Towards Interpretable Sequence Continuation: Analyzing Shared Circuits in Large Language Models

Overview

• Transformers, powerful language models, often have complex architectures that can be difficult to interpret.
• Recent research has aimed to reverse-engineer transformers into more human-readable representations called "circuits" that implement specific algorithmic functions.
• This paper extends this research by analyzing and comparing circuits for similar sequence continuation tasks, including increasing sequences of Arabic numerals, number words, and months.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on understanding the inner workings of transformer language models. Transformers, like GPT-2 and LLaMA-2-7B, have complex architectures that can be difficult for humans to interpret. However, recent research has found a way to reverse-engineer these models into more understandable representations called "circuits."

These circuits essentially break down the transformers' decision-making processes into smaller, algorithmic components. In this paper, the researchers analyze and compare the circuits responsible for completing similar sequence-based tasks, such as continuing sequences of Arabic numerals, number words, and months. By doing this, they can identify the key computational building blocks that these models use to recognize and predict patterns in these types of sequences.

The core insight is that semantically related tasks, like continuing number and date sequences, rely on shared circuit subgraphs (or subcomponents) that play analogous roles. This suggests that transformers develop reusable "circuit components" to handle certain types of linguistic and logical reasoning. Understanding these shared computational structures can help researchers better predict and control the behavior of these models, identify errors, and work towards more robust and interpretable language AI.

Technical Explanation

The researchers extend previous work on reverse-engineering transformers into interpretable "circuits" by analyzing and comparing the circuits for similar sequence continuation tasks. Specifically, they examine the circuits responsible for completing sequences of Arabic numerals, number words, and months in both GPT-2 Small and LLaMA-2-7B models.

Through their analysis, the researchers identify a key sub-circuit in both models that is responsible for detecting sequence members and predicting the next member. Interestingly, they find that semantically related sequence tasks (e.g., numbers vs. months) rely on shared circuit subgraphs with analogous roles.

Furthermore, the researchers show that this sequence-focused sub-circuit also has effects on various math-related prompts, such as continued sequences of Spanish number words and months, as well as solving natural language word problems. This suggests that transformers develop reusable "circuit components" to handle certain types of logical and linguistic reasoning.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a valuable contribution to the growing field of "mechanistic interpretability" for transformer language models. By documenting the shared computational structures underlying related sequence tasks, the researchers offer insights that could lead to better model behavior predictions, identification of errors, and safer editing procedures.

That said, the paper is limited in its scope, focusing only on a narrow set of sequence-based tasks. While the findings are intriguing, it's unclear how generalizable they are to the full breadth of transformer capabilities. Additional research would be needed to explore the circuit-level organization of transformers across a wider range of linguistic and reasoning tasks.

Another potential area for further investigation is the extent to which these shared circuit components are truly "reusable" in a modular sense. The paper suggests that transformers develop generic building blocks for certain types of processing, but the degree of flexibility and recombination of these components remains an open question.

Overall, this work represents an important step towards a mechanistic understanding of transformer language models, which could ultimately lead to more robust, aligned, and interpretable AI systems. However, continued research and careful validation will be necessary to fully realize the potential of this approach.

Conclusion

This paper provides a valuable contribution to the emerging field of "mechanistic interpretability" for transformer language models. By reverse-engineering GPT-2 Small and LLaMA-2-7B into interpretable "circuits," the researchers were able to identify a key sub-circuit responsible for detecting and predicting members of sequence-based tasks, such as continuing Arabic numerals, number words, and months.

Crucially, the researchers found that semantically related sequence tasks rely on shared circuit subgraphs with analogous roles. This suggests that transformers develop reusable "circuit components" to handle certain types of logical and linguistic reasoning, which could enable better model behavior predictions, error identification, and safer editing procedures.

While the scope of the paper is limited, the insights it provides represent an important step towards a mechanistic understanding of transformer language models. Continued research in this area could lead to the development of more robust, aligned, and interpretable AI systems that can be better understood and controlled by humans.