Understanding Adam Optimizer via Online Learning of Updates: Adam is FTRL in Disguise

Overview

• This paper provides a new perspective on the theoretical understanding of the Adam optimizer, a popular algorithm used in machine learning.
• The authors show that Adam can be viewed as a principled online learning framework called Follow-the-Regularized-Leader (FTRL), which has been studied extensively in the online learning literature.
• By connecting Adam to FTRL, the authors are able to shed light on the benefits of Adam's algorithmic components from an online learning perspective.

Plain English Explanation

The Adam optimizer is a widely used algorithm in machine learning, but its inner workings are not fully understood. Most existing analyses show that Adam's performance can be achieved by simpler, non-adaptive algorithms like Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD).

In this paper, the authors take a different approach. They view the design of a good optimizer as the design of a good online learner. Online learning is a framework where an algorithm makes a series of decisions and receives feedback, gradually improving its performance.

The key insight is that Adam corresponds to a specific type of online learner called Follow-the-Regularized-Leader (FTRL). By making this connection, the authors can analyze Adam's algorithmic components, such as its adaptive learning rates, from the perspective of online learning theory.

This new viewpoint helps explain why Adam can outperform simpler optimizers like SGD in certain scenarios. It also suggests ways to further improve the algorithm by drawing on the extensive research in online learning and adaptive gradient methods.

Technical Explanation

The authors build on the recent work of Cutkosky et al. (2023), which introduced the framework of online learning of updates/increments. In this framework, the goal is to design an optimizer that chooses updates or increments based on an online learner.

The key observation is that Adam can be viewed as a specific instance of this framework, where the online learner is the Follow-the-Regularized-Leader (FTRL) algorithm. FTRL is a well-studied online learning algorithm that has been shown to have strong theoretical guarantees.

By making this connection, the authors are able to analyze the benefits of Adam's algorithmic components, such as its adaptive learning rates, from the perspective of online learning theory. They show that Adam's performance can be explained by the properties of the FTRL algorithm, which suggests ways to further improve the optimizer.

Critical Analysis

The authors provide a novel and insightful analysis of the Adam optimizer, but there are a few caveats to consider:

1. The paper focuses on the theoretical understanding of Adam, but does not directly address its empirical performance. While the online learning perspective offers valuable insights, it would be helpful to see how these insights translate to practical improvements in machine learning tasks.

2. The analysis assumes certain conditions, such as convex objectives and bounded gradients, that may not always hold in real-world applications. It would be useful to understand how the results generalize to more challenging settings.

3. The paper does not discuss potential limitations or drawbacks of the FTRL framework for designing optimizers. It would be interesting to explore alternative online learning approaches and compare their strengths and weaknesses.

Overall, this research offers a fresh and promising direction for understanding the Adam optimizer. By connecting it to the well-studied field of online learning, the authors have opened up new avenues for further research and potential algorithm improvements.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel perspective on the Adam optimizer, a widely used algorithm in machine learning. By showing that Adam corresponds to a principled online learning framework called Follow-the-Regularized-Leader (FTRL), the authors are able to shed light on the benefits of Adam's algorithmic components.

This new viewpoint helps explain why Adam can outperform simpler optimizers like Stochastic Gradient Descent in certain scenarios. It also suggests ways to further improve the algorithm by drawing on the extensive research in online learning and adaptive gradient methods.

While the analysis has some caveats, it offers a promising direction for enhancing our theoretical understanding of Adam and other optimizers. By continuing to explore the connections between optimization and online learning, researchers may uncover additional insights that lead to more robust and effective algorithms for machine learning.