Unlearning with Control: Assessing Real-world Utility for Large Language Model Unlearning
2406.09179
0
0
Abstract
The compelling goal of eradicating undesirable data behaviors, while preserving usual model functioning, underscores the significance of machine unlearning within the domain of large language models (LLMs). Recent research has begun to approach LLM unlearning via gradient ascent (GA) -- increasing the prediction risk for those training strings targeted to be unlearned, thereby erasing their parameterized responses. Despite their simplicity and efficiency, we suggest that GA-based methods face the propensity towards excessive unlearning, resulting in various undesirable model behaviors, such as catastrophic forgetting, that diminish their practical utility. In this paper, we suggest a set of metrics that can capture multiple facets of real-world utility and propose several controlling methods that can regulate the extent of excessive unlearning. Accordingly, we suggest a general framework to better reflect the practical efficacy of various unlearning methods -- we begin by controlling the unlearning procedures/unlearned models such that no excessive unlearning occurs and follow by the evaluation for unlearning efficacy. Our experimental analysis on established benchmarks revealed that GA-based methods are far from perfect in practice, as strong unlearning is at the high cost of hindering the model utility. We conclude that there is still a long way towards practical and effective LLM unlearning, and more efforts are required in this field.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the real-world utility of unlearning techniques for large language models (LLMs).
- The authors assess the effectiveness of various unlearning approaches in removing specific knowledge from pre-trained LLMs.
- They explore the tradeoffs between unlearning performance, model utility, and computational cost.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 are incredibly powerful, but they can also learn and retain information that we may want to remove later on. This is known as the "unlearning" problem. Rethinking Machine Unlearning for Large Language Models, Machine Unlearning for Large Language Models, and other related papers have explored different techniques for unlearning information in LLMs.
In this paper, the authors take a closer look at how well these unlearning approaches work in the real world. They assess the ability of various unlearning methods to effectively remove specific knowledge from pre-trained LLMs, while also considering the impact on the model's overall usefulness and the computational resources required.
The key idea is to find the right balance between unlearning performance, model utility, and efficiency. The authors hope that their findings will help guide the development of more practical and effective unlearning techniques for LLMs.
Technical Explanation
The paper begins by providing an overview of LLM learning and unlearning. The authors discuss the challenges of unlearning in LLMs, including the need to preserve the model's overall utility and the computational costs involved.
They then describe several unlearning approaches, including Machine Unlearning for Pre-trained Large Language Models, A More Practical Approach to Machine Unlearning, and To Each Textual Sequence Its Own: Improving Machine Unlearning. The authors evaluate the performance of these techniques in removing specific knowledge from pre-trained LLMs, as well as the impact on the model's overall utility and the computational resources required.
The experiments involve training LLMs on a variety of datasets, including textual and visual data, and then using the unlearning techniques to remove specific information. The authors measure the effectiveness of the unlearning process, the model's performance on downstream tasks, and the computational cost.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive and rigorous evaluation of the real-world utility of LLM unlearning techniques. The authors acknowledge the limitations of the study, such as the specific datasets and models used, and the difficulty of completely removing knowledge from a large, complex model.
One potential issue raised is the inherent tradeoff between unlearning performance and model utility. Highly effective unlearning techniques may come at the cost of reduced model capabilities, which could limit the practical applications of the technology.
Additionally, the computational cost of unlearning, particularly for large-scale models, is a significant concern that requires further investigation. The authors suggest the need for more efficient unlearning algorithms and hardware support to make the process more feasible in real-world scenarios.
Conclusion
This paper offers a valuable contribution to the ongoing research on unlearning in large language models. The authors provide a detailed assessment of the effectiveness, utility, and efficiency of various unlearning techniques, offering insights that can guide the development of more practical and effective solutions.
The findings highlight the challenges and tradeoffs involved in LLM unlearning, underscoring the need for continued research and innovation in this area. As the use of LLMs becomes more widespread, the ability to reliably and efficiently remove specific knowledge will become increasingly important, both from a technical and ethical standpoint.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Rethinking Machine Unlearning for Large Language Models
Sijia Liu, Yuanshun Yao, Jinghan Jia, Stephen Casper, Nathalie Baracaldo, Peter Hase, Xiaojun Xu, Yuguang Yao, Hang Li, Kush R. Varshney, Mohit Bansal, Sanmi Koyejo, Yang Liu
0
0
We explore machine unlearning (MU) in the domain of large language models (LLMs), referred to as LLM unlearning. This initiative aims to eliminate undesirable data influence (e.g., sensitive or illegal information) and the associated model capabilities, while maintaining the integrity of essential knowledge generation and not affecting causally unrelated information. We envision LLM unlearning becoming a pivotal element in the life-cycle management of LLMs, potentially standing as an essential foundation for developing generative AI that is not only safe, secure, and trustworthy, but also resource-efficient without the need of full retraining. We navigate the unlearning landscape in LLMs from conceptual formulation, methodologies, metrics, and applications. In particular, we highlight the often-overlooked aspects of existing LLM unlearning research, e.g., unlearning scope, data-model interaction, and multifaceted efficacy assessment. We also draw connections between LLM unlearning and related areas such as model editing, influence functions, model explanation, adversarial training, and reinforcement learning. Furthermore, we outline an effective assessment framework for LLM unlearning and explore its applications in copyright and privacy safeguards and sociotechnical harm reduction.
4/8/2024
Machine Unlearning in Large Language Models
Saaketh Koundinya Gundavarapu, Shreya Agarwal, Arushi Arora, Chandana Thimmalapura Jagadeeshaiah
0
0
Machine unlearning, a novel area within artificial intelligence, focuses on addressing the challenge of selectively forgetting or reducing undesirable knowledge or behaviors in machine learning models, particularly in the context of large language models (LLMs). This paper introduces a methodology to align LLMs, such as Open Pre-trained Transformer Language Models, with ethical, privacy, and safety standards by leveraging the gradient ascent algorithm for knowledge unlearning. Our approach aims to selectively erase or modify learned information in LLMs, targeting harmful responses and copyrighted content. This paper presents a dual-pronged approach to enhance the ethical and safe behavior of large language models (LLMs) by addressing the issues of harmful responses and copyrighted content. To mitigate harmful responses, we applied gradient ascent on the PKU dataset, achieving a 75% reduction in harmful responses for Open Pre-trained Transformer Language Models (OPT1.3b and OPT2.7b) citet{zhang2022opt} while retaining previous knowledge using the TruthfulQA dataset citet{DBLP:journals/corr/abs-2109-07958}. For handling copyrighted content, we constructed a custom dataset based on the Lord of the Rings corpus and aligned LLMs (OPT1.3b and OPT2.7b) citet{zhang2022opt} through LoRA: Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Language Models citet{DBLP:journals/corr/abs-2106-09685} finetuning. Subsequently, we employed gradient ascent to unlearn the Lord of the Rings content, resulting in a remarkable reduction in the presence of copyrighted material. To maintain a diverse knowledge base, we utilized the Book Corpus dataset. Additionally, we propose a new evaluation technique for assessing the effectiveness of harmful unlearning.
5/27/2024
Machine Unlearning of Pre-trained Large Language Models
Jin Yao, Eli Chien, Minxin Du, Xinyao Niu, Tianhao Wang, Zezhou Cheng, Xiang Yue
0
0
This study investigates the concept of the `right to be forgotten' within the context of large language models (LLMs). We explore machine unlearning as a pivotal solution, with a focus on pre-trained models--a notably under-researched area. Our research delineates a comprehensive framework for machine unlearning in pre-trained LLMs, encompassing a critical analysis of seven diverse unlearning methods. Through rigorous evaluation using curated datasets from arXiv, books, and GitHub, we establish a robust benchmark for unlearning performance, demonstrating that these methods are over $10^5$ times more computationally efficient than retraining. Our results show that integrating gradient ascent with gradient descent on in-distribution data improves hyperparameter robustness. We also provide detailed guidelines for efficient hyperparameter tuning in the unlearning process. Our findings advance the discourse on ethical AI practices, offering substantive insights into the mechanics of machine unlearning for pre-trained LLMs and underscoring the potential for responsible AI development.
5/31/2024
Avoiding Copyright Infringement via Machine Unlearning
Guangyao Dou, Zheyuan Liu, Qing Lyu, Kaize Ding, Eric Wong
0
0
Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities but also pose risks by learning and generating copyrighted material, leading to significant legal and ethical concerns. To address these issues, it is critical for model owners to be able to unlearn copyrighted content at various time steps. We explore the setting of sequential unlearning, where copyrighted content is removed over multiple time steps - a scenario that has not been rigorously addressed. To tackle this challenge, we propose Stable Sequential Unlearning (SSU), a novel unlearning framework for LLMs, designed to have a more stable process to remove copyrighted content from LLMs throughout different time steps using task vectors, by incorporating additional random labeling loss and applying gradient-based weight saliency mapping. Experiments demonstrate that SSU finds a good balance between unlearning efficacy and maintaining the model's general knowledge compared to existing baselines.
6/18/2024