TraceMesh: Scalable and Streaming Sampling for Distributed Traces
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces TraceMesh, a scalable and streaming sampling technique for distributed trace data analysis.
- TraceMesh aims to address the challenges of processing and understanding the massive amounts of trace data generated by modern cloud-based services.
- The key ideas behind TraceMesh include a mesh-based sampling approach, adaptive sampling algorithms, and streaming data processing capabilities.
Plain English Explanation
When cloud-based services run, they generate huge amounts of trace data that can be used to understand how the services are performing and where issues might be occurring. However, this trace data can be overwhelming to process and analyze, especially as the services become more complex and distributed.
TraceMesh aims to make it easier to work with this trace data by using a clever sampling technique. Instead of trying to process all of the trace data, TraceMesh selects a representative sample that can provide insights without requiring the analysis of every single piece of data. This sampling is done in a way that ensures the most important information is captured, even as the trace data changes over time.
The key innovation in TraceMesh is the use of a "mesh" structure to organize the trace data and determine what should be sampled. This mesh approach allows TraceMesh to adapt to changes in the data and ensure that the most relevant information is always being analyzed. TraceMesh also has the ability to process the trace data in a continuous, streaming fashion, rather than having to wait for all the data to be collected before starting the analysis.
Overall, TraceMesh provides a scalable and efficient way to work with the massive amounts of trace data generated by modern cloud services, allowing developers and operators to more effectively monitor and understand the performance of their systems.
Technical Explanation
TraceMesh addresses the challenge of processing and understanding distributed trace data at scale by proposing a novel mesh-based sampling approach. The key technical elements of TraceMesh include:
-
Mesh-based Sampling: TraceMesh organizes the trace data into a mesh structure, where each node in the mesh represents a part of the distributed system. The sampling process selectively chooses which nodes to include in the analysis, based on their importance and the changes occurring in the system over time. This mesh-based sampling approach helps to ensure that the most relevant information is captured, even as the system evolves.
-
Adaptive Sampling Algorithms: TraceMesh employs adaptive sampling algorithms that dynamically adjust the sampling rate based on the characteristics of the trace data. This helps to ensure that the sampling process remains effective as the system changes, without requiring manual tuning or reconfiguration.
-
Streaming Data Processing: TraceMesh is designed to process trace data in a continuous, streaming fashion, rather than requiring all the data to be collected before analysis can begin. This streaming data processing capability allows for more timely insights and reduces the storage and computational requirements of the system.
The paper presents experimental results that demonstrate the effectiveness of TraceMesh in capturing the key insights from distributed trace data while significantly reducing the computational overhead compared to traditional, non-sampling-based approaches. The authors also discuss the potential limitations of their approach, such as the impact of sampling on the accuracy of certain types of analysis, and suggest areas for future research to address these challenges.
Critical Analysis
The TraceMesh approach presented in this paper represents a significant advancement in the field of distributed trace data analysis. By introducing a mesh-based sampling technique and adaptive algorithms, the authors have addressed the scalability challenges that have historically plagued this domain. The ability to process trace data in a streaming fashion is also a valuable contribution, as it enables more timely insights and reduces the resource requirements of the system.
However, the paper does highlight some potential limitations and areas for further research. For example, the authors note that the accuracy of certain types of analysis, such as those focused on rare events or specific performance bottlenecks, may be impacted by the sampling process. Addressing these accuracy trade-offs and ensuring that critical information is not lost due to sampling will be an important area of future work.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a detailed discussion of the computational and storage requirements of the TraceMesh system, which could be a concern for organizations with limited resources. Further research exploring the resource efficiency of the approach, as well as its ability to scale to the largest cloud-based service deployments, would be valuable.
Overall, the TraceMesh paper represents an important step forward in the field of distributed trace data analysis. By combining innovative sampling techniques with streaming data processing capabilities, the authors have developed a promising approach for making sense of the massive amounts of trace data generated by modern cloud-based services. As the authors continue to refine and expand upon this work, it will be interesting to see how TraceMesh evolves and is adopted by the broader community.
Conclusion
The TraceMesh paper introduces a novel approach for scalable and streaming sampling of distributed trace data, addressing a critical challenge faced by operators of modern cloud-based services. By organizing the trace data into a mesh structure and employing adaptive sampling algorithms, TraceMesh is able to capture the key insights from this data while significantly reducing the computational overhead compared to traditional, non-sampling-based approaches.
The streaming data processing capabilities of TraceMesh further enhance its practicality, enabling more timely insights and reducing the storage requirements of the system. While the paper highlights some potential limitations, such as the impact of sampling on the accuracy of certain types of analysis, the overall contribution of TraceMesh represents an important advancement in the field of distributed trace data analysis.
As cloud-based services continue to grow in scale and complexity, tools like TraceMesh will become increasingly essential for developers and operators seeking to monitor, understand, and optimize the performance of their systems. The innovative techniques introduced in this paper pave the way for further research and development in this critical area of cloud computing infrastructure.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
TraceMesh: Scalable and Streaming Sampling for Distributed Traces
Zhuangbin Chen, Zhihan Jiang, Yuxin Su, Michael R. Lyu, Zibin Zheng
Distributed tracing serves as a fundamental element in the monitoring of cloud-based and datacenter systems. It provides visibility into the full lifecycle of a request or operation across multiple services, which is essential for understanding system dependencies and performance bottlenecks. To mitigate computational and storage overheads, most tracing frameworks adopt a uniform sampling strategy, which inevitably captures overlapping and redundant information. More advanced methods employ learning-based approaches to bias the sampling toward more informative traces. However, existing methods fall short of considering the high-dimensional and dynamic nature of trace data, which is essential for the production deployment of trace sampling. To address these practical challenges, in this paper we present TraceMesh, a scalable and streaming sampler for distributed traces. TraceMesh employs Locality-Sensitivity Hashing (LSH) to improve sampling efficiency by projecting traces into a low-dimensional space while preserving their similarity. In this process, TraceMesh accommodates previously unseen trace features in a unified and streamlined way. Subsequently, TraceMesh samples traces through evolving clustering, which dynamically adjusts the sampling decision to avoid over-sampling of recurring traces. The proposed method is evaluated with trace data collected from both open-source microservice benchmarks and production service systems. Experimental results demonstrate that TraceMesh outperforms state-of-the-art methods by a significant margin in both sampling accuracy and efficiency.
Read more6/12/2024
0
An Online Probabilistic Distributed Tracing System
M. Toslali, S. Qasim, S. Parthasarathy, F. A. Oliveira, H. Huang, G. Stringhini, Z. Liu, A. K. Coskun
Distributed tracing has become a fundamental tool for diagnosing performance issues in the cloud by recording causally ordered, end-to-end workflows of request executions. However, tracing in production workloads can introduce significant overheads due to the extensive instrumentation needed for identifying performance variations. This paper addresses the trade-off between the cost of tracing and the utility of the spans within that trace through Astraea, an online probabilistic distributed tracing system. Astraea is based on our technique that combines online Bayesian learning and multi-armed bandit frameworks. This formulation enables Astraea to effectively steer tracing towards the useful instrumentation needed for accurate performance diagnosis. Astraea localizes performance variations using only 10-28% of available instrumentation, markedly reducing tracing overhead, storage, compute costs, and trace analysis time.
Read more5/27/2024
0
Pattern or Artifact? Interactively Exploring Embedding Quality with TRACE
Edith Heiter, Liesbet Martens, Ruth Seurinck, Martin Guilliams, Tijl De Bie, Yvan Saeys, Jefrey Lijffijt
This paper presents TRACE, a tool to analyze the quality of 2D embeddings generated through dimensionality reduction techniques. Dimensionality reduction methods often prioritize preserving either local neighborhoods or global distances, but insights from visual structures can be misleading if the objective has not been achieved uniformly. TRACE addresses this challenge by providing a scalable and extensible pipeline for computing both local and global quality measures. The interactive browser-based interface allows users to explore various embeddings while visually assessing the pointwise embedding quality. The interface also facilitates in-depth analysis by highlighting high-dimensional nearest neighbors for any group of points and displaying high-dimensional distances between points. TRACE enables analysts to make informed decisions regarding the most suitable dimensionality reduction method for their specific use case, by showing the degree and location where structure is preserved in the reduced space.
Read more6/21/2024
🧠
0
Distributed Matrix-Based Sampling for Graph Neural Network Training
Alok Tripathy, Katherine Yelick, Aydin Buluc
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) offer a compact and computationally efficient way to learn embeddings and classifications on graph data. GNN models are frequently large, making distributed minibatch training necessary. The primary contribution of this paper is new methods for reducing communication in the sampling step for distributed GNN training. Here, we propose a matrix-based bulk sampling approach that expresses sampling as a sparse matrix multiplication (SpGEMM) and samples multiple minibatches at once. When the input graph topology does not fit on a single device, our method distributes the graph and use communication-avoiding SpGEMM algorithms to scale GNN minibatch sampling, enabling GNN training on much larger graphs than those that can fit into a single device memory. When the input graph topology (but not the embeddings) fits in the memory of one GPU, our approach (1) performs sampling without communication, (2) amortizes the overheads of sampling a minibatch, and (3) can represent multiple sampling algorithms by simply using different matrix constructions. In addition to new methods for sampling, we introduce a pipeline that uses our matrix-based bulk sampling approach to provide end-to-end training results. We provide experimental results on the largest Open Graph Benchmark (OGB) datasets on $128$ GPUs, and show that our pipeline is $2.5times$ faster than Quiver (a distributed extension to PyTorch-Geometric) on a $3$-layer GraphSAGE network. On datasets outside of OGB, we show a $8.46times$ speedup on $128$ GPUs in per-epoch time. Finally, we show scaling when the graph is distributed across GPUs and scaling for both node-wise and layer-wise sampling algorithms.
Read more4/22/2024