ADaPT: As-Needed Decomposition and Planning with Language Models

Overview

• The paper introduces a new approach called As-Needed Decomposition and Planning for complex Tasks (ADaPT) to address the shortcomings of existing methods for using large language models (LLMs) in interactive decision-making tasks that require planning and adapting to the environment.
• Existing methods either iteratively determine the next action (iterative executors) or generate plans and execute sub-tasks using LLMs (plan-and-execute), but struggle with task complexity as the inability to execute any sub-task may lead to task failure.
• ADaPT explicitly plans and decomposes complex sub-tasks as-needed, i.e., when the LLM is unable to execute them, and recursively decomposes sub-tasks to adapt to both task complexity and LLM capability.

Plain English Explanation

ADaPT: As-Needed Decomposition and Planning for complex Tasks is a new approach that aims to improve the performance of large language models (LLMs) in complex, interactive tasks that require planning and adapting to the environment.

Imagine you're trying to bake a cake, but you've never baked before. An iterative executor approach would be like trying to figure out the next step one at a time, without a clear plan. A plan-and-execute approach would be like generating a full recipe and instructions upfront, but if you get stuck on one step, the whole plan falls apart.

ADaPT takes a different approach. It breaks down the overall cake-baking task into smaller, more manageable sub-tasks. If the LLM (your "baking assistant") gets stuck on a sub-task, ADaPT will decompose that sub-task further, until it finds something the LLM can handle. This recursive decomposition allows the system to adapt to the complexity of the task and the limitations of the LLM.

The researchers tested ADaPT on several complex, interactive tasks, including a novel dataset called TextCraft, and found that it significantly outperformed established methods, achieving success rates up to 28.3% higher. This shows the value of ADaPT's dynamic, multi-level approach to task planning and execution.

Technical Explanation

ADaPT: As-Needed Decomposition and Planning for complex Tasks introduces a new approach to using large language models (LLMs) for interactive decision-making tasks that require planning and adapting to the environment.

Existing methods fall into two broad categories: iterative executors, which determine the next action iteratively, and plan-and-execute, which generate plans and execute sub-tasks using LLMs. However, these methods struggle with task complexity, as the inability to execute any sub-task may lead to task failure.

To address these shortcomings, the authors introduce ADaPT, which explicitly plans and decomposes complex sub-tasks as-needed, i.e., when the LLM is unable to execute them. ADaPT recursively decomposes sub-tasks to adapt to both task complexity and LLM capability.

The researchers evaluate ADaPT on several complex, interactive tasks, including a novel dataset called TextCraft. Their results demonstrate that ADaPT substantially outperforms established strong baselines, achieving success rates up to 28.3% higher in ALFWorld, 27% in WebShop, and 33% in TextCraft.

Through extensive analysis, the authors illustrate the importance of multilevel decomposition and establish that ADaPT dynamically adjusts to the capabilities of the executor LLM as well as to task complexity.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to using large language models (LLMs) for complex, interactive tasks that require planning and adaptation. The key strength of ADaPT is its ability to dynamically decompose sub-tasks as needed, which allows it to handle task complexity and adapt to the limitations of the LLM executor.

One potential limitation of the research is the scope of the evaluated tasks. While the authors introduce a novel dataset called TextCraft, the other tasks (ALFWorld and WebShop) may not fully capture the breadth of real-world, interactive decision-making scenarios. It would be valuable to see how ADaPT performs on an even wider range of tasks, including those with more ambiguous or open-ended objectives.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the computational or memory requirements of ADaPT compared to the baseline methods. As the complexity of tasks and the number of sub-tasks grow, the resource demands of the recursive decomposition process may become a practical concern. Further research into the scalability and efficiency of ADaPT would be useful.

Overall, the ADaPT: As-Needed Decomposition and Planning for complex Tasks paper presents a promising approach to leveraging LLMs for complex, interactive decision-making. The authors have demonstrated the value of their dynamic, multi-level decomposition strategy, and their work opens up exciting avenues for further research in this area.

Conclusion

The ADaPT: As-Needed Decomposition and Planning for complex Tasks paper introduces a novel approach to using large language models (LLMs) for interactive decision-making tasks that require planning and adaptation. By explicitly planning and decomposing complex sub-tasks as needed, ADaPT is able to outperform established methods and achieve significantly higher success rates on a range of challenging tasks.

The key innovation of ADaPT is its ability to dynamically adjust to both task complexity and the capabilities of the LLM executor. This multilevel decomposition strategy allows the system to break down tasks into manageable sub-tasks and recursively adapt as needed, addressing a key limitation of existing approaches.

The successful evaluation of ADaPT on tasks like ALFWorld, WebShop, and the novel TextCraft dataset demonstrates the practical value of this research. As LLMs continue to play a growing role in interactive decision-making, the insights from this paper can help pave the way for more robust and capable systems that can handle complex, real-world challenges.