A Survey of Anomaly Detection in In-Vehicle Networks

Read original: arXiv:2409.07505 - Published 9/14/2024 by Ovgu Ozdemir, M. Tuu{g}berk .Ic{s}yapar, P{i}nar Karagoz, Klaus Werner Schmidt, Demet Demir, N. Alpay Karagoz
Total Score

0

A Survey of Anomaly Detection in In-Vehicle Networks

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Provides a high-level summary of the paper's key findings and contributions
  • Covers the main topics addressed, such as anomaly detection, in-vehicle networks, and machine learning techniques
  • Highlights the importance and timeliness of this research area

Plain English Explanation

This paper surveys the field of anomaly detection in in-vehicle networks, which are the communication systems found in modern vehicles. As vehicles become more connected and automated, there is a growing need to detect and prevent cyber attacks that could compromise vehicle safety and security.

The paper examines how machine learning and deep learning techniques can be used to identify anomalies in the data transmitted over in-vehicle networks, known as the CAN bus. This could help detect and prevent attacks like masquerade attacks where an attacker pretends to be a legitimate component of the vehicle's systems.

Overall, the survey provides a comprehensive overview of the current state of anomaly detection research in this important and rapidly evolving field.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by introducing the concept of anomaly detection in the context of in-vehicle networks. It explains how the increasing connectivity and automation of modern vehicles has led to a growing need for robust security measures to protect against cyber attacks that could compromise vehicle safety and functionality.

The authors then provide an overview of common anomaly detection techniques, including statistical methods, machine learning, and deep learning approaches. They discuss the strengths and weaknesses of these different techniques and how they have been applied to the problem of anomaly detection in in-vehicle networks.

The bulk of the paper is dedicated to a systematic review of the existing research in this area. The authors analyze a wide range of studies, examining the data sources, feature engineering, and model architectures used, as well as the performance metrics and evaluation methodologies employed. They also highlight the key insights and findings from this body of work.

Throughout the paper, the authors identify several important research gaps and areas for further investigation. For example, they note the need for more comprehensive datasets, the challenge of detecting novel and sophisticated attacks, and the potential for interpretability and explainability in anomaly detection models.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough and well-structured survey of the current state of anomaly detection research in in-vehicle networks. The authors have done an admirable job of synthesizing a large and diverse body of literature, and their analysis of the key trends and insights is thoughtful and balanced.

One potential limitation of the paper is its focus on academic research, with less discussion of real-world deployment and practical challenges. While the authors do acknowledge the need for more comprehensive datasets and the difficulty of detecting novel attacks, they could have delved deeper into the practical challenges and limitations of existing approaches.

Additionally, the paper does not critically examine the ethical implications of this research, such as the potential for false positives, the risk of misuse, or the broader societal impacts of increased vehicle surveillance and security measures. As this field continues to evolve, it will be important for researchers to consider these broader societal considerations.

Conclusion

Overall, this paper serves as a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners working in the field of anomaly detection for in-vehicle networks. It provides a thorough and insightful overview of the current state of the art, while also highlighting key areas for future research and development. As vehicles become increasingly connected and automated, the importance of robust and reliable security measures will only continue to grow, making this an increasingly critical area of study.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

A Survey of Anomaly Detection in In-Vehicle Networks
Total Score

0

A Survey of Anomaly Detection in In-Vehicle Networks

Ovgu Ozdemir, M. Tuu{g}berk .Ic{s}yapar, P{i}nar Karagoz, Klaus Werner Schmidt, Demet Demir, N. Alpay Karagoz

Modern vehicles are equipped with Electronic Control Units (ECU) that are used for controlling important vehicle functions including safety-critical operations. ECUs exchange information via in-vehicle communication buses, of which the Controller Area Network (CAN bus) is by far the most widespread representative. Problems that may occur in the vehicle's physical parts or malicious attacks may cause anomalies in the CAN traffic, impairing the correct vehicle operation. Therefore, the detection of such anomalies is vital for vehicle safety. This paper reviews the research on anomaly detection for in-vehicle networks, more specifically for the CAN bus. Our main focus is the evaluation of methods used for CAN bus anomaly detection together with the datasets used in such analysis. To provide the reader with a more comprehensive understanding of the subject, we first give a brief review of related studies on time series-based anomaly detection. Then, we conduct an extensive survey of recent deep learning-based techniques as well as conventional techniques for CAN bus anomaly detection. Our comprehensive analysis delves into anomaly detection algorithms employed in in-vehicle networks, specifically focusing on their learning paradigms, inherent strengths, and weaknesses, as well as their efficacy when applied to CAN bus datasets. Lastly, we highlight challenges and open research problems in CAN bus anomaly detection.

Read more

9/14/2024

Total Score

0

Systematic Review: Anomaly Detection in Connected and Autonomous Vehicles

J. R. V. Solaas, N. Tuptuk, E. Mariconti

This systematic review focuses on anomaly detection for connected and autonomous vehicles. The initial database search identified 2160 articles, of which 203 were included in this review after rigorous screening and assessment. This study revealed that the most commonly used Artificial Intelligence (AI) algorithms employed in anomaly detection are neural networks like LSTM, CNN, and autoencoders, alongside one-class SVM. Most anomaly-based models were trained using real-world operational vehicle data, although anomalies, such as attacks and faults, were often injected artificially into the datasets. These models were evaluated mostly using five key evaluation metrics: recall, accuracy, precision, F1-score, and false positive rate. The most frequently used selection of evaluation metrics used for anomaly detection models were accuracy, precision, recall, and F1-score. This systematic review presents several recommendations. First, there is a need to incorporate multiple evaluation metrics to provide a comprehensive assessment of the anomaly detection models. Second, only a small proportion of the studies have made their models open source, indicating a need to share models publicly to facilitate collaboration within the research community, and to validate and compare findings effectively. Third, there is a need for benchmarking datasets with predefined anomalies or cyberattacks to test and improve the effectiveness of the proposed anomaly-based detection models. Furthermore, there is a need for future research to investigate the deployment of anomaly detection to a vehicle to assess its performance on the road. There is a notable lack of research done on intrusion detection systems using different protocols to CAN, such as Ethernet and FlexRay.

Read more

5/7/2024

AI-Driven Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) on the ROAD dataset: A Comparative Analysis for automotive Controller Area Network (CAN)
Total Score

0

AI-Driven Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) on the ROAD dataset: A Comparative Analysis for automotive Controller Area Network (CAN)

Lorenzo Guerra, Linhan Xu, Paolo Bellavista, Thomas Chapuis, Guillaume Duc, Pavlo Mozharovskyi, Van-Tam Nguyen

The integration of digital devices in modern vehicles has revolutionized automotive technology, enhancing safety and the overall driving experience. The Controller Area Network (CAN) bus is a central system for managing in-vehicle communication between the electronic control units (ECUs). However, the CAN protocol poses security challenges due to inherent vulnerabilities, lacking encryption and authentication, which, combined with an expanding attack surface, necessitates robust security measures. In response to this challenge, numerous Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) have been developed and deployed. Nonetheless, an open, comprehensive, and realistic dataset to test the effectiveness of such IDSs remains absent in the existing literature. This paper addresses this gap by considering the latest ROAD dataset, containing stealthy and sophisticated injections. The methodology involves dataset labelling and the implementation of both state-of-the-art deep learning models and traditional machine learning models to show the discrepancy in performance between the datasets most commonly used in the literature and the ROAD dataset, a more realistic alternative.

Read more

9/6/2024

Detecting Masquerade Attacks in Controller Area Networks Using Graph Machine Learning
Total Score

0

Detecting Masquerade Attacks in Controller Area Networks Using Graph Machine Learning

William Marfo, Pablo Moriano, Deepak K. Tosh, Shirley V. Moore

Modern vehicles rely on a myriad of electronic control units (ECUs) interconnected via controller area networks (CANs) for critical operations. Despite their ubiquitous use and reliability, CANs are susceptible to sophisticated cyberattacks, particularly masquerade attacks, which inject false data that mimic legitimate messages at the expected frequency. These attacks pose severe risks such as unintended acceleration, brake deactivation, and rogue steering. Traditional intrusion detection systems (IDS) often struggle to detect these subtle intrusions due to their seamless integration into normal traffic. This paper introduces a novel framework for detecting masquerade attacks in the CAN bus using graph machine learning (ML). We hypothesize that the integration of shallow graph embeddings with time series features derived from CAN frames enhances the detection of masquerade attacks. We show that by representing CAN bus frames as message sequence graphs (MSGs) and enriching each node with contextual statistical attributes from time series, we can enhance detection capabilities across various attack patterns compared to using only graph-based features. Our method ensures a comprehensive and dynamic analysis of CAN frame interactions, improving robustness and efficiency. Extensive experiments on the ROAD dataset validate the effectiveness of our approach, demonstrating statistically significant improvements in the detection rates of masquerade attacks compared to a baseline that uses only graph-based features, as confirmed by Mann-Whitney U and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests (p < 0.05).

Read more

8/13/2024