Token Spammers, Rug Pulls, and SniperBots: An Analysis of the Ecosystem of Tokens in Ethereum and the Binance Smart Chain (BNB)

Overview

• The researchers conducted a longitudinal analysis of the BNB Smart Chain and Ethereum blockchains from their inception to March 2022.
• They studied the ecosystem of tokens and liquidity pools, comparing the two blockchains.
• The study estimated the lifetime of tokens, finding that around 60% are active for less than a day.
• The researchers also discovered that 1% of addresses create an anomalous number of tokens (between 20% and 25%).
• The paper presents an investigation of exit scam fraud and its prevalence on both blockchains.
• The researchers found that token spammers use short-lived tokens as disposable tokens to perpetrate these frauds serially.
• The paper also identifies a new type of trader bot involved in these activities and quantifies its presence in the exit scam operations.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers looked at the BNB Smart Chain and Ethereum blockchains over time, from when they were first created up until March 2022. They wanted to understand the ecosystems of the tokens and liquidity pools on these two blockchains, and see how they are similar or different.

One of the key findings is that about 60% of the tokens only exist for less than a day. This suggests that these tokens are being created and used for very short-term purposes, rather than as long-term, stable projects. The researchers also found that a small number of addresses (just 1%) are responsible for creating a large portion of the tokens (between 20% and 25%).

The paper also explores a type of fraud called an "exit scam." This is when the creators of a token suddenly withdraw all the funds and disappear, leaving investors with worthless tokens. The researchers found that token spammers are using these short-lived tokens as a way to carry out these exit scams repeatedly.

Additionally, the researchers identified a new kind of automated trading program, or "bot," that is involved in these exit scam activities. They were able to detect the presence of these bots and measure how much they are participating in the exit scam operations.

Technical Explanation

The researchers performed a longitudinal analysis of the BNB Smart Chain and Ethereum blockchains, tracking the ecosystems of tokens and liquidity pools from the inception of each blockchain up to March 2022. They studied the characteristics and behaviors of the tokens, including their lifetime, to uncover insights about the dynamics of these blockchain networks.

One key finding was that approximately 60% of the tokens on these blockchains have a lifetime of less than one day. This suggests that a significant portion of the token activity is focused on very short-term projects or potentially malicious activities, rather than long-term, sustainable use cases.

Further analysis revealed that a small fraction (1%) of addresses are responsible for creating a disproportionately high number of tokens, ranging from 20% to 25% of the total token supply. This concentration of token creation activity in a small subset of addresses raises questions about the motivations and behaviors of these prolific token creators.

The researchers also investigated the presence of exit scam fraud, where token creators suddenly withdraw all the funds and abandon the project, leaving investors with worthless tokens. They found that token spammers leverage these short-lived tokens as disposable instruments to perpetrate these exit scams repeatedly.

Additionally, the paper identifies a new type of trader bot involved in the exit scam operations and quantifies its activity across the two blockchain ecosystems. The detection and analysis of these automated trading programs provides insights into the sophisticated strategies employed by bad actors in these blockchain networks.

Critical Analysis

The researchers provide a comprehensive longitudinal analysis of the BNB Smart Chain and Ethereum blockchains, offering valuable insights into the dynamics and potential issues within these ecosystems. However, the study is limited to the timeframe up to March 2022, and it would be informative to see if the trends and patterns observed have continued or evolved since then.

While the paper highlights the prevalence of short-lived tokens and the concentration of token creation activity in a small number of addresses, it does not delve deeply into the underlying motivations and incentives that drive these behaviors. Further research could explore the socioeconomic factors and potential vulnerabilities in the blockchain infrastructure that enable such activities to thrive.

Additionally, the paper's identification of a new type of trader bot involved in exit scam operations raises concerns about the evolving sophistication of malicious actors in blockchain networks. Continued monitoring and analysis of these automated trading strategies, as well as the development of more robust detection and mitigation mechanisms, could be crucial for enhancing the security and integrity of these emerging technologies.

Conclusion

This longitudinal analysis of the BNB Smart Chain and Ethereum blockchains provides valuable insights into the dynamics and potential issues within these ecosystems. The researchers uncovered concerning trends, such as the prevalence of short-lived tokens and the concentration of token creation activity in a small subset of addresses, which suggest the presence of malicious activities like exit scams.

The paper's identification of a new type of trader bot involved in these exit scam operations highlights the need for ongoing vigilance and the development of more advanced detection and mitigation strategies. As blockchain technologies continue to evolve and gain mainstream adoption, addressing these security challenges will be crucial for fostering trust and ensuring the long-term viability of these decentralized systems.

The findings presented in this research serve as a call to action for blockchain developers, regulators, and the broader community to collaborate in strengthening the resilience and integrity of these emerging technologies. By understanding and addressing the underlying vulnerabilities, the potential for blockchain-based innovation and adoption can be better realized.