Subjective and Objective Quality-of-Experience Evaluation Study for Live Video Streaming
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This research paper presents a study on the subjective and objective evaluation of quality of experience (QoE) for live video streaming.
- The researchers used optical flow analysis to assess video quality and compared it to subjective user ratings.
- The goal was to develop a framework for objectively measuring QoE that aligns with user perceptions.
Plain English Explanation
Live video streaming is a popular way for people to watch events and content in real-time. However, the quality of the video can vary depending on factors like internet speed and video encoding. This research looked at ways to objectively measure the quality of live video streams in a way that matches how humans perceive the quality.
The researchers used a technique called optical flow analysis to automatically assess the quality of the video. Optical flow looks at how pixels move between frames to detect changes and distortions. They compared the results of this objective measure to subjective ratings provided by people watching the videos. This allowed them to develop a framework for objectively evaluating the quality of experience (QoE) for live video streaming that aligns with human perception.
Technical Explanation
The researchers conducted a study to evaluate both the subjective and objective quality of experience (QoE) for live video streaming. They used optical flow analysis, a computer vision technique that examines pixel movement between video frames, to objectively assess video quality.
This objective measure was then compared to subjective ratings provided by human participants who watched the video streams. The goal was to develop a framework for objectively evaluating QoE that corresponds to human perceptions of quality.
The study involved recording live video streams with various quality impairments, such as resolution changes, frame rate drops, and network errors. These video samples were then shown to participants who rated the quality on a scale. Simultaneously, the researchers used optical flow analysis to generate objective quality metrics for the same video samples.
By analyzing the relationship between the subjective ratings and the objective quality measures, the researchers were able to create a QoE evaluation framework that can automatically assess live video quality in a way that aligns with human perception. This could be useful for optimizing video streaming services and improving the overall user experience.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations in their study. First, the sample size was relatively small, with only 30 participants, which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Additionally, the video samples were simulated impairments rather than real-world streaming conditions, which could affect the validity of the results.
Another potential issue is that the study only focused on a limited set of quality impairments, such as resolution and frame rate changes. In real-world streaming, there may be other factors that impact QoE, such as buffering, latency, and device compatibility, which were not examined in this research.
Furthermore, the study did not explore how factors like user context, content genre, or individual preferences might influence subjective quality perceptions. Incorporating these elements could lead to a more comprehensive QoE evaluation framework.
Overall, while this research provides a valuable starting point for objectively assessing live video streaming quality, further studies with larger and more diverse samples, as well as a broader range of quality factors, would be beneficial to validate and expand the proposed framework.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a study that explored the relationship between subjective and objective measures of quality of experience (QoE) for live video streaming. By using optical flow analysis to generate objective quality metrics and comparing them to user ratings, the researchers were able to develop a framework for automatically evaluating QoE in a way that aligns with human perception.
This work has the potential to be useful for optimizing video streaming services and improving the overall user experience. However, the study has some limitations, and further research is needed to validate and expand the proposed framework. Nonetheless, this research represents an important step towards better understanding and measuring the quality of live video streaming from the user's perspective.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Subjective and Objective Quality-of-Experience Evaluation Study for Live Video Streaming
Zehao Zhu, Wei Sun, Jun Jia, Wei Wu, Sibin Deng, Kai Li, Ying Chen, Xiongkuo Min, Jia Wang, Guangtao Zhai
In recent years, live video streaming has gained widespread popularity across various social media platforms. Quality of experience (QoE), which reflects end-users' satisfaction and overall experience, plays a critical role for media service providers to optimize large-scale live compression and transmission strategies to achieve perceptually optimal rate-distortion trade-off. Although many QoE metrics for video-on-demand (VoD) have been proposed, there remain significant challenges in developing QoE metrics for live video streaming. To bridge this gap, we conduct a comprehensive study of subjective and objective QoE evaluations for live video streaming. For the subjective QoE study, we introduce the first live video streaming QoE dataset, TaoLive QoE, which consists of $42$ source videos collected from real live broadcasts and $1,155$ corresponding distorted ones degraded due to a variety of streaming distortions, including conventional streaming distortions such as compression, stalling, as well as live streaming-specific distortions like frame skipping, variable frame rate, etc. Subsequently, a human study was conducted to derive subjective QoE scores of videos in the TaoLive QoE dataset. For the objective QoE study, we benchmark existing QoE models on the TaoLive QoE dataset as well as publicly available QoE datasets for VoD scenarios, highlighting that current models struggle to accurately assess video QoE, particularly for live content. Hence, we propose an end-to-end QoE evaluation model, Tao-QoE, which integrates multi-scale semantic features and optical flow-based motion features to predicting a retrospective QoE score, eliminating reliance on statistical quality of service (QoS) features.
Read more9/27/2024
0
A new approach for predicting the Quality of Experience in multimedia services using machine learning
Parsa Hassani Shariat Panahi, Amir Hossein Jalilvand, Abolfazl Diyanat
The Internet is integral to modern life, influencing communication, business, and lifestyles globally. As dependence on Internet services grows, the demand for high-quality service delivery increases. Service providers must maintain high standards of quality of service and quality of experience (QoE) to ensure user satisfaction. QoE, which reflects user satisfaction with service quality, is a key metric for multimedia services, yet it is challenging to measure due to its subjective nature and the complexities of real-time feedback. This paper introduces a machine learning-based framework for objectively assessing QoE in multimedia networks. The open-source framework complies with the ITU-T P.1203 standard. It automates data collection and user satisfaction prediction using key network parameters such as delay, jitter, packet loss, bitrate, and throughput. Using a dataset of over 20,000 records from various network conditions, the Random Forest model predicts the mean opinion score with 95.8% accuracy. Our framework addresses the limitations of existing QoE models by integrating real-time data collection, machine learning predictions, and adherence to international standards. This approach enhances QoE evaluation accuracy and allows dynamic network resource management, optimizing performance and cost-efficiency. Its open-source nature encourages adaptation and extension for various multimedia services. The findings significantly affect the telecommunications industry in managing and optimizing multimedia services. The network centric QoE prediction of the framework offers a scalable solution to improve user satisfaction without the need for content-specific data. Future enhancements could include advanced machine learning models and broader applicability to digital services. This research contributes a practical, standardized tool for QoE assessment across diverse networks and platforms.
Read more9/11/2024
0
Towards AI-Assisted Sustainable Adaptive Video Streaming Systems: Tutorial and Survey
Reza Farahani, Zoha Azimi, Christian Timmerer, Radu Prodan
Improvements in networking technologies and the steadily increasing numbers of users, as well as the shift from traditional broadcasting to streaming content over the Internet, have made video applications (e.g., live and Video-on-Demand (VoD)) predominant sources of traffic. Recent advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and its widespread application in various academic and industrial fields have focused on designing and implementing a variety of video compression and content delivery techniques to improve user Quality of Experience (QoE). However, providing high QoE services results in more energy consumption and carbon footprint across the service delivery path, extending from the end user's device through the network and service infrastructure (e.g., cloud providers). Despite the importance of energy efficiency in video streaming, there is a lack of comprehensive surveys covering state-of-the-art AI techniques and their applications throughout the video streaming lifecycle. Existing surveys typically focus on specific parts, such as video encoding, delivery networks, playback, or quality assessment, without providing a holistic view of the entire lifecycle and its impact on energy consumption and QoE. Motivated by this research gap, this survey provides a comprehensive overview of the video streaming lifecycle, content delivery, energy and Video Quality Assessment (VQA) metrics and models, and AI techniques employed in video streaming. In addition, it conducts an in-depth state-of-the-art analysis focused on AI-driven approaches to enhance the energy efficiency of end-to-end aspects of video streaming systems (i.e., encoding, delivery network, playback, and VQA approaches). Finally, it discusses prospective research directions for developing AI-assisted energy-aware video streaming systems.
Read more6/5/2024
🗣️
0
Enhancing Quality of Experience in Telecommunication Networks: A Review of Frameworks and Machine Learning Algorithms
Parsa H. S. Panahi, Amir H. Jalilvand, Abolfazl Diyanat
The Internet service provider industry is currently experiencing intense competition as companies strive to provide top-notch services to their customers. Providers are introducing cutting-edge technologies to enhance service quality, understanding that their survival depends on the level of service they offer. However, evaluating service quality is a complex task. A crucial aspect of this evaluation lies in understanding user experience, which significantly impacts the success and reputation of a service or product. Ensuring a seamless and positive user experience is essential for attracting and retaining customers. To date, much effort has been devoted to developing tools for measuring Quality of Experience (QoE), which incorporate both subjective and objective criteria. These tools, available in closed and open-source formats, are accessible to organizations and contribute to improving user experience quality. This review article delves into recent research and initiatives aimed at creating frameworks for assessing user QoE. It also explores the integration of machine learning algorithms to enhance these tools for future advancements. Additionally, the article examines current challenges and envisions future directions in the development of these measurement tools.
Read more4/26/2024