A Survey of Knowledge Tracing: Models, Variants, and Applications

Read original: arXiv:2105.15106 - Published 4/12/2024 by Shuanghong Shen, Qi Liu, Zhenya Huang, Yonghe Zheng, Minghao Yin, Minjuan Wang, Enhong Chen

🧪

Overview

Modern online education can automatically analyze student behavior data to provide intelligent educational services.
Knowledge Tracing (KT) is a fundamental task for analyzing student data, aiming to monitor students' evolving knowledge during problem-solving.
This survey investigates recent advancements in the rapidly growing field of KT.

Plain English Explanation

When students learn online, the system can collect a lot of data about how they interact with the course material and solve problems. Knowledge Tracing is the process of using this student behavior data to monitor and understand the students' evolving knowledge and skills as they progress through the course.

This paper provides an overview of the latest research in Knowledge Tracing. It first presents three main types of KT models, each using different technical approaches. Then it reviews many variations of these models that consider more complex learning assumptions.

The paper also discusses how KT is being applied in different educational scenarios. To help researchers and practitioners in this field, the authors have developed two open-source software libraries: one for downloading and preprocessing KT-related datasets, and one that provides implementations of the major KT models.

Finally, the paper suggests some potential directions for future research in this rapidly advancing area. The goal is to help both researchers and educators continue improving how online education systems can intelligently adapt to support student learning.

Technical Explanation

The paper first outlines three fundamental types of Knowledge Tracing models:

Classic KT Models: These use Bayesian networks to model student knowledge and update it based on their responses.
Deep KT Models: These use deep neural networks to more flexibly model complex relationships in student learning.
Sequential KT Models: These treat student learning as a sequential decision process and use reinforcement learning techniques.

The paper then reviews many extensions and variants of these fundamental models that incorporate additional factors, such as:

Skill Dependencies: Modeling how mastery of one skill affects learning of related skills
Learning Curves: Accounting for the typical learning progression of skills over time
Student Representations: Capturing individual student characteristics to personalize the model

The survey also covers how Knowledge Tracing is being applied in diverse educational scenarios, such as intelligent tutoring systems, online courses, and educational games.

To facilitate research and development in this area, the authors have created two open-source libraries: EduData for dataset access and preprocessing, and EduKTM for implementing major KT models.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive overview of the rapid progress in Knowledge Tracing research, covering both the technical advancements and the practical applications.

However, the authors acknowledge some limitations and areas for further work:

Most existing KT models make simplifying assumptions about student learning that may not fully capture the complexity of real-world educational settings.
Incorporating additional factors like student motivation, learning environment, and teaching strategies could further improve KT performance.
Validating KT models' real-world effectiveness in improving student outcomes is an ongoing challenge.

Additionally, some readers may question whether over-reliance on automated KT systems could negatively impact the human elements of teaching and learning. Careful consideration of the ethical implications is warranted as this technology becomes more widely adopted.

Conclusion

This survey paper provides a thorough review of the rapid advancements in Knowledge Tracing research, covering the technical evolution of KT models, their various applications, and the supporting software tools developed by the authors.

The research outlined in this paper has significant potential to enhance online education by enabling intelligent, personalized learning experiences tailored to each student's evolving knowledge and skills. As the field continues to progress, it will be important to carefully consider the limitations and ethical implications to ensure these technologies truly benefit students and support effective teaching practices.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🧪

A Survey of Knowledge Tracing: Models, Variants, and Applications

Shuanghong Shen, Qi Liu, Zhenya Huang, Yonghe Zheng, Minghao Yin, Minjuan Wang, Enhong Chen

Modern online education has the capacity to provide intelligent educational services by automatically analyzing substantial amounts of student behavioral data. Knowledge Tracing (KT) is one of the fundamental tasks for student behavioral data analysis, aiming to monitor students' evolving knowledge state during their problem-solving process. In recent years, a substantial number of studies have concentrated on this rapidly growing field, significantly contributing to its advancements. In this survey, we will conduct a thorough investigation of these progressions. Firstly, we present three types of fundamental KT models with distinct technical routes. Subsequently, we review extensive variants of the fundamental KT models that consider more stringent learning assumptions. Moreover, the development of KT cannot be separated from its applications, thereby we present typical KT applications in various scenarios. To facilitate the work of researchers and practitioners in this field, we have developed two open-source algorithm libraries: EduData that enables the download and preprocessing of KT-related datasets, and EduKTM that provides an extensible and unified implementation of existing mainstream KT models. Finally, we discuss potential directions for future research in this rapidly growing field. We hope that the current survey will assist both researchers and practitioners in fostering the development of KT, thereby benefiting a broader range of students.

4/12/2024

Personalized Knowledge Tracing through Student Representation Reconstruction and Class Imbalance Mitigation

Zhiyu Chen, Wei Ji, Jing Xiao, Zitao Liu

Knowledge tracing is a technique that predicts students' future performance by analyzing their learning process through historical interactions with intelligent educational platforms, enabling a precise evaluation of their knowledge mastery. Recent studies have achieved significant progress by leveraging powerful deep neural networks. These models construct complex input representations using questions, skills, and other auxiliary information but overlook individual student characteristics, which limits the capability for personalized assessment. Additionally, the available datasets in the field exhibit class imbalance issues. The models that simply predict all responses as correct without substantial effort can yield impressive accuracy. In this paper, we propose PKT, a novel approach for personalized knowledge tracing. PKT reconstructs representations from sequences of interactions with a tutoring platform to capture latent information about the students. Moreover, PKT incorporates focal loss to improve prioritize minority classes, thereby achieving more balanced predictions. Extensive experimental results on four publicly available educational datasets demonstrate the advanced predictive performance of PKT in comparison with 16 state-of-the-art models. To ensure the reproducibility of our research, the code is publicly available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/PKT.

9/12/2024

Language Model Can Do Knowledge Tracing: Simple but Effective Method to Integrate Language Model and Knowledge Tracing Task

Unggi Lee, Jiyeong Bae, Dohee Kim, Sookbun Lee, Jaekwon Park, Taekyung Ahn, Gunho Lee, Damji Stratton, Hyeoncheol Kim

Knowledge Tracing (KT) is a critical task in online learning for modeling student knowledge over time. Despite the success of deep learning-based KT models, which rely on sequences of numbers as data, most existing approaches fail to leverage the rich semantic information in the text of questions and concepts. This paper proposes Language model-based Knowledge Tracing (LKT), a novel framework that integrates pre-trained language models (PLMs) with KT methods. By leveraging the power of language models to capture semantic representations, LKT effectively incorporates textual information and significantly outperforms previous KT models on large benchmark datasets. Moreover, we demonstrate that LKT can effectively address the cold-start problem in KT by leveraging the semantic knowledge captured by PLMs. Interpretability of LKT is enhanced compared to traditional KT models due to its use of text-rich data. We conducted the local interpretable model-agnostic explanation technique and analysis of attention scores to interpret the model performance further. Our work highlights the potential of integrating PLMs with KT and paves the way for future research in KT domain.

6/11/2024

⚙️

Explainable Few-shot Knowledge Tracing

Haoxuan Li, Jifan Yu, Yuanxin Ouyang, Zhuang Liu, Wenge Rong, Juanzi Li, Zhang Xiong

Knowledge tracing (KT), aiming to mine students' mastery of knowledge by their exercise records and predict their performance on future test questions, is a critical task in educational assessment. While researchers achieved tremendous success with the rapid development of deep learning techniques, current knowledge tracing tasks fall into the cracks from real-world teaching scenarios. Relying heavily on extensive student data and solely predicting numerical performances differs from the settings where teachers assess students' knowledge state from limited practices and provide explanatory feedback. To fill this gap, we explore a new task formulation: Explainable Few-shot Knowledge Tracing. By leveraging the powerful reasoning and generation abilities of large language models (LLMs), we then propose a cognition-guided framework that can track the student knowledge from a few student records while providing natural language explanations. Experimental results from three widely used datasets show that LLMs can perform comparable or superior to competitive deep knowledge tracing methods. We also discuss potential directions and call for future improvements in relevant topics.

5/28/2024