Active clustering with bandit feedback

Overview

• The paper investigates the Active Clustering Problem (ACP), where a learner interacts with a stochastic multi-armed bandit with high-dimensional feedback
• The arms are divided into hidden groups, and the learner's task is to uncover this hidden partition with the smallest budget (i.e., fewest observations) and a low probability of error
• The paper (i) derives a lower bound for the budget required to solve the ACP, and (ii) introduces the computationally efficient ACB algorithm, whose budget matches the lower bound in most regimes

Plain English Explanation

The researchers are studying a challenging problem called the Active Clustering Problem (ACP). Imagine you have a slot machine with many different arms (options), and each arm gives you a different reward when you pull it. However, the arms are secretly divided into groups, and the arms within the same group have the same average reward.

Your goal is to figure out how the arms are grouped together, but you want to do this as efficiently as possible - by pulling the arms as few times as possible. The researchers show that there is a lower limit on how few pulls you need to do this with a high chance of getting the grouping right. They also introduce a new algorithm called ACB that can usually achieve this lower limit, doing better than a simple strategy of pulling each arm the same number of times.

Importantly, the researchers find that in this active setting, where you can choose which arms to pull, there is no gap between the computational power you need and the information you need to solve the problem. This is different from some other related problems, where there can be a gap.

Technical Explanation

The researchers investigate the Active Clustering Problem (ACP), where a learner interacts with an N-armed stochastic bandit with d-dimensional subGaussian feedback. There exists a hidden partition of the arms into K groups, such that arms within the same group share the same mean vector.

The learner's task is to uncover this hidden partition with the smallest budget (i.e., the least number of observations) and a probability of error smaller than a prescribed constant δ. The researchers (i) derive a non-asymptotic lower bound for the budget required to solve the ACP, and (ii) introduce the computationally efficient ACB algorithm, whose budget matches the lower bound in most regimes.

The researchers show that ACB outperforms a uniform sampling strategy, where each arm is pulled the same number of times. Importantly, the researchers establish that there is no computation-information gap in the active setting, unlike in the batch setting (where all observations are collected before analysis). This is in contrast to other related problems, such as federated combinatorial multi-agent multi-armed bandits and neural active learning beyond bandits, where such gaps can exist.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge some limitations of their work. For example, they assume that the arms' rewards are subGaussian, which may not always hold in practice. Additionally, the researchers focus on the setting where the number of groups K is known in advance, which may not always be the case in real-world applications.

Further research could explore relaxing these assumptions, or investigate the performance of the ACB algorithm in more complex scenarios, such as the tree bandits with generative Bayes setting. It would also be interesting to see how the ACB algorithm compares to other active clustering approaches, such as the data-driven upper confidence bounds method.

Conclusion

In this paper, the researchers make significant contributions to the understanding of the Active Clustering Problem (ACP). They derive a non-asymptotic lower bound for the budget required to solve the problem and introduce the computationally efficient ACB algorithm, which matches this lower bound in most regimes. Importantly, the researchers establish that there is no computation-information gap in the active setting, in contrast to other related problems.

These findings have important implications for the design of efficient exploration strategies in high-dimensional bandit problems, with potential applications in areas such as recommendation systems, online advertising, and interactive learning. The insights from this research could also inform the development of new active learning algorithms that can more effectively uncover hidden structures in complex data.