Toward an Artist-Centred AI

Overview

• The paper discusses the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) on the arts, focusing on the principles, practices, and tools that should guide the use of AI in artistic creativity.
• The authors propose a framework of atomic attributes that summarize the values deemed important for artistically pertinent AI, such as being unexpected, diversified, affordant, and evolvable.
• The framework was developed by examining the challenges that AI poses to art production, distribution, consumption, and monetization, considering the differentiating potentials of AI beyond the purely technical ontology.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at how artificial intelligence (AI) is affecting the world of art. As AI becomes more advanced, it's starting to have a big impact on things like how art is made, shared, enjoyed, and even paid for. The authors wanted to figure out what principles, practices, and tools should guide the use of AI in the arts to make sure it's a positive change.

They came up with a framework that lists the key values they think AI should have to be truly helpful for artistic creativity. These include being unexpected, diversified, affordant, and evolvable. In other words, AI in the arts should be able to come up with new and surprising ideas, offer a wide range of options, be accessible to artists, and be able to adapt and grow over time.

The authors looked at the challenges that AI creates for art, like how it might change the way art is made, shared, and paid for. They also considered how AI can be used in unique ways, beyond just the technical side of things. The goal was to figure out what kind of AI would be best suited for the arts and help artists thrive.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a framework for the use of AI in the arts, focusing on the principles, practices, and tools that should guide the development and application of AI in artistic creativity. The authors contextualise the notions of suitability and desirability of AI in the arts by examining the challenges that AI poses to art production, distribution, consumption, and monetization.

The framework is composed of a set of atomic attributes that summarize the values of AI deemed important for artistic creativity. These attributes include being unexpected, diversified, affordant, and evolvable. The authors argue that artistically pertinent AI should possess these qualities, going beyond the purely technical ontology and considering the differentiating potentials of AI.

The paper's approach involved exploring the challenges that AI presents to the arts, such as those discussed in related works like AI Art is Theft: Labour Extraction & Exploitation, Foregrounding Artist Opinions: A Survey Study on Transparency & Ownership, and Towards an Ethical & Inclusive Implementation of AI. By considering these challenges and the unique capabilities of AI, the authors propose a framework to guide the development of AI systems that can positively impact artistic creativity.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thoughtful and nuanced perspective on the role of AI in the arts, acknowledging the complex challenges and opportunities that emerge from the intersection of these two domains. The proposed framework of atomic attributes, such as being unexpected, diversified, affordant, and evolvable, offers a valuable lens through which to evaluate the suitability and desirability of AI-based tools and systems for artistic creativity.

One potential limitation of the research is the breadth of the topic, as the authors attempt to address the broad impact of AI on art production, distribution, consumption, and monetization. This could lead to a somewhat surface-level treatment of certain aspects, and the authors may have benefited from a more focused exploration of specific use cases or artistic disciplines.

Additionally, while the framework provides a conceptual foundation, the practical implementation and empirical validation of these attributes could be an area for further research. The paper does not delve deeply into how these principles can be translated into concrete design guidelines or evaluation criteria for AI-powered artistic tools and systems.

Nevertheless, the paper makes a valuable contribution by bringing the discussion of AI and the arts into the mainstream discourse and offering a starting point for more nuanced, multidisciplinary dialogues on the topic. The authors' emphasis on unexpected, diversified, affordant, and evolvable AI characteristics encourages a forward-thinking and adaptable approach to the integration of these technologies within the arts.

Conclusion

This paper presents a framework for guiding the development and application of AI in the arts, emphasizing the importance of principles such as being unexpected, diversified, affordant, and evolvable. By examining the challenges that AI poses to art production, distribution, consumption, and monetization, and considering the unique capabilities of AI beyond the purely technical, the authors have proposed a set of values that they believe should underpin artistically pertinent AI systems.

The framework offers a valuable starting point for discussions on the responsible and beneficial integration of AI within the arts, encouraging a shift in perspective from viewing AI as a disruptive force to considering it as a tool that can enhance and empower artistic creativity. As the influence of AI continues to grow, this research provides a foundation for further exploration and collaboration between technologists, artists, and policymakers to ensure that the development of AI aligns with the values and needs of the artistic community.