A Unifying Action Principle for Classical Mechanical Systems
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a unifying action principle for classical mechanical systems, including both holonomic and non-holonomic systems.
- The proposed framework provides a consistent way to derive the equations of motion for a wide range of mechanical systems.
- The key idea is to use a generalized Lagrangian that incorporates both the kinetic and potential energies, as well as the constraint forces.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new way to understand the behavior of classical mechanical systems, such as pendulums, carts, or gears. The researchers developed a general mathematical framework that can describe the motion of a wide variety of mechanical systems, both those with and without constraints on their movement.
At the core of this framework is the concept of an "action principle." This is a way of characterizing the overall behavior of a system by considering the total "action" or energy it experiences over time. The researchers show that by using a generalized form of the Lagrangian (the difference between kinetic and potential energy), they can derive the equations of motion for many different types of mechanical systems in a unified way.
This is significant because previously, engineers and physicists had to use different approaches to model constrained or "non-holonomic" systems, which have restrictions on how they can move. The new action principle provides a consistent mathematical foundation that can handle both unconstrained and constrained systems.
By unifying the treatment of these mechanical systems, the researchers hope to provide a more comprehensive and flexible tool for analyzing and designing a broad range of classical mechanical devices and machines. This could have important implications for fields like robotics, vehicle dynamics, and machine design.
Technical Explanation
The key contribution of this paper is the formulation of a unifying action principle that can derive the equations of motion for both holonomic and non-holonomic classical mechanical systems.
The researchers start by defining a generalized Lagrangian function that includes both the kinetic and potential energies of the system, as well as the constraint forces acting on the system. They then show that the principle of stationary action - minimizing the total "action" or energy over time - leads to the correct equations of motion for a wide range of mechanical systems.
For non-holonomic systems that have motion constraints, the researchers incorporate the constraint forces directly into the Lagrangian. This allows them to derive the equations of motion in a unified way, without having to resort to separate treatments for constrained and unconstrained systems.
The proposed framework is quite general and can be applied to study the dynamics of robotic systems, Hamiltonian mechanics, and even adaptive gait modeling for kinematic systems. The unifying action principle provides a consistent mathematical foundation for analyzing a wide range of classical mechanical problems.
Critical Analysis
The main strength of this research is the generality and flexibility of the proposed action principle framework. By incorporating both the kinetic/potential energies and constraint forces into a single Lagrangian function, the researchers are able to derive the equations of motion for a broad class of mechanical systems in a unified way.
However, the paper does not provide a detailed comparison to other approaches for modeling non-holonomic systems, such as the use of Lagrange multipliers or virtual work principles. It would be helpful to understand how the unifying action principle relates to and improves upon these established techniques.
Additionally, the paper focuses primarily on the theoretical derivation of the framework and does not include many worked examples or numerical simulations to demonstrate its practical utility. Validating the approach on specific mechanical systems and comparing its performance to other methods would strengthen the contribution.
Overall, this research presents an interesting and potentially impactful new way of thinking about classical mechanics. Further development and application of the unifying action principle could lead to advances in areas like robotics, vehicle design, and the general study of constrained mechanical systems.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a unifying action principle that provides a consistent mathematical framework for deriving the equations of motion for a wide range of classical mechanical systems, including both holonomic and non-holonomic systems.
The key innovation is the formulation of a generalized Lagrangian function that encompasses both the kinetic/potential energies and the constraint forces acting on the system. By minimizing the total "action" or energy over time, the researchers show that this principle leads to the correct equations of motion in a unified way, without having to resort to separate treatments for different classes of mechanical systems.
This work has the potential to advance the state-of-the-art in classical mechanics and enable more comprehensive and flexible modeling of mechanical systems across many engineering disciplines. Further development and validation of the unifying action principle could lead to important breakthroughs in areas like robotics, vehicle dynamics, and the general study of constrained mechanical systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
New!A Unifying Action Principle for Classical Mechanical Systems
A. Rothkopf, W. A. Horowitz
The modern theory of classical mechanics, developed by Lagrange, Hamilton and Noether, attempts to cast all of classical motion in the form of an optimization problem, based on an energy functional called the classical action. The most important advantage of this formalism is the ability to manifestly incorporate and exploit symmetries and conservation laws. This reformulation succeeded for unconstrained and holonomic systems that at most obey position equality constraints. Non-holonomic systems, which obey velocity dependent constraints or position inequality constraints, are abundant in nature and of central relevance for science, engineering and industry. All attempts so far to solve non-holonomic dynamics as a classical action optimization problem have failed. Here we utilize the classical limit of a quantum field theory action principle to construct a novel classical action for non-holonomic systems. We therefore put to rest the 190 year old question of whether classical mechanics is variational, answering in the affirmative. We illustrate and validate our approach by solving three canonical model problems by direct numerical optimization of our new action. The formalism developed in this work significantly extends the reach of action principles to a large class of relevant mechanical systems, opening new avenues for their analysis and control both analytically and numerically.
Read more9/18/2024
📊
0
Energy-consistent integration of mechanical systems based on Livens principle
Philipp L. Kinon, Peter Betsch
In this work we make use of Livens principle (sometimes also referred to as Hamilton-Pontryagin principle) in order to obtain a novel structure-preserving integrator for mechanical systems. In contrast to the canonical Hamiltonian equations of motion, the Euler-Lagrange equations pertaining to Livens principle circumvent the need to invert the mass matrix. This is an essential advantage with respect to singular mass matrices, which can yield severe difficulties for the modelling and simulation of multibody systems. Moreover, Livens principle unifies both Lagrangian and Hamiltonian viewpoints on mechanics. Additionally, the present framework avoids the need to set up the system's Hamiltonian. The novel scheme algorithmically conserves a general energy function and aims at the preservation of momentum maps corresponding to symmetries of the system. We present an extension to mechanical systems subject to holonomic constraints. The performance of the newly devised method is studied in representative examples.
Read more4/1/2024
0
New!A variational approach to geometric mechanics for undulating robotic locomotion
Sean Even, Patrick S. Martinez, Cora Keogh, Oliver Gross, Yasemin Ozkan-Aydin, Peter Schroder
Limbless organisms of all sizes use undulating patterns of self-deformation to locomote. Geometric mechanics, which maps deformations to motions, provides a powerful framework to formalize and investigate the theoretical properties and limitations of such modes of locomotion. However, the inherent level of abstraction poses a challenge when bridging the gap between theory or simulations and laboratory experiments. We investigate the challenges of modeling motion trajectories of an undulating robotic locomotor by comparing experiments and simulations performed with a variational integrator. Despite the extensive simplifications that the model based on a geometric variation principle entails, the simulations show good agreement on average. Notably, our approach merely requires the knowledge of the emph{dissipation metric} -- a Riemannian metric on the configuration space, which can in practice be approximated by means closely resembling emph{resistive force theory}.
Read more9/18/2024
0
New!Learning Generalized Hamiltonians using fully Symplectic Mappings
Harsh Choudhary, Chandan Gupta, Vyacheslav kungrutsev, Melvin Leok, Georgios Korpas
Many important physical systems can be described as the evolution of a Hamiltonian system, which has the important property of being conservative, that is, energy is conserved throughout the evolution. Physics Informed Neural Networks and in particular Hamiltonian Neural Networks have emerged as a mechanism to incorporate structural inductive bias into the NN model. By ensuring physical invariances are conserved, the models exhibit significantly better sample complexity and out-of-distribution accuracy than standard NNs. Learning the Hamiltonian as a function of its canonical variables, typically position and velocity, from sample observations of the system thus becomes a critical task in system identification and long-term prediction of system behavior. However, to truly preserve the long-run physical conservation properties of Hamiltonian systems, one must use symplectic integrators for a forward pass of the system's simulation. While symplectic schemes have been used in the literature, they are thus far limited to situations when they reduce to explicit algorithms, which include the case of separable Hamiltonians or augmented non-separable Hamiltonians. We extend it to generalized non-separable Hamiltonians, and noting the self-adjoint property of symplectic integrators, we bypass computationally intensive backpropagation through an ODE solver. We show that the method is robust to noise and provides a good approximation of the system Hamiltonian when the state variables are sampled from a noisy observation. In the numerical results, we show the performance of the method concerning Hamiltonian reconstruction and conservation, indicating its particular advantage for non-separable systems.
Read more9/18/2024