Towards Complex Ontology Alignment using Large Language Models
2404.10329
0
0
Abstract
Ontology alignment, a critical process in the Semantic Web for detecting relationships between different ontologies, has traditionally focused on identifying so-called simple 1-to-1 relationships through class labels and properties comparison. The more practically useful exploration of more complex alignments remains a hard problem to automate, and as such is largely underexplored, i.e. in application practice it is usually done manually by ontology and domain experts. Recently, the surge in Natural Language Processing (NLP) capabilities, driven by advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs), presents new opportunities for enhancing ontology engineering practices, including ontology alignment tasks. This paper investigates the application of LLM technologies to tackle the complex ontology alignment challenge. Leveraging a prompt-based approach and integrating rich ontology content so-called modules our work constitutes a significant advance towards automating the complex alignment task.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of large language models (LLMs) for aligning complex ontologies, which are formal representations of knowledge that can capture intricate relationships between concepts.
- The researchers propose a novel approach that leverages the semantic understanding and reasoning capabilities of LLMs to identify and resolve complex correspondences between ontologies, going beyond simple one-to-one mappings.
- The paper presents the architecture and key components of their system, as well as the results of experiments on benchmark datasets, demonstrating the potential of LLMs for tackling the challenging task of complex ontology alignment.
Plain English Explanation
Ontologies are like dictionaries for the digital world, containing detailed information about different concepts and how they are related to each other. Aligning, or matching, these ontologies from different sources can be a complex task, as the relationships between concepts can be quite intricate.
This research explores the use of large language models, which are AI systems trained on vast amounts of text data, to help with this challenge. The researchers believe that these powerful language models can understand the semantic connections between concepts in a way that goes beyond simple one-to-one mappings, allowing them to identify and resolve more complex correspondences between ontologies.
The paper outlines their approach, which involves using the LLM as a kind of "oracle" to provide insights and guidance for the ontology alignment process. The researchers then describe the architecture of their system and present the results of experiments on benchmark datasets, showing the potential of this method for tackling the challenging problem of complex ontology alignment.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a novel approach for complex ontology alignment using large language models. The key idea is to leverage the semantic understanding and reasoning capabilities of LLMs to identify and resolve complex correspondences between ontologies, going beyond simple one-to-one mappings.
The system architecture involves a modular design, with the LLM acting as a central "oracle" that provides insights and guidance for the alignment process. This includes using the LLM to:
- Encode the ontology concepts and their relationships into vector representations.
- Identify potential complex correspondences between the ontologies, such as many-to-many mappings or hierarchical relationships.
- Reason about the semantic connections between concepts to resolve ambiguities and refine the alignment.
The researchers evaluated their approach on benchmark datasets for complex ontology alignment, comparing it to state-of-the-art methods. The results demonstrate the potential of LLMs for this task, with the system achieving significant improvements in alignment quality compared to traditional techniques.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling exploration of the use of LLMs for tackling the challenge of complex ontology alignment. The researchers acknowledge the limitations of existing approaches, which often struggle with more intricate relationships between concepts, and make a strong case for the potential of LLMs to address this gap.
One potential area for further research mentioned in the paper is the need to better understand the "black box" nature of LLMs and how to improve the interpretability and explainability of the alignment decisions. Advances in this area could help practitioners better trust and validate the system's outputs.
Additionally, the researchers note that their current approach relies on a modular design, with the LLM acting as a central component. An interesting avenue for future work could be to explore more integrated approaches where the LLM is more seamlessly embedded into the overall ontology alignment pipeline.
Overall, this paper provides a strong foundation for using LLMs to support ontology matching and modelling tasks, and the researchers have identified several promising directions for further research and development in this area.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach for leveraging the power of large language models to tackle the challenge of complex ontology alignment. By using the LLM as a central "oracle" to provide semantic insights and guidance, the researchers have demonstrated the potential of this method to achieve significant improvements in alignment quality compared to traditional techniques.
The modular system architecture and the promising experimental results highlight the value of this research for the broader field of ontology engineering and knowledge representation. As LLMs continue to evolve and become more widely adopted, the ideas and techniques explored in this paper could pave the way for more advanced and intelligent ontology management systems that can handle the nuances and complexities of real-world knowledge domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
LLMs4OM: Matching Ontologies with Large Language Models
Hamed Babaei Giglou, Jennifer D'Souza, Felix Engel, Soren Auer
0
0
Ontology Matching (OM), is a critical task in knowledge integration, where aligning heterogeneous ontologies facilitates data interoperability and knowledge sharing. Traditional OM systems often rely on expert knowledge or predictive models, with limited exploration of the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs). We present the LLMs4OM framework, a novel approach to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs in OM tasks. This framework utilizes two modules for retrieval and matching, respectively, enhanced by zero-shot prompting across three ontology representations: concept, concept-parent, and concept-children. Through comprehensive evaluations using 20 OM datasets from various domains, we demonstrate that LLMs, under the LLMs4OM framework, can match and even surpass the performance of traditional OM systems, particularly in complex matching scenarios. Our results highlight the potential of LLMs to significantly contribute to the field of OM.
4/24/2024
Large language models as oracles for instantiating ontologies with domain-specific knowledge
Giovanni Ciatto, Andrea Agiollo, Matteo Magnini, Andrea Omicini
0
0
Background. Endowing intelligent systems with semantic data commonly requires designing and instantiating ontologies with domain-specific knowledge. Especially in the early phases, those activities are typically performed manually by human experts possibly leveraging on their own experience. The resulting process is therefore time-consuming, error-prone, and often biased by the personal background of the ontology designer. Objective. To mitigate that issue, we propose a novel domain-independent approach to automatically instantiate ontologies with domain-specific knowledge, by leveraging on large language models (LLMs) as oracles. Method. Starting from (i) an initial schema composed by inter-related classes andproperties and (ii) a set of query templates, our method queries the LLM multi- ple times, and generates instances for both classes and properties from its replies. Thus, the ontology is automatically filled with domain-specific knowledge, compliant to the initial schema. As a result, the ontology is quickly and automatically enriched with manifold instances, which experts may consider to keep, adjust, discard, or complement according to their own needs and expertise. Contribution. We formalise our method in general way and instantiate it over various LLMs, as well as on a concrete case study. We report experiments rooted in the nutritional domain where an ontology of food meals and their ingredients is semi-automatically instantiated from scratch, starting from a categorisation of meals and their relationships. There, we analyse the quality of the generated ontologies and compare ontologies attained by exploiting different LLMs. Finally, we provide a SWOT analysis of the proposed method.
4/8/2024
š¬
On the Use of Large Language Models to Generate Capability Ontologies
Luis Miguel Vieira da Silva, Aljosha Kocher, Felix Gehlhoff, Alexander Fay
0
0
Capability ontologies are increasingly used to model functionalities of systems or machines. The creation of such ontological models with all properties and constraints of capabilities is very complex and can only be done by ontology experts. However, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown that they can generate machine-interpretable models from natural language text input and thus support engineers / ontology experts. Therefore, this paper investigates how LLMs can be used to create capability ontologies. We present a study with a series of experiments in which capabilities with varying complexities are generated using different prompting techniques and with different LLMs. Errors in the generated ontologies are recorded and compared. To analyze the quality of the generated ontologies, a semi-automated approach based on RDF syntax checking, OWL reasoning, and SHACL constraints is used. The results of this study are very promising because even for complex capabilities, the generated ontologies are almost free of errors.
4/30/2024
Towards Ontology-Enhanced Representation Learning for Large Language Models
Francesco Ronzano, Jay Nanavati
0
0
Taking advantage of the widespread use of ontologies to organise and harmonize knowledge across several distinct domains, this paper proposes a novel approach to improve an embedding-Large Language Model (embedding-LLM) of interest by infusing the knowledge formalized by a reference ontology: ontological knowledge infusion aims at boosting the ability of the considered LLM to effectively model the knowledge domain described by the infused ontology. The linguistic information (i.e. concept synonyms and descriptions) and structural information (i.e. is-a relations) formalized by the ontology are utilized to compile a comprehensive set of concept definitions, with the assistance of a powerful generative LLM (i.e. GPT-3.5-turbo). These concept definitions are then employed to fine-tune the target embedding-LLM using a contrastive learning framework. To demonstrate and evaluate the proposed approach, we utilize the biomedical disease ontology MONDO. The results show that embedding-LLMs enhanced by ontological disease knowledge exhibit an improved capability to effectively evaluate the similarity of in-domain sentences from biomedical documents mentioning diseases, without compromising their out-of-domain performance.
6/3/2024