Validating Deep-Learning Weather Forecast Models on Recent High-Impact Extreme Events
2404.17652
0
0
Abstract
The forecast accuracy of deep-learning-based weather prediction models is improving rapidly, leading many to speak of a second revolution in weather forecasting. With numerous methods being developed, and limited physical guarantees offered by deep-learning models, there is a critical need for comprehensive evaluation of these emerging techniques. While this need has been partly fulfilled by benchmark datasets, they provide little information on rare and impactful extreme events, or on compound impact metrics, for which model accuracy might degrade due to misrepresented dependencies between variables. To address these issues, we compare deep-learning weather prediction models (GraphCast, PanguWeather, FourCastNet) and ECMWF's high-resolution forecast (HRES) system in three case studies: the 2021 Pacific Northwest heatwave, the 2023 South Asian humid heatwave, and the North American winter storm in 2021. We find evidence that machine learning (ML) weather prediction models can locally achieve similar accuracy to HRES on record-shattering events such as the 2021 Pacific Northwest heatwave and even forecast the compound 2021 North American winter storm substantially better. However, extrapolating to extreme conditions may impact machine learning models more severely than HRES, as evidenced by the comparable or superior spatially- and temporally-aggregated forecast accuracy of HRES for the two heatwaves studied. The ML forecasts also lack variables required to assess the health risks of events such as the 2023 South Asian humid heatwave. Generally, case-study-driven, impact-centric evaluation can complement existing research, increase public trust, and aid in developing reliable ML weather prediction models.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper validates the performance of deep learning weather forecast models on recent high-impact extreme weather events.
- The researchers evaluated the accuracy of these models in predicting events like heatwaves, droughts, and floods that have had significant societal and economic impacts.
- The goal was to assess the ability of advanced AI weather modeling techniques to capture the complexity of these extreme phenomena.
Plain English Explanation
Weather forecasting is an essential tool for preparing communities and industries for potentially devastating events like heatwaves, droughts, and floods. In recent years, deep learning models have shown promise in improving weather prediction accuracy. However, it's crucial to validate how well these advanced AI models perform on the most impactful extreme weather incidents.
This paper takes a closer look at evaluating the capabilities of deep learning weather forecasting systems. The researchers analyzed how well the models could predict the development and progression of severe weather events that have caused significant harm to communities and the economy. By rigorously testing the models on these high-impact scenarios, the study aims to provide a real-world assessment of the current state-of-the-art in AI-powered weather forecasting.
Technical Explanation
The researchers acquired observational data and model outputs for several recent extreme weather events, including heatwaves, droughts, and flooding incidents. They then compared the forecasts generated by state-of-the-art deep learning weather models against the actual observed conditions to assess the models' accuracy.
The team utilized a range of evaluation metrics to quantify the models' performance, such as calculating bias, assessing spatial patterns, and measuring the ability to capture the intensity and timing of the extreme events. This rigorous validation process allowed them to identify strengths, weaknesses, and areas for further improvement in the deep learning weather forecasting approaches.
Critical Analysis
The study provides valuable insights into the real-world capabilities of deep learning weather models, but it also acknowledges some important limitations. The researchers note that the models may struggle to capture the full complexity of extreme weather phenomena, which can involve nonlinear interactions and rapid changes in conditions.
Additionally, the study is limited to a relatively small set of high-impact events, and the researchers suggest that expanding the validation dataset to include a wider range of extreme scenarios would be beneficial. [Incorporating more diverse data sources and exploring advanced techniques like conditional diffusion models could also help improve the models' performance on these challenging forecasting tasks.
Conclusion
This paper presents a rigorous validation of deep learning weather forecast models on recent high-impact extreme events. The findings suggest that while these advanced AI systems show promise, there is still room for improvement in accurately predicting the development and impacts of severe weather incidents.
By thoroughly evaluating the models' performance on real-world, high-stakes scenarios, the researchers have provided valuable insights to guide the ongoing advancement of weather forecasting capabilities. Continued research and development in this area could lead to significant improvements in the ability to prepare for and mitigate the effects of extreme weather events, which have far-reaching consequences for communities, businesses, and the environment.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
ExtremeCast: Boosting Extreme Value Prediction for Global Weather Forecast
Wanghan Xu, Kang Chen, Tao Han, Hao Chen, Wanli Ouyang, Lei Bai
0
0
Data-driven weather forecast based on machine learning (ML) has experienced rapid development and demonstrated superior performance in the global medium-range forecast compared to traditional physics-based dynamical models. However, most of these ML models struggle with accurately predicting extreme weather, which is closely related to the extreme value prediction. Through mathematical analysis, we prove that the use of symmetric losses, such as the Mean Squared Error (MSE), leads to biased predictions and underestimation of extreme values. To address this issue, we introduce Exloss, a novel loss function that performs asymmetric optimization and highlights extreme values to obtain accurate extreme weather forecast. Furthermore, we introduce a training-free extreme value enhancement strategy named ExEnsemble, which increases the variance of pixel values and improves the forecast robustness. Combined with an advanced global weather forecast model, extensive experiments show that our solution can achieve state-of-the-art performance in extreme weather prediction, while maintaining the overall forecast accuracy comparable to the top medium-range forecast models.
5/10/2024
🖼️
Forecasting the Future with Future Technologies: Advancements in Large Meteorological Models
Hailong Shu, Yue Wang, Weiwei Song, Huichuang Guo, Zhen Song
0
0
The field of meteorological forecasting has undergone a significant transformation with the integration of large models, especially those employing deep learning techniques. This paper reviews the advancements and applications of these models in weather prediction, emphasizing their role in transforming traditional forecasting methods. Models like FourCastNet, Pangu-Weather, GraphCast, ClimaX, and FengWu have made notable contributions by providing accurate, high-resolution forecasts, surpassing the capabilities of traditional Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) models. These models utilize advanced neural network architectures, such as Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs), Graph Neural Networks (GNNs), and Transformers, to process diverse meteorological data, enhancing predictive accuracy across various time scales and spatial resolutions. The paper addresses challenges in this domain, including data acquisition and computational demands, and explores future opportunities for model optimization and hardware advancements. It underscores the integration of artificial intelligence with conventional meteorological techniques, promising improved weather prediction accuracy and a significant contribution to addressing climate-related challenges. This synergy positions large models as pivotal in the evolving landscape of meteorological forecasting.
4/11/2024
Lightning-Fast Thunderstorm Warnings: Predicting Severe Convective Environments with Global Neural Weather Models
Monika Feldmann, Tom Beucler, Milton Gomez, Olivia Martius
0
0
The recently released suite of AI weather models can produce multi-day, medium-range forecasts within seconds, with a skill on par with state-of-the-art operational forecasts. Traditional AI model evaluation predominantly targets global scores on single levels. Specific prediction tasks, such as severe convective environments, require much more precision on a local scale and with the correct vertical gradients between levels. With a focus on the convective season of global hotspots in 2020, we assess the skill of three top-performing AI models (Pangu-Weather, GraphCast, FourCastNet) for Convective Available Potential Energy (CAPE) and Deep Layer Shear (DLS) at lead-times of up to 10 days against the ERA-5 reanalysis and the IFS operational numerical weather prediction model. Looking at the example of a US tornado outbreak on April 12 and 13, 2020, all models predict elevated CAPE and DLS values multiple days in advance. The spatial structures in the AI models are smoothed in comparison to IFS and ERA-5. The models show differing biases in the prediction of CAPE values, with GraphCast capturing the value distribution the most accurately and FourCastNet showing a consistent underestimation. In seasonal analyses around the globe, we generally see the highest performance by GraphCast and Pangu-Weather, which match or even exceed the performance of IFS. CAPE derived from vertically coarse pressure levels of neural weather models lacks the precision of the vertically fine resolution of numerical models. The promising results here indicate that a direct prediction of CAPE in AI models is likely to be skillful. This would open unprecedented opportunities for fast and inexpensive predictions of severe weather phenomena. By advancing the assessment of AI models towards process-based evaluations we lay the foundation for hazard-driven applications of AI-based weather forecasts.
6/17/2024
Vision-Language Models Meet Meteorology: Developing Models for Extreme Weather Events Detection with Heatmaps
Jian Chen, Peilin Zhou, Yining Hua, Dading Chong, Meng Cao, Yaowei Li, Zixuan Yuan, Bing Zhu, Junwei Liang
0
0
Real-time detection and prediction of extreme weather protect human lives and infrastructure. Traditional methods rely on numerical threshold setting and manual interpretation of weather heatmaps with Geographic Information Systems (GIS), which can be slow and error-prone. Our research redefines Extreme Weather Events Detection (EWED) by framing it as a Visual Question Answering (VQA) problem, thereby introducing a more precise and automated solution. Leveraging Vision-Language Models (VLM) to simultaneously process visual and textual data, we offer an effective aid to enhance the analysis process of weather heatmaps. Our initial assessment of general-purpose VLMs (e.g., GPT-4-Vision) on EWED revealed poor performance, characterized by low accuracy and frequent hallucinations due to inadequate color differentiation and insufficient meteorological knowledge. To address these challenges, we introduce ClimateIQA, the first meteorological VQA dataset, which includes 8,760 wind gust heatmaps and 254,040 question-answer pairs covering four question types, both generated from the latest climate reanalysis data. We also propose Sparse Position and Outline Tracking (SPOT), an innovative technique that leverages OpenCV and K-Means clustering to capture and depict color contours in heatmaps, providing ClimateIQA with more accurate color spatial location information. Finally, we present Climate-Zoo, the first meteorological VLM collection, which adapts VLMs to meteorological applications using the ClimateIQA dataset. Experiment results demonstrate that models from Climate-Zoo substantially outperform state-of-the-art general VLMs, achieving an accuracy increase from 0% to over 90% in EWED verification. The datasets and models in this study are publicly available for future climate science research: https://github.com/AlexJJJChen/Climate-Zoo.
6/17/2024