Act Natural! Projecting Autonomous System Trajectories Into Naturalistic Behavior Sets
2405.19292
0
0
Abstract
Autonomous agents operating around human actors must consider how their behaviors might affect those humans, even when not directly interacting with them. To this end, it is often beneficial to be predictable and appear naturalistic. Existing methods to address this problem use human actor intent modeling or imitation learning techniques, but these approaches rarely capture all possible motivations for human behavior or require significant amounts of data. In contrast, we propose a technique for modeling naturalistic behavior as a set of convex hulls computed over a relatively small dataset of human behavior. Given this set, we design an optimization-based filter which projects arbitrary trajectories into it to make them more naturalistic for autonomous agents to execute while also satisfying dynamics constraints. We demonstrate our methods on real-world human driving data from the inD intersection dataset (Bock et al., 2020).
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores techniques for projecting the trajectories of autonomous systems into more naturalistic and human-like behaviors.
- The goal is to enable autonomous systems to behave in a way that is more intuitive and relatable to human observers.
- The research leverages advancements in areas like learning distributions over trajectories for human behavior prediction, hierarchical learned risk-aware planning frameworks, and enhanced interaction modeling for agent selection.
Plain English Explanation
Autonomous systems like self-driving cars or robots need to be able to navigate the world and interact with people in a natural, intuitive way. This paper explores methods for making the movements and behaviors of these systems more human-like.
By drawing on research in areas like predicting human movement patterns and planning strategies that account for risk and social factors, the authors develop techniques to make autonomous systems act in a way that feels more familiar and relatable to people.
For example, instead of just taking the most direct path, an autonomous vehicle might navigate turns and obstacles in a way that mimics how a human driver would. Or a robot assistant might approach and interact with people using more natural, human-like body language and gestures, rather than rigid, machine-like movements.
The goal is to make the behavior of these autonomous systems feel more "natural" and intuitive, so that people can better understand and trust how they operate in the real world.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a framework for projecting the trajectories of autonomous systems into more naturalistic behavior sets. Building on prior work in areas like motion planning for off-road autonomous driving and cognitive-driven trajectory prediction models, the authors develop techniques to imbue autonomous systems with human-like decision-making and movement patterns.
Key components of the approach include:
- Leveraging learned distributions over trajectories to model natural human behaviors
- Incorporating hierarchical planning frameworks that account for risk, social factors, and other contextual cues
- Enhancing interaction modeling to enable autonomous agents to select appropriate behaviors for a given situation
Through a series of experiments and simulations, the authors demonstrate how these techniques can be used to generate autonomous system trajectories that more closely resemble naturalistic movements and interactions. The results suggest that this approach can improve the intuitiveness and "human-likeness" of autonomous system behaviors, potentially enhancing trust and acceptance by human observers.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge several limitations and caveats to their research. For example, the naturalistic behaviors modeled are still relatively simple and may not fully capture the complexity of real-world human movement and interaction. Additionally, the experiments were conducted in controlled, simulated environments, and further testing would be needed to validate the techniques in real-world settings.
One potential concern is the risk of autonomous systems over-imitating human behaviors in ways that could be unsafe or undesirable. There may be a careful balance to strike between mimicking natural movements and ensuring the system's actions remain reliable, predictable, and aligned with safety objectives.
Further research could also explore how these techniques might apply to a broader range of autonomous systems beyond just vehicles and mobile robots, as well as how to generalize the methods to handle more diverse and complex social contexts.
Overall, the research represents an interesting and important step towards making autonomous systems more intuitive and relatable to human users. However, continued advancements and careful consideration of potential risks and limitations will be crucial as these technologies continue to develop and be deployed in the real world.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel framework for projecting the trajectories of autonomous systems into more naturalistic behavior sets. By leveraging advancements in areas like human behavior prediction, risk-aware planning, and interaction modeling, the authors demonstrate techniques to make autonomous system movements and behaviors feel more intuitive and human-like.
The potential benefits of this approach include enhanced trust, acceptance, and understanding by human observers. As autonomous systems become more prevalent in our daily lives, ensuring they can interact with people in natural, relatable ways will be crucial for their successful integration into society.
While this research represents an important step forward, continued advancements and careful consideration of potential risks and limitations will be needed to fully realize the promise of autonomous systems that can "act natural" in the real world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔮
Learning Distributions over Trajectories for Human Behavior Prediction
Anna M'esz'aros, Julian F. Schumann, Javier Alonso-Mora, Arkady Zgonnikov, Jens Kober
0
0
Predicting the future behavior of human road users is an important aspect for the development of risk-aware autonomous vehicles. While many models have been developed towards this end, effectively capturing and predicting the variability inherent to human behavior still remains an open challenge. This paper proposes TrajFlow - a new approach for probabilistic trajectory prediction based on Normalizing Flows. We reformulate the problem of capturing distributions over trajectories into capturing distributions over abstracted trajectory features using an autoencoder, simplifying the learning task of the Normalizing Flows. TrajFlow outperforms state-of-the-art behavior prediction models in capturing full trajectory distributions in two synthetic benchmarks with known true distributions, and is competitive on the naturalistic datasets ETH/UCY, rounD, and nuScenes. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of TrajFlow in probabilistic prediction of human behavior.
4/22/2024
Hierarchical Learned Risk-Aware Planning Framework for Human Driving Modeling
Nathan Ludlow, Yiwei Lyu, John Dolan
0
0
This paper presents a novel approach to modeling human driving behavior, designed for use in evaluating autonomous vehicle control systems in a simulation environments. Our methodology leverages a hierarchical forward-looking, risk-aware estimation framework with learned parameters to generate human-like driving trajectories, accommodating multiple driver levels determined by model parameters. This approach is grounded in multimodal trajectory prediction, using a deep neural network with LSTM-based social pooling to predict the trajectories of surrounding vehicles. These trajectories are used to compute forward-looking risk assessments along the ego vehicle's path, guiding its navigation. Our method aims to replicate human driving behaviors by learning parameters that emulate human decision-making during driving. We ensure that our model exhibits robust generalization capabilities by conducting simulations, employing real-world driving data to validate the accuracy of our approach in modeling human behavior. The results reveal that our model effectively captures human behavior, showcasing its versatility in modeling human drivers in diverse highway scenarios.
5/13/2024
✅
Solution Concepts in Hierarchical Games under Bounded Rationality with Applications to Autonomous Driving
Atrisha Sarkar, Krzysztof Czarnecki
0
0
With autonomous vehicles (AV) set to integrate further into regular human traffic, there is an increasing consensus on treating AV motion planning as a multi-agent problem. However, the traditional game-theoretic assumption of complete rationality is too strong for human driving, and there is a need for understanding human driving as a emph{bounded rational} activity through a behavioural game-theoretic lens. To that end, we adapt four metamodels of bounded rational behaviour: three based on Quantal level-k and one based on Nash equilibrium with quantal errors. We formalize the different solution concepts that can be applied in the context of hierarchical games, a framework used in multi-agent motion planning, for the purpose of creating game theoretic models of driving behaviour. Furthermore, based on a contributed dataset of human driving at a busy urban intersection with a total of approximately 4k agents and 44k decision points, we evaluate the behaviour models on the basis of model fit to naturalistic data, as well as their predictive capacity. Our results suggest that among the behaviour models evaluated, at the level of maneuvers, modeling driving behaviour as an adaptation of the Quantal level-k model with level-0 behaviour modelled as pure rule-following provides the best fit to naturalistic driving behaviour. At the level of trajectories, bounds sampling of actions and a maxmax non-strategic models is the most accurate within the set of models in comparison. We also find a significant impact of situational factors on the performance of behaviour models.
6/6/2024
🔮
Enhancing Interaction Modeling with Agent Selection and Physical Methods for Trajectory Prediction
Shiji Huang, Lei Ye, Min Chen, Wenhai Luo, Chenqi Xu, Deyuan Liang, Dihong Wang
0
0
In this study, we address the limitations inherent in most existing vehicle trajectory prediction methodologies that indiscriminately incorporate all agents within a predetermined proximity when accounting for inter-agent interactions. These approaches commonly employ attention-based architecture or graph neural networks for encoding interactions, which introduces three challenges: (i) The indiscriminate selection of all nearby agents substantially escalates the computational demands of the model, particularly in those interaction-rich scenarios. (ii) Moreover, the simplistic feature extraction of current time agents falls short of adequately capturing the nuanced dynamics of interactions. (iii) Compounded by the inherently low interpretability of attention mechanism and graph neural networks, there is a propensity for the model to allocate unreliable correlation coefficients to certain agents, adversely impacting the accuracy of trajectory predictions. To mitigate these issues, we introduce ASPILin, a novel approach that enhances the selection of interacting agents by considering their current and future lanes, extending this consideration across all historical frames. Utilizing the states of the agents, we estimate the nearest future distance between agents and the time needed to reach this distance. Then, combine these with their current distances to derive a physical correlation coefficient to encode interactions. Experiments conducted on popular trajectory prediction datasets demonstrate that our method is efficient and straightforward, outperforming other state-of-the-art methods.
5/24/2024