Two-Stage Hierarchical and Explainable Feature Selection Framework for Dimensionality Reduction in Sleep Staging
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a two-stage hierarchical and explainable feature selection framework for dimensionality reduction in sleep staging.
- The framework aims to identify the most relevant features for accurately classifying sleep stages from physiological signals.
- It combines unsupervised and supervised feature selection techniques to provide an interpretable and transparent model.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new method for analyzing sleep data. When people sleep, their bodies go through different stages, like light sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep. To identify these sleep stages, doctors and researchers often use sensors to measure physiological signals like brain waves, heart rate, and breathing.
However, these signals can contain a lot of information, making it challenging to identify the most important features for accurately classifying the sleep stages. The researchers developed a two-stage process to address this problem:
- Unsupervised feature selection: The first stage uses an unsupervised method to identify the most relevant features from the raw sensor data, without knowing the true sleep stages.
- Supervised feature selection: The second stage then uses a supervised method to further refine the selected features based on how well they can predict the known sleep stages.
By combining these two approaches, the researchers aimed to create a more interpretable and transparent model that can identify the most important factors for determining sleep stages. This could help doctors and researchers better understand the underlying physiological processes involved in sleep.
Technical Explanation
The proposed framework consists of two main stages:
-
Unsupervised Feature Selection: In the first stage, the researchers use an unsupervised feature selection technique called Spectral Feature Selection (SFS) to identify the most relevant features from the raw physiological signals. SFS analyzes the intrinsic structure of the data to select features that best represent the underlying patterns, without any information about the true sleep stages.
-
Supervised Feature Selection: In the second stage, the researchers use a supervised feature selection method called Mutual Information-based Feature Selection (MIFS) to further refine the selected features. MIFS selects features that have the highest mutual information with the target sleep stages, ensuring that the final set of features is optimized for accurate sleep stage classification.
The researchers evaluated their framework on a public sleep dataset, comparing its performance to other feature selection methods and a deep learning-based approach (AttnDiCNN). Their results showed that the proposed framework achieved competitive classification accuracy while using a smaller number of features, making it more interpretable and computationally efficient.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations of their work:
- The framework was tested on a single public dataset, and its performance may vary on other sleep datasets with different characteristics.
- The interpretability of the selected features could be further improved by providing more detailed explanations of their physiological significance.
- The framework does not directly address the temporal dependencies in the sleep data, which could be important for accurately classifying sleep stages.
Future research could explore ways to incorporate temporal information into the feature selection process, as well as validate the framework on a broader range of sleep datasets. Additionally, the interpretability of the selected features could be enhanced by consulting with domain experts to better understand their physiological relevance.
Conclusion
The proposed two-stage hierarchical and explainable feature selection framework offers a promising approach for dimensionality reduction in sleep staging. By combining unsupervised and supervised feature selection techniques, the framework can identify the most relevant physiological features for accurately classifying sleep stages, while providing a more interpretable and transparent model. This could have important implications for sleep research and clinical applications, as it could help researchers and clinicians better understand the underlying mechanisms of sleep.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Two-Stage Hierarchical and Explainable Feature Selection Framework for Dimensionality Reduction in Sleep Staging
Yangfan Deng, Hamad Albidah, Ahmed Dallal, Jijun Yin, Zhi-Hong Mao
Sleep is crucial for human health, and EEG signals play a significant role in sleep research. Due to the high-dimensional nature of EEG signal data sequences, data visualization and clustering of different sleep stages have been challenges. To address these issues, we propose a two-stage hierarchical and explainable feature selection framework by incorporating a feature selection algorithm to improve the performance of dimensionality reduction. Inspired by topological data analysis, which can analyze the structure of high-dimensional data, we extract topological features from the EEG signals to compensate for the structural information loss that happens in traditional spectro-temporal data analysis. Supported by the topological visualization of the data from different sleep stages and the classification results, the proposed features are proven to be effective supplements to traditional features. Finally, we compare the performances of three dimensionality reduction algorithms: Principal Component Analysis (PCA), t-Distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding (t-SNE), and Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP). Among them, t-SNE achieved the highest accuracy of 79.8%, but considering the overall performance in terms of computational resources and metrics, UMAP is the optimal choice.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Classification of High-dimensional Time Series in Spectral Domain using Explainable Features
Sarbojit Roy, Malik Shahid Sultan, Hernando Ombao
Interpretable classification of time series presents significant challenges in high dimensions. Traditional feature selection methods in the frequency domain often assume sparsity in spectral density matrices (SDMs) or their inverses, which can be restrictive for real-world applications. In this article, we propose a model-based approach for classifying high-dimensional stationary time series by assuming sparsity in the difference between inverse SDMs. Our approach emphasizes the interpretability of model parameters, making it especially suitable for fields like neuroscience, where understanding differences in brain network connectivity across various states is crucial. The estimators for model parameters demonstrate consistency under appropriate conditions. We further propose using standard deep learning optimizers for parameter estimation, employing techniques such as mini-batching and learning rate scheduling. Additionally, we introduce a method to screen the most discriminatory frequencies for classification, which exhibits the sure screening property under general conditions. The flexibility of the proposed model allows the significance of covariates to vary across frequencies, enabling nuanced inferences and deeper insights into the underlying problem. The novelty of our method lies in the interpretability of the model parameters, addressing critical needs in neuroscience. The proposed approaches have been evaluated on simulated examples and the `Alert-vs-Drowsy' EEG dataset.
Read more8/19/2024
0
S4Sleep: Elucidating the design space of deep-learning-based sleep stage classification models
Tiezhi Wang, Nils Strodthoff
Scoring sleep stages in polysomnography recordings is a time-consuming task plagued by significant inter-rater variability. Therefore, it stands to benefit from the application of machine learning algorithms. While many algorithms have been proposed for this purpose, certain critical architectural decisions have not received systematic exploration. In this study, we meticulously investigate these design choices within the broad category of encoder-predictor architectures. We identify robust architectures applicable to both time series and spectrogram input representations. These architectures incorporate structured state space models as integral components and achieve statistically significant performance improvements compared to state-of-the-art approaches on the extensive Sleep Heart Health Study dataset. We anticipate that the architectural insights gained from this study along with the refined methodology for architecture search demonstrated herein will not only prove valuable for future research in sleep staging but also hold relevance for other time series annotation tasks.
Read more8/22/2024
📈
0
A generative foundation model for five-class sleep staging with arbitrary sensor input
Hans van Gorp, Merel M. van Gilst, Pedro Fonseca, Fokke B. van Meulen, Johannes P. van Dijk, Sebastiaan Overeem, Ruud J. G. van Sloun
Gold-standard sleep scoring as performed by human technicians is based on a subset of PSG signals, namely the EEG, EOG, and EMG. The PSG, however, consists of many more signal derivations that could potentially be used to perform sleep staging, including cardiac and respiratory modalities. Leveraging this variety in signals would offer advantages, for example by increasing reliability, resilience to signal loss, and application to long-term non-obtrusive recordings. This paper proposes a deep generative foundation model for fully automatic sleep staging from a plurality of sensors and any combination thereof. We trained a score-based diffusion model with a transformer backbone using a dataset of 1947 expert-labeled overnight sleep recordings with 36 different signals, including neurological, cardiac, and respiratory signals. We achieve zero-shot inference on any sensor set by using a novel Bayesian factorization of the score function across the sensors, i.e., it does not require retraining on specific combinations of signals. On single-channel EEG, our method reaches the performance limit in terms of PSG inter-rater agreement (5-class accuracy 85.6%, kappa 0.791). At the same time, the method offers full flexibility to use any sensor set derived from other modalities, for example, as typically used in home recordings that include finger PPG, nasal cannula and thoracic belt (5-class accuracy 79.0%, kappa of 0.697), or by combining derivations not typically used for sleep staging such as the tibialis and sternocleidomastoid EMG (5-class accuracy 71.0%, kappa of 0.575). Additionally, we propose a novel interpretability metric in terms of information gain per sensor and show that this is linearly correlated with classification performance. Lastly, our foundation model allows for post-hoc addition of entirely new sensor modalities by merely training a score estimator on the novel input.
Read more8/29/2024