There is HOPE to Avoid HiPPOs for Long-memory State Space Models
0
🛠️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- State-space models (SSMs) with linear, time-invariant (LTI) systems are effective for learning long sequences.
- However, these models face several challenges:
- Requiring specific initializations of the system matrices to achieve state-of-the-art performance.
- Needing training of the state matrices on a logarithmic scale with very small learning rates to prevent instabilities.
- Requiring the model to have exponentially decaying memory to ensure an asymptotically stable LTI system.
Plain English Explanation
State-space models (SSMs) that use linear, time-invariant (LTI) systems are known to be effective at learning long sequences of data. These models work by maintaining an internal "state" that represents the current state of the system, and they use this state to make predictions about the future. However, these LTI-based SSMs face several challenges:
-
Initialization: They require carefully designed initializations of the system matrices (the mathematical representations of the system) in order to achieve the best possible performance. If the initializations are not done correctly, the model may not work as well.
-
Training: To prevent the model from becoming unstable during training, the state matrices need to be trained using very small learning rates on a logarithmic scale. This means the training process can be slow and difficult.
-
Memory: The LTI-based SSMs need to have an exponentially decaying memory in order to ensure the system is stable over time. This means the model's "memory" of past inputs decreases rapidly, which can limit its ability to learn long-term dependencies.
Technical Explanation
To address these issues, the researchers in this paper view SSMs through the lens of Hankel operator theory, which provides a unified theory for the initialization and training of SSMs. Building on this theory, they develop a new parameterization scheme called HOPE (Hankel Operator Parameterized Embeddings) for LTI systems.
The HOPE approach utilizes Markov parameters within Hankel operators to allow for random initializations of the LTI systems and improve training stability. Importantly, this also provides the SSMs with non-decaying memory capabilities, addressing the third challenge mentioned earlier.
The model efficiently implements these innovations by nonuniformly sampling the transfer functions of LTI systems, and it requires fewer parameters compared to canonical SSMs. When evaluated on Long-Range Arena (LRA) tasks, an SSM parameterized by Hankel operators demonstrated improved performance compared to HiPPO-initialized models like S4 and S4D.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a novel approach to addressing the challenges of LTI-based SSMs, leveraging Hankel operator theory to enable more stable initializations, training, and memory capabilities. This is a significant contribution to the field of sequence modeling, as it could lead to more reliable and effective SSMs for a variety of applications.
However, the paper does not extensively discuss the computational complexity or inference time of the HOPE-based SSM compared to other models. Additionally, the paper only evaluates the model on a limited set of tasks, and it would be valuable to see how it performs on a wider range of benchmarks, especially in real-world settings.
Conclusion
This research presents a promising approach to improving the performance and reliability of state-space models by addressing key challenges in the initialization, training, and memory characteristics of LTI-based systems. The HOPE parameterization scheme, grounded in Hankel operator theory, offers a novel way to overcome the limitations of traditional SSMs and could have important implications for sequence modeling tasks across various domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
0
There is HOPE to Avoid HiPPOs for Long-memory State Space Models
Annan Yu, Michael W. Mahoney, N. Benjamin Erichson
State-space models (SSMs) that utilize linear, time-invariant (LTI) systems are known for their effectiveness in learning long sequences. However, these models typically face several challenges: (i) they require specifically designed initializations of the system matrices to achieve state-of-the-art performance, (ii) they require training of state matrices on a logarithmic scale with very small learning rates to prevent instabilities, and (iii) they require the model to have exponentially decaying memory in order to ensure an asymptotically stable LTI system. To address these issues, we view SSMs through the lens of Hankel operator theory, which provides us with a unified theory for the initialization and training of SSMs. Building on this theory, we develop a new parameterization scheme, called HOPE, for LTI systems that utilizes Markov parameters within Hankel operators. This approach allows for random initializations of the LTI systems and helps to improve training stability, while also provides the SSMs with non-decaying memory capabilities. Our model efficiently implements these innovations by nonuniformly sampling the transfer functions of LTI systems, and it requires fewer parameters compared to canonical SSMs. When benchmarked against HiPPO-initialized models such as S4 and S4D, an SSM parameterized by Hankel operators demonstrates improved performance on Long-Range Arena (LRA) tasks. Moreover, we use a sequential CIFAR-10 task with padded noise to empirically corroborate our SSM's long memory capacity.
Read more5/24/2024
👁️
0
HiPPO-Prophecy: State-Space Models can Provably Learn Dynamical Systems in Context
Federico Arangath Joseph, Kilian Konstantin Haefeli, Noah Liniger, Caglar Gulcehre
This work explores the in-context learning capabilities of State Space Models (SSMs) and presents, to the best of our knowledge, the first theoretical explanation of a possible underlying mechanism. We introduce a novel weight construction for SSMs, enabling them to predict the next state of any dynamical system after observing previous states without parameter fine-tuning. This is accomplished by extending the HiPPO framework to demonstrate that continuous SSMs can approximate the derivative of any input signal. Specifically, we find an explicit weight construction for continuous SSMs and provide an asymptotic error bound on the derivative approximation. The discretization of this continuous SSM subsequently yields a discrete SSM that predicts the next state. Finally, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our parameterization empirically. This work should be an initial step toward understanding how sequence models based on SSMs learn in context.
Read more7/22/2024
0
Longhorn: State Space Models are Amortized Online Learners
Bo Liu, Rui Wang, Lemeng Wu, Yihao Feng, Peter Stone, Qiang Liu
The most fundamental capability of modern AI methods such as Large Language Models (LLMs) is the ability to predict the next token in a long sequence of tokens, known as ``sequence modeling. Although the Transformers model is the current dominant approach to sequence modeling, its quadratic computational cost with respect to sequence length is a significant drawback. State-space models (SSMs) offer a promising alternative due to their linear decoding efficiency and high parallelizability during training. However, existing SSMs often rely on seemingly ad hoc linear recurrence designs. In this work, we explore SSM design through the lens of online learning, conceptualizing SSMs as meta-modules for specific online learning problems. This approach links SSM design to formulating precise online learning objectives, with state transition rules derived from optimizing these objectives. Based on this insight, we introduce a novel deep SSM architecture based on the implicit update for optimizing an online regression objective. Our experimental results show that our models outperform state-of-the-art SSMs, including the Mamba model, on standard sequence modeling benchmarks and language modeling tasks.
Read more8/2/2024
0
StableSSM: Alleviating the Curse of Memory in State-space Models through Stable Reparameterization
Shida Wang, Qianxiao Li
In this paper, we investigate the long-term memory learning capabilities of state-space models (SSMs) from the perspective of parameterization. We prove that state-space models without any reparameterization exhibit a memory limitation similar to that of traditional RNNs: the target relationships that can be stably approximated by state-space models must have an exponential decaying memory. Our analysis identifies this curse of memory as a result of the recurrent weights converging to a stability boundary, suggesting that a reparameterization technique can be effective. To this end, we introduce a class of reparameterization techniques for SSMs that effectively lift its memory limitations. Besides improving approximation capabilities, we further illustrate that a principled choice of reparameterization scheme can also enhance optimization stability. We validate our findings using synthetic datasets, language models and image classifications.
Read more6/6/2024