Think Before You Act: Decision Transformers with Working Memory
2305.16338
0
0
👀
Abstract
Decision Transformer-based decision-making agents have shown the ability to generalize across multiple tasks. However, their performance relies on massive data and computation. We argue that this inefficiency stems from the forgetting phenomenon, in which a model memorizes its behaviors in parameters throughout training. As a result, training on a new task may deteriorate the model's performance on previous tasks. In contrast to LLMs' implicit memory mechanism, the human brain utilizes distributed memory storage, which helps manage and organize multiple skills efficiently, mitigating the forgetting phenomenon. Inspired by this, we propose a working memory module to store, blend, and retrieve information for different downstream tasks. Evaluation results show that the proposed method improves training efficiency and generalization in Atari games and Meta-World object manipulation tasks. Moreover, we demonstrate that memory fine-tuning further enhances the adaptability of the proposed architecture.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Decision Transformer-based agents can generalize across multiple tasks, but their performance relies on massive data and computation.
- This inefficiency is attributed to the "forgetting phenomenon," where a model memorizes behaviors in its parameters, leading to deterioration in performance on previous tasks when trained on new tasks.
- In contrast, the human brain utilizes a distributed memory storage mechanism, which helps manage and organize multiple skills efficiently, mitigating the forgetting phenomenon.
- Inspired by this, the researchers propose a working memory module to store, blend, and retrieve information for different downstream tasks.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a problem with current decision-making AI agents that use a type of model called a "Decision Transformer." These agents can learn to perform multiple tasks, but they require a lot of data and computational power to do so.
The researchers argue that this inefficiency is caused by the way these models "remember" what they've learned. As the model is trained on new tasks, it tends to "forget" how to do the earlier tasks it was trained on. This is known as the "forgetting phenomenon."
In contrast, the human brain has a different way of storing and organizing information, which helps us learn and remember multiple skills more efficiently. The researchers were inspired by this and came up with a new module, called a "working memory module," that can help AI agents store, combine, and retrieve information for different tasks, avoiding the forgetting problem.
Technical Explanation
The proposed method involves incorporating a working memory module into the Decision Transformer architecture. This module is designed to store and blend information from different tasks, allowing the model to adapt and learn new tasks without forgetting previous ones.
The researchers evaluate their approach on Atari games and Meta-World object manipulation tasks, and the results show that it improves training efficiency and generalization compared to the standard Decision Transformer. They also demonstrate that "memory fine-tuning" can further enhance the adaptability of the proposed architecture.
Critical Analysis
While the proposed method shows promising results, the paper does not address some potential limitations. For example, the working memory module's scalability and the complexity of maintaining and updating multiple task representations are not thoroughly explored. Additionally, the paper does not discuss how the approach might perform on more complex, real-world tasks beyond the Atari and Meta-World environments.
Nonetheless, the researchers' inspiration from human memory mechanisms and their attempt to address the forgetting phenomenon in Decision Transformer-based agents are commendable. Further research in this direction could lead to more efficient and adaptable decision-making AI systems.
Conclusion
The paper presents a novel approach to improving the performance and efficiency of Decision Transformer-based decision-making agents. By incorporating a working memory module inspired by human memory mechanisms, the researchers have demonstrated a way to mitigate the forgetting phenomenon and enhance the agents' ability to learn and adapt to new tasks without compromising their performance on previous tasks. While the proposed method has room for improvement, it represents a valuable step towards more efficient and versatile AI decision-making systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
Empowering Working Memory for Large Language Model Agents
Jing Guo, Nan Li, Jianchuan Qi, Hang Yang, Ruiqiao Li, Yuzhen Feng, Si Zhang, Ming Xu
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive linguistic capabilities. However, a key limitation persists in their lack of human-like memory faculties. LLMs exhibit constrained memory retention across sequential interactions, hindering complex reasoning. This paper explores the potential of applying cognitive psychology's working memory frameworks, to enhance LLM architecture. The limitations of traditional LLM memory designs are analyzed, including their isolation of distinct dialog episodes and lack of persistent memory links. To address this, an innovative model is proposed incorporating a centralized Working Memory Hub and Episodic Buffer access to retain memories across episodes. This architecture aims to provide greater continuity for nuanced contextual reasoning during intricate tasks and collaborative scenarios. While promising, further research is required into optimizing episodic memory encoding, storage, prioritization, retrieval, and security. Overall, this paper provides a strategic blueprint for developing LLM agents with more sophisticated, human-like memory capabilities, highlighting memory mechanisms as a vital frontier in artificial general intelligence.
5/29/2024
Extended Mind Transformers
Phoebe Klett, Thomas Ahle
0
0
Pre-trained language models demonstrate general intelligence and common sense, but long inputs quickly become a bottleneck for memorizing information at inference time. We resurface a simple method, Memorizing Transformers (Wu et al., 2022), that gives the model access to a bank of pre-computed memories. We show that it is possible to fix many of the shortcomings of the original method, such as the need for fine-tuning, by critically assessing how positional encodings should be updated for the keys and values retrieved. This intuitive method uses the model's own key/query system to select and attend to the most relevant memories at each generation step, rather than using external embeddings. We demonstrate the importance of external information being retrieved in a majority of decoder layers, contrary to previous work. We open source a new counterfactual long-range retrieval benchmark, and show that Extended Mind Transformers outperform today's state of the art by 6% on average.
6/5/2024
Remembering Transformer for Continual Learning
Yuwei Sun, Ippei Fujisawa, Arthur Juliani, Jun Sakuma, Ryota Kanai
0
0
Neural networks encounter the challenge of Catastrophic Forgetting (CF) in continual learning, where new task learning interferes with previously learned knowledge. Existing data fine-tuning and regularization methods necessitate task identity information during inference and cannot eliminate interference among different tasks, while soft parameter sharing approaches encounter the problem of an increasing model parameter size. To tackle these challenges, we propose the Remembering Transformer, inspired by the brain's Complementary Learning Systems (CLS). Remembering Transformer employs a mixture-of-adapters architecture and a generative model-based novelty detection mechanism in a pretrained Transformer to alleviate CF. Remembering Transformer dynamically routes task data to the most relevant adapter with enhanced parameter efficiency based on knowledge distillation. We conducted extensive experiments, including ablation studies on the novelty detection mechanism and model capacity of the mixture-of-adapters, in a broad range of class-incremental split tasks and permutation tasks. Our approach demonstrated SOTA performance surpassing the second-best method by 15.90% in the split tasks, reducing the memory footprint from 11.18M to 0.22M in the five splits CIFAR10 task.
5/17/2024
Memoria: Resolving Fateful Forgetting Problem through Human-Inspired Memory Architecture
Sangjun Park, JinYeong Bak
0
0
Making neural networks remember over the long term has been a longstanding issue. Although several external memory techniques have been introduced, most focus on retaining recent information in the short term. Regardless of its importance, information tends to be fatefully forgotten over time. We present Memoria, a memory system for artificial neural networks, drawing inspiration from humans and applying various neuroscientific and psychological theories. The experimental results prove the effectiveness of Memoria in the diverse tasks of sorting, language modeling, and classification, surpassing conventional techniques. Engram analysis reveals that Memoria exhibits the primacy, recency, and temporal contiguity effects which are characteristics of human memory.
6/11/2024