-Factored Approximate Curvature for Physics-Informed Neural Networks
Felix Dangel, Johannes Muller, Marius Zeinhofer
0
0
Physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) are infamous for being hard to train. Recently, second-order methods based on natural gradient and Gauss-Newton methods have shown promising performance, improving the accuracy achieved by first-order methods by several orders of magnitude. While promising, the proposed methods only scale to networks with a few thousand parameters due to the high computational cost to evaluate, store, and invert the curvature matrix. We propose Kronecker-factored approximate curvature (KFAC) for PINN losses that greatly reduces the computational cost and allows scaling to much larger networks. Our approach goes beyond the established KFAC for traditional deep learning problems as it captures contributions from a PDE's differential operator that are crucial for optimization. To establish KFAC for such losses, we use Taylor-mode automatic differentiation to describe the differential operator's computation graph as a forward network with shared weights. This allows us to apply KFAC thanks to a recently-developed general formulation for networks with weight sharing. Empirically, we find that our KFAC-based optimizers are competitive with expensive second-order methods on small problems, scale more favorably to higher-dimensional neural networks and PDEs, and consistently outperform first-order methods and LBFGS.
5/28/2024
H-Fac: Memory-Efficient Optimization with Factorized Hamiltonian Descent
Son Nguyen, Lizhang Chen, Bo Liu, Qiang Liu
0
0
In this study, we introduce a novel adaptive optimizer, H-Fac, which incorporates a factorized approach to momentum and scaling parameters. Our algorithm demonstrates competitive performances on both ResNets and Vision Transformers, while achieving sublinear memory costs through the use of rank-1 parameterizations for moment estimators. We develop our algorithms based on principles derived from Hamiltonian dynamics, providing robust theoretical underpinnings. These optimization algorithms are designed to be both straightforward and adaptable, facilitating easy implementation in diverse settings.
6/18/2024
🌿
Thermodynamic Natural Gradient Descent
Kaelan Donatella, Samuel Duffield, Maxwell Aifer, Denis Melanson, Gavin Crooks, Patrick J. Coles
0
0
Second-order training methods have better convergence properties than gradient descent but are rarely used in practice for large-scale training due to their computational overhead. This can be viewed as a hardware limitation (imposed by digital computers). Here we show that natural gradient descent (NGD), a second-order method, can have a similar computational complexity per iteration to a first-order method, when employing appropriate hardware. We present a new hybrid digital-analog algorithm for training neural networks that is equivalent to NGD in a certain parameter regime but avoids prohibitively costly linear system solves. Our algorithm exploits the thermodynamic properties of an analog system at equilibrium, and hence requires an analog thermodynamic computer. The training occurs in a hybrid digital-analog loop, where the gradient and Fisher information matrix (or any other positive semi-definite curvature matrix) are calculated at given time intervals while the analog dynamics take place. We numerically demonstrate the superiority of this approach over state-of-the-art digital first- and second-order training methods on classification tasks and language model fine-tuning tasks.
5/24/2024