Tactical Game-theoretic Decision-making with Homotopy Class Constraints

2406.13656

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 6/21/2024 by Michael Khayyat, Alessandro Zanardi, Stefano Arrigoni, Francesco Braghin

📉

Abstract

We propose a tactical homotopy-aware decision-making framework for game-theoretic motion planning in urban environments. We model urban driving as a generalized Nash equilibrium problem and employ a mixed-integer approach to tame the combinatorial aspect of motion planning. More specifically, by utilizing homotopy classes, we partition the high-dimensional solution space into finite, well-defined subregions. Each subregion (homotopy) corresponds to a high-level tactical decision, such as the passing order between pairs of players. The proposed formulation allows to find global optimal Nash equilibria in a computationally tractable manner by solving a mixed-integer quadratic program. Each homotopy decision is represented by a binary variable that activates different sets of linear collision avoidance constraints. This extra homotopic constraint allows to find solutions in a more efficient way (on a roundabout scenario on average 5-times faster). We experimentally validate the proposed approach on scenarios taken from the rounD dataset. Simulation-based testing in receding horizon fashion demonstrates the capability of the framework in achieving globally optimal solutions while yielding a 78% average decrease in the computational time with respect to an implementation without the homotopic constraints.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper presents a novel approach to homotopic path set planning for robot manipulation and navigation tasks.
  • It introduces a homotopy-aware multi-agent path planning algorithm that considers collision avoidance and occlusion awareness.
  • The authors also propose a game-theoretic framework for hierarchical decision-making under bounded rationality.
  • Additionally, the paper explores interaction-aware vehicle motion planning for collision avoidance.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers have developed new techniques to help robots and autonomous vehicles navigate complex environments more effectively. The homotopic path set planning approach allows robots to find the best routes by considering different possible paths, similar to how humans might imagine several routes to reach a destination. The homotopy-aware multi-agent path planning algorithm enables multiple robots or vehicles to coordinate their movements and avoid collisions, even in partially occluded environments.

The researchers also developed a game-theoretic framework to model hierarchical decision-making, where different agents (e.g., robots, vehicles) make choices based on their own limited information and rationality. This helps capture the complexity of real-world scenarios where agents may not have complete knowledge or the ability to make perfectly optimal decisions.

Additionally, the paper explores interaction-aware vehicle motion planning, which allows autonomous vehicles to anticipate and respond to the behaviors of other vehicles on the road, improving safety and efficiency.

Overall, these techniques could enable more robust and adaptable navigation for robots and autonomous vehicles, allowing them to handle a wider range of real-world challenges.

Technical Explanation

The homotopic path set planning approach proposed in the paper represents the robot's workspace as a topological space and uses homotopy theory to efficiently generate a set of candidate paths that the robot can follow. This allows the robot to consider multiple possible routes and choose the one that best satisfies the given constraints, such as obstacle avoidance and manipulation goals.

The homotopy-aware multi-agent path planning algorithm extends this concept to scenarios with multiple agents, enabling them to coordinate their movements and avoid collisions even in partially occluded environments. The algorithm considers the homotopic properties of the agents' paths, allowing them to navigate in a way that preserves the desired topological structure.

The game-theoretic framework for hierarchical decision-making under bounded rationality models the interactions between agents as a game, where each agent makes decisions based on their own limited information and cognitive capabilities. This framework allows for more realistic modeling of real-world scenarios, where agents may not have complete knowledge or the ability to make perfectly optimal decisions.

The interaction-aware vehicle motion planning approach enables autonomous vehicles to anticipate and respond to the behaviors of other vehicles on the road. By modeling the interactions between vehicles, the algorithm can generate motion plans that improve safety and efficiency, even in complex, dynamic environments.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a comprehensive set of techniques to address various challenges in robot and autonomous vehicle navigation. The researchers have made significant contributions to the field by incorporating concepts from topology, game theory, and multi-agent systems to develop more robust and adaptable planning algorithms.

One potential limitation of the homotopic path set planning approach is that it may be computationally expensive, especially in environments with a large number of obstacles. The researchers acknowledge this and propose optimization techniques to improve efficiency. Further research could explore ways to balance the trade-off between planning flexibility and computational complexity.

The game-theoretic framework for hierarchical decision-making under bounded rationality is a promising approach, but its practical implementation may face challenges in accurately modeling the cognitive capabilities and decision-making processes of real-world agents. Validating the model's assumptions and understanding the impact of bounded rationality on the overall system performance would be an important area for future study.

While the interaction-aware vehicle motion planning technique shows promise for improving safety and efficiency, its effectiveness may depend on the accuracy of the models used to predict other vehicles' behaviors. Addressing uncertainty and dealing with unpredictable agent behaviors could be an important direction for further research.

Overall, the paper makes valuable contributions to the field of robot and autonomous vehicle navigation, and the proposed techniques have the potential to significantly improve the capabilities and performance of these systems in real-world applications.

Conclusion

The researchers have developed a comprehensive set of techniques to address various challenges in robot and autonomous vehicle navigation. The homotopic path set planning, homotopy-aware multi-agent path planning, game-theoretic decision-making, and interaction-aware vehicle motion planning approaches presented in this paper have the potential to significantly improve the capabilities and performance of these systems in real-world applications.

While the paper identifies some limitations and areas for future research, the overall contributions are highly valuable and could lead to more robust, adaptable, and efficient navigation solutions for robots and autonomous vehicles. These advancements have important implications for various domains, such as manufacturing, transportation, and disaster response, where the safe and reliable operation of these systems is critical.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Homotopic Path Set Planning for Robot Manipulation and Navigation

Homotopic Path Set Planning for Robot Manipulation and Navigation

Jing Huang, Yunxi Tang, Kwok Wai Samuel Au

YC

0

Reddit

0

This paper addresses path set planning that yields important applications in robot manipulation and navigation such as path generation for deformable object keypoints and swarms. A path set refers to the collection of finite agent paths to represent the overall spatial path of a group of keypoints or a swarm, whose collective properties meet spatial and topological constraints. As opposed to planning a single path, simultaneously planning multiple paths with constraints poses nontrivial challenges in complex environments. This paper presents a systematic planning pipeline for homotopic path sets, a widely applicable path set class in robotics. An extended visibility check condition is first proposed to attain a sparse passage distribution amidst dense obstacles. Passage-aware optimal path planning compatible with sampling-based planners is then designed for single path planning with adjustable costs. Large accessible free space for path set accommodation can be achieved by the planned path while having a sufficiently short path length. After specifying the homotopic properties of path sets, path set generation based on deformable path transfer is proposed in an efficient centralized manner. The effectiveness of these methods is validated by extensive simulated and experimental results.

Read more

6/6/2024

Homotopy-Aware Multi-Agent Path Planning in Plane

Homotopy-Aware Multi-Agent Path Planning in Plane

Kazumi Kasaura

YC

0

Reddit

0

We propose an efficient framework using the Dynnikov coordinates for homotopy-aware multi-agent path planning in the plane. We developed a method to generate multiple homotopically distinct solutions of multi-agent path planning problem in the plane by combining our framework with revised prioritized planning and proved its completeness in the grid world under specific assumptions. Experimentally, we demonstrated the scalability of our method for the number of agents. We also confirmed experimentally that homotopy-aware planning contributes to avoiding locally optimal solutions when searching for low-cost trajectories for a swarm of agents in a continuous environment.

Read more

5/31/2024

Game-theoretic Occlusion-Aware Motion Planning: an Efficient Hybrid-Information Approach

Game-theoretic Occlusion-Aware Motion Planning: an Efficient Hybrid-Information Approach

Kushagra Gupta, David Fridovich-Keil

YC

0

Reddit

0

We present a novel algorithm for game-theoretic trajectory planning, tailored for settings in which agents can only observe one another in specific regions of the state space. Such problems arise naturally in the context of multi-robot navigation, where occlusions due to environment geometry naturally mask agents' view of one another. In this paper, we formalize these settings as dynamic games with a hybrid information structure, which interleaves so-called open-loop periods (in which agents cannot observe one another) with feedback periods (with full state observability). We present two main contributions. First, we study a canonical variant of these hybrid information games in which agents' dynamics are linear, and objectives are convex and quadratic. Here, we build upon classical solution methods for the open-loop and feedback variants of these games to derive an algorithm for the hybrid information case that matches the cubic runtime of the classical settings. Second, we consider a far broader class of problems in which agents' dynamics are nonlinear, and objectives are nonquadratic; we reduce these problems to sequences of hybrid information linear-quadratic games and empirically demonstrate that iteratively solving these simpler problems with the proposed algorithm yields reliable convergence to approximate Nash equilibria through simulation studies of overtaking and intersection traffic scenarios.

Read more

6/18/2024

Solution Concepts in Hierarchical Games under Bounded Rationality with Applications to Autonomous Driving

Atrisha Sarkar, Krzysztof Czarnecki

YC

0

Reddit

0

With autonomous vehicles (AV) set to integrate further into regular human traffic, there is an increasing consensus on treating AV motion planning as a multi-agent problem. However, the traditional game-theoretic assumption of complete rationality is too strong for human driving, and there is a need for understanding human driving as a emph{bounded rational} activity through a behavioural game-theoretic lens. To that end, we adapt four metamodels of bounded rational behaviour: three based on Quantal level-k and one based on Nash equilibrium with quantal errors. We formalize the different solution concepts that can be applied in the context of hierarchical games, a framework used in multi-agent motion planning, for the purpose of creating game theoretic models of driving behaviour. Furthermore, based on a contributed dataset of human driving at a busy urban intersection with a total of approximately 4k agents and 44k decision points, we evaluate the behaviour models on the basis of model fit to naturalistic data, as well as their predictive capacity. Our results suggest that among the behaviour models evaluated, at the level of maneuvers, modeling driving behaviour as an adaptation of the Quantal level-k model with level-0 behaviour modelled as pure rule-following provides the best fit to naturalistic driving behaviour. At the level of trajectories, bounds sampling of actions and a maxmax non-strategic models is the most accurate within the set of models in comparison. We also find a significant impact of situational factors on the performance of behaviour models.

Read more

6/6/2024