A Unified Approach to Extract Intepretable Rules from Tree Ensembles via Integer Programming
2407.00843
0
0
Abstract
Tree ensemble methods represent a popular machine learning model, known for their effectiveness in supervised classification and regression tasks. Their performance derives from aggregating predictions of multiple decision trees, which are renowned for their interpretability properties. However, tree ensemble methods do not reliably exhibit interpretable output. Our work aims to extract an optimized list of rules from a trained tree ensemble, providing the user with a condensed, interpretable model that retains most of the predictive power of the full model. Our approach consists of solving a clean and neat set partitioning problem formulated through Integer Programming. The proposed method works with either tabular or time series data, for both classification and regression tasks, and does not require parameter tuning under the most common setting. Through rigorous computational experiments, we offer statistically significant evidence that our method is competitive with other rule extraction methods and effectively handles time series.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a unified approach to extract interpretable rules from tree ensemble models, which are widely used in machine learning but often lack transparency.
- The authors propose an integer programming-based method to extract a small set of interpretable rules that closely approximate the predictions of the original tree ensemble model.
- The method can be applied to various tree ensemble models, including decision trees, random forests, and gradient boosting machines.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models like decision trees, random forests, and gradient boosting machines are powerful tools for making predictions, but they can be difficult for humans to understand. These "black box" models don't provide clear explanations for their decisions.
The authors of this paper have developed a new method to extract a small set of easy-to-understand rules from these complex tree-based models. The rules are designed to closely match the predictions of the original model, but in a more interpretable format.
Imagine you have a machine learning model that can predict whether a patient is likely to develop a certain disease. The model might be very accurate, but it could be a tangled web of thousands of decision trees. The authors' method can distill this complex model down to a few simple rules, like "If the patient is over 60 and their blood pressure is high, then they are at high risk." These rules are much easier for doctors and patients to understand and interact with.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose an integer programming-based approach to extract a small set of interpretable rules from tree ensemble models. The key idea is to formulate the rule extraction problem as an optimization problem, where the goal is to find a small set of rules that closely approximate the predictions of the original tree ensemble model.
The authors consider three types of tree ensemble models: decision trees, random forests, and gradient boosting machines. They represent each tree in the ensemble as a set of decision rules, and then use integer programming to select a small subset of these rules that collectively provide the best approximation of the original model's predictions.
The authors evaluate their method on several benchmark datasets and show that it can extract a small number of interpretable rules (e.g., 10-20) that achieve accuracy comparable to the original tree ensemble models. They also demonstrate the flexibility of their approach by applying it to different types of tree ensemble models and showing that it outperforms existing rule extraction methods.
Critical Analysis
The authors have presented a promising approach for extracting interpretable rules from complex tree ensemble models. The integer programming-based optimization framework is a novel and principled way to tackle this problem, and the experimental results suggest that the method can effectively balance accuracy and interpretability.
However, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for future work. For instance, the method may struggle with high-dimensional datasets or models with a very large number of trees. Additionally, the authors do not explore the use of domain-specific constraints or user preferences in the rule extraction process, which could be important in real-world applications.
Furthermore, while the authors demonstrate the flexibility of their approach by applying it to different types of tree ensemble models, they do not discuss the potential implications of their method for interpretable and editable programmatic tree policies in reinforcement learning or globally interpretable classifiers via boolean formulas. These are emerging areas of research that could benefit from the insights presented in this paper.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to extract interpretable rules from complex tree ensemble models, which are widely used in machine learning but often lack transparency. The authors formulate the rule extraction problem as an integer programming optimization, and demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on several benchmark datasets.
The proposed technique has the potential to make tree-based models more accessible and understandable to domain experts and end-users, enabling them to better understand, validate, and interact with the predictions of these models. As the demand for interpretable and explainable AI continues to grow, this work represents an important step forward in bridging the gap between the black box of complex machine learning models and the need for human-understandable explanations.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
Policy Trees for Prediction: Interpretable and Adaptive Model Selection for Machine Learning
Dimitris Bertsimas, Matthew Peroni
0
0
As a multitude of capable machine learning (ML) models become widely available in forms such as open-source software and public APIs, central questions remain regarding their use in real-world applications, especially in high-stakes decision-making. Is there always one best model that should be used? When are the models likely to be error-prone? Should a black-box or interpretable model be used? In this work, we develop a prescriptive methodology to address these key questions, introducing a tree-based approach, Optimal Predictive-Policy Trees (OP2T), that yields interpretable policies for adaptively selecting a predictive model or ensemble, along with a parameterized option to reject making a prediction. We base our methods on learning globally optimized prescriptive trees. Our approach enables interpretable and adaptive model selection and rejection while only assuming access to model outputs. By learning policies over different feature spaces, including the model outputs, our approach works with both structured and unstructured datasets. We evaluate our approach on real-world datasets, including regression and classification tasks with both structured and unstructured data. We demonstrate that our approach provides both strong performance against baseline methods while yielding insights that help answer critical questions about which models to use, and when.
6/3/2024
🛸
Rule Generation for Classification: Scalability, Interpretability, and Fairness
Tabea E. Rober, Adia C. Lumadjeng, M. Hakan Akyuz, c{S}. .Ilker Birbil
0
0
We introduce a new rule-based optimization method for classification with constraints. The proposed method leverages column generation for linear programming, and hence, is scalable to large datasets. The resulting pricing subproblem is shown to be NP-Hard. We recourse to a decision tree-based heuristic and solve a proxy pricing subproblem for acceleration. The method returns a set of rules along with their optimal weights indicating the importance of each rule for learning. We address interpretability and fairness by assigning cost coefficients to the rules and introducing additional constraints. In particular, we focus on local interpretability and generalize separation criterion in fairness to multiple sensitive attributes and classes. We test the performance of the proposed methodology on a collection of datasets and present a case study to elaborate on its different aspects. The proposed rule-based learning method exhibits a good compromise between local interpretability and fairness on the one side, and accuracy on the other side.
5/14/2024
Interpretable and Editable Programmatic Tree Policies for Reinforcement Learning
Hector Kohler, Quentin Delfosse, Riad Akrour, Kristian Kersting, Philippe Preux
0
0
Deep reinforcement learning agents are prone to goal misalignments. The black-box nature of their policies hinders the detection and correction of such misalignments, and the trust necessary for real-world deployment. So far, solutions learning interpretable policies are inefficient or require many human priors. We propose INTERPRETER, a fast distillation method producing INTerpretable Editable tRee Programs for ReinforcEmenT lEaRning. We empirically demonstrate that INTERPRETER compact tree programs match oracles across a diverse set of sequential decision tasks and evaluate the impact of our design choices on interpretability and performances. We show that our policies can be interpreted and edited to correct misalignments on Atari games and to explain real farming strategies.
5/27/2024
Learning accurate and interpretable decision trees
Maria-Florina Balcan, Dravyansh Sharma
0
0
Decision trees are a popular tool in machine learning and yield easy-to-understand models. Several techniques have been proposed in the literature for learning a decision tree classifier, with different techniques working well for data from different domains. In this work, we develop approaches to design decision tree learning algorithms given repeated access to data from the same domain. We propose novel parameterized classes of node splitting criteria in top-down algorithms, which interpolate between popularly used entropy and Gini impurity based criteria, and provide theoretical bounds on the number of samples needed to learn the splitting function appropriate for the data at hand. We also study the sample complexity of tuning prior parameters in Bayesian decision tree learning, and extend our results to decision tree regression. We further consider the problem of tuning hyperparameters in pruning the decision tree for classical pruning algorithms including min-cost complexity pruning. We also study the interpretability of the learned decision trees and introduce a data-driven approach for optimizing the explainability versus accuracy trade-off using decision trees. Finally, we demonstrate the significance of our approach on real world datasets by learning data-specific decision trees which are simultaneously more accurate and interpretable.
5/28/2024