Training robust and generalizable quantum models

Read original: arXiv:2311.11871 - Published 5/24/2024 by Julian Berberich, Daniel Fink, Daniel Pranji'c, Christian Tutschku, Christian Holm

🏋️

Overview

Explores the relationship between adversarial robustness and generalization in quantum machine learning models
Derives parameter-dependent Lipschitz bounds to analyze the impact of data encoding on robustness and generalization
Proposes a practical strategy for training robust and generalizable quantum models by regularizing the Lipschitz bound
Finds that trainable data encodings are crucial for systematically adapting robustness and generalization during training

Plain English Explanation

Adversarial robustness and the ability to generalize well are both important characteristics of reliable machine learning models. This paper examines these properties in the context of quantum machine learning, using a mathematical concept called Lipschitz bounds.

The researchers show that the way the input data is encoded, or represented, in the quantum model has a significant impact on how robust the model is to small changes in the data. They also find that the data encoding affects how well the model can generalize, or apply what it has learned to new, unseen data.

The paper suggests a practical strategy for training quantum models to be both robust and generalizable. The key is to regularize, or control, the Lipschitz bound during the training process. This helps the model learn encodings that make it more resilient to data perturbations and better able to perform well on new examples.

Interestingly, the researchers also discover that for quantum models with fixed, non-trainable data encodings (a common setup in this field), the Lipschitz bound cannot be adjusted. This means that trainable encodings are essential if you want to systematically improve a quantum model's robustness and generalization abilities during training.

Technical Explanation

The paper derives parameter-dependent Lipschitz bounds for quantum machine learning models with trainable data encodings. Lipschitz continuity is a mathematical property that relates small changes in the input to bounded changes in the output. The researchers show that the norm, or size, of the data encoding has a crucial impact on the model's robustness against adversarial perturbations of the input data.

They also derive a bound on the model's generalization error, which explicitly involves the parameters of the data encoding. This suggests that by regularizing the Lipschitz bound during training, one can improve both the robustness and the generalization performance of the quantum model.

In contrast, for quantum models with fixed, non-trainable data encodings (a common setup), the researchers find that the Lipschitz bound cannot be influenced by tuning the model parameters. This underscores the importance of having trainable data encodings if you want to systematically adapt the robustness and generalization of a quantum machine learning model during the training process.

The paper supports these theoretical findings with numerical experiments that illustrate the practical implications of their work.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis of the relationship between adversarial robustness and generalization in quantum machine learning models. The derivation of parameter-dependent Lipschitz bounds is a novel contribution that offers insights into the role of data encoding in these two crucial model properties.

One potential limitation of the research is that it focuses primarily on the theoretical analysis, and the numerical experiments are relatively limited in scope. Further empirical validation of the proposed training strategy on larger-scale quantum machine learning problems would help strengthen the practical relevance of the findings.

Additionally, the paper does not delve into the specific challenges of implementing trainable data encodings in quantum hardware, which could involve additional technical hurdles. Exploring the feasibility and potential bottlenecks of this approach in real-world quantum computing setups would be an important next step.

Overall, this research represents an important step forward in understanding the fundamental tradeoffs and design considerations for building robust and generalizable quantum machine learning models. The insights provided can inform the development of more reliable and trustworthy quantum AI systems in the future.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel theoretical analysis of the relationship between adversarial robustness and generalization in quantum machine learning models. The key findings are that the data encoding used in the quantum model has a crucial impact on both its resilience to small input changes and its ability to generalize to new examples.

The researchers demonstrate that by regularizing the Lipschitz bound during training, one can improve the robustness and generalization performance of quantum models. Importantly, they also show that this approach is only feasible with trainable data encodings, as models with fixed, non-trainable encodings cannot have their Lipschitz bound systematically adjusted.

These insights can inform the development of more reliable and trustworthy quantum AI systems, which will be essential as the field of quantum machine learning continues to evolve. By better understanding the fundamental tradeoffs and design considerations for building robust and generalizable quantum models, researchers can work towards realizing the full potential of quantum computing for a wide range of real-world applications.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏋️

Training robust and generalizable quantum models

Julian Berberich, Daniel Fink, Daniel Pranji'c, Christian Tutschku, Christian Holm

Adversarial robustness and generalization are both crucial properties of reliable machine learning models. In this paper, we study these properties in the context of quantum machine learning based on Lipschitz bounds. We derive parameter-dependent Lipschitz bounds for quantum models with trainable encoding, showing that the norm of the data encoding has a crucial impact on the robustness against data perturbations. Further, we derive a bound on the generalization error which explicitly involves the parameters of the data encoding. Our theoretical findings give rise to a practical strategy for training robust and generalizable quantum models by regularizing the Lipschitz bound in the cost. Further, we show that, for fixed and non-trainable encodings, as those frequently employed in quantum machine learning, the Lipschitz bound cannot be influenced by tuning the parameters. Thus, trainable encodings are crucial for systematically adapting robustness and generalization during training. The practical implications of our theoretical findings are illustrated with numerical results.

5/24/2024

Certifiably Robust Encoding Schemes

Aman Saxena, Tom Wollschlager, Nicola Franco, Jeanette Miriam Lorenz, Stephan Gunnemann

Quantum machine learning uses principles from quantum mechanics to process data, offering potential advances in speed and performance. However, previous work has shown that these models are susceptible to attacks that manipulate input data or exploit noise in quantum circuits. Following this, various studies have explored the robustness of these models. These works focus on the robustness certification of manipulations of the quantum states. We extend this line of research by investigating the robustness against perturbations in the classical data for a general class of data encoding schemes. We show that for such schemes, the addition of suitable noise channels is equivalent to evaluating the mean value of the noiseless classifier at the smoothed data, akin to Randomized Smoothing from classical machine learning. Using our general framework, we show that suitable additions of phase-damping noise channels improve empirical and provable robustness for the considered class of encoding schemes.

8/6/2024

👁️

A Comparative Analysis of Adversarial Robustness for Quantum and Classical Machine Learning Models

Maximilian Wendlinger, Kilian Tscharke, Pascal Debus

Quantum machine learning (QML) continues to be an area of tremendous interest from research and industry. While QML models have been shown to be vulnerable to adversarial attacks much in the same manner as classical machine learning models, it is still largely unknown how to compare adversarial attacks on quantum versus classical models. In this paper, we show how to systematically investigate the similarities and differences in adversarial robustness of classical and quantum models using transfer attacks, perturbation patterns and Lipschitz bounds. More specifically, we focus on classification tasks on a handcrafted dataset that allows quantitative analysis for feature attribution. This enables us to get insight, both theoretically and experimentally, on the robustness of classification networks. We start by comparing typical QML model architectures such as amplitude and re-upload encoding circuits with variational parameters to a classical ConvNet architecture. Next, we introduce a classical approximation of QML circuits (originally obtained with Random Fourier Features sampling but adapted in this work to fit a trainable encoding) and evaluate this model, denoted Fourier network, in comparison to other architectures. Our findings show that this Fourier network can be seen as a middle ground on the quantum-classical boundary. While adversarial attacks successfully transfer across this boundary in both directions, we also show that regularization helps quantum networks to be more robust, which has direct impact on Lipschitz bounds and transfer attacks.

4/26/2024

⛏️

Generalization with data-dependent quantum geometry

Tobias Haug, M. S. Kim

Generalization is the ability of machine learning models to make accurate predictions on new data by learning from training data. However, understanding generalization of quantum machine learning models has been a major challenge. Here, we introduce the data quantum Fisher information metric (DQFIM). It describes the capacity of variational quantum algorithms depending on variational ansatz, training data and their symmetries. We apply the DQFIM to quantify circuit parameters and training data needed to successfully train and generalize. Using the dynamical Lie algebra, we explain how to generalize using a low number of training states. Counter-intuitively, breaking symmetries of the training data can help to improve generalization. Finally, we find that out-of-distribution generalization, where training and testing data are drawn from different data distributions, can be better than using the same distribution. Our work provides a useful framework to explore the power of quantum machine learning models.

7/30/2024