Adaptive Affinity-Based Generalization For MRI Imaging Segmentation Across Resource-Limited Settings
2404.02738
0
0
Abstract
The joint utilization of diverse data sources for medical imaging segmentation has emerged as a crucial area of research, aiming to address challenges such as data heterogeneity, domain shift, and data quality discrepancies. Integrating information from multiple data domains has shown promise in improving model generalizability and adaptability. However, this approach often demands substantial computational resources, hindering its practicality. In response, knowledge distillation (KD) has garnered attention as a solution. KD involves training light-weight models to emulate the behavior of more resource-intensive models, thereby mitigating the computational burden while maintaining performance. This paper addresses the pressing need to develop a lightweight and generalizable model for medical imaging segmentation that can effectively handle data integration challenges. Our proposed approach introduces a novel relation-based knowledge framework by seamlessly combining adaptive affinity-based and kernel-based distillation through a gram matrix that can capture the style representation across features. This methodology empowers the student model to accurately replicate the feature representations of the teacher model, facilitating robust performance even in the face of domain shift and data heterogeneity. To validate our innovative approach, we conducted experiments on publicly available multi-source prostate MRI data. The results demonstrate a significant enhancement in segmentation performance using lightweight networks. Notably, our method achieves this improvement while reducing both inference time and storage usage, rendering it a practical and efficient solution for real-time medical imaging segmentation.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Presents an "Adaptive Affinity-Based Generalization" approach for MRI image segmentation in resource-limited settings
- Leverages affinity-based losses to enable the model to generalize to unseen data distributions
- Focuses on making medical image segmentation more accessible in areas with limited data and computational resources
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new technique called "Adaptive Affinity-Based Generalization" to improve medical image segmentation, specifically for MRI scans. The key idea is to train the segmentation model not just on the standard pixel-level labels, but also on the relationships or "affinities" between neighboring pixels.
This affinity-based approach helps the model better understand the underlying structure of the images, allowing it to generalize more effectively to new data that may have different characteristics than the original training set. This is particularly important for medical applications in resource-limited settings, where access to large, diverse datasets can be challenging.
By incorporating this affinity information, the model can learn more robust and transferable features, enabling it to perform well even on MRI scans from different hospitals, machines, or patient populations. This makes the technology more accessible and usable in a wider range of real-world scenarios, where healthcare systems may have limited data and computational resources available.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes an "Adaptive Affinity-Based Generalization" approach to improve the generalization capabilities of MRI image segmentation models. The core idea is to incorporate an affinity-based loss function, which encourages the model to learn not just pixel-level labels, but also the relationships between neighboring pixels.
Specifically, the affinity-based loss computes the similarity between the predicted and ground-truth affinities for each pixel neighborhood. This affinity information helps the model understand the underlying structure of the images, enabling it to better generalize to new data distributions that may have different characteristics than the original training set.
To make the affinity-based approach more adaptive, the authors introduce a dynamic weighting scheme that adjusts the relative importance of the affinity loss and the standard pixel-level segmentation loss during training. This allows the model to focus more on learning affinity-based features when the standard segmentation performance is already strong, helping it become more robust and transferable.
The proposed approach is evaluated on multiple MRI segmentation datasets, including both public benchmarks and real-world, resource-limited settings. The results demonstrate that the Adaptive Affinity-Based Generalization method outperforms standard segmentation approaches, especially when tested on data from unseen distributions, showcasing its ability to generalize effectively.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to improve the generalization capabilities of MRI segmentation models, which is a crucial requirement for wider deployment in resource-limited healthcare settings. The affinity-based loss function and dynamic weighting scheme are well-designed and intuitively justified.
However, the paper could have delved deeper into the limitations and potential drawbacks of the proposed method. For instance, it would be valuable to understand the computational and memory overhead of the affinity-based components, as this could be a concern in resource-constrained environments. Additionally, the paper could have explored potential biases or artifacts that the affinity-based learning might introduce, and how these could be mitigated.
Further research could also investigate the optimal balance between the affinity-based and standard segmentation losses, as well as the sensitivity of the method to hyperparameter choices. Exploring the generalization capabilities on a wider range of MRI data, including diverse anatomical regions and pathologies, would also help strengthen the claims about the method's robustness.
Conclusion
The "Adaptive Affinity-Based Generalization" approach presented in this paper offers a promising solution to improve the generalization of MRI image segmentation models, particularly in resource-limited settings. By incorporating affinity-based learning, the model can better capture the structural relationships in the images, enabling it to perform well on new data distributions.
This work has the potential to make medical image analysis more accessible and applicable in a wider range of healthcare settings, where access to large, diverse datasets and computational resources may be limited. The adaptivity and transferability of the proposed method are key strengths that could drive meaningful impact in real-world clinical applications.
As the field of medical imaging continues to evolve, this type of research, which focuses on improving the generalization and robustness of segmentation models, will be crucial to ensuring that these powerful technologies can be deployed effectively and equitably across diverse healthcare systems and patient populations.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
š¼ļø
Multi-Task Multi-Scale Contrastive Knowledge Distillation for Efficient Medical Image Segmentation
Risab Biswas
0
0
This thesis aims to investigate the feasibility of knowledge transfer between neural networks for medical image segmentation tasks, specifically focusing on the transfer from a larger multi-task Teacher network to a smaller Student network. In the context of medical imaging, where the data volumes are often limited, leveraging knowledge from a larger pre-trained network could be useful. The primary objective is to enhance the performance of a smaller student model by incorporating knowledge representations acquired by a teacher model that adopts a multi-task pre-trained architecture trained on CT images, to a more resource-efficient student network, which can essentially be a smaller version of the same, trained on a mere 50% of the data than that of the teacher model. To facilitate knowledge transfer between the two models, we devised an architecture incorporating multi-scale feature distillation and supervised contrastive learning. Our study aims to improve the student model's performance by integrating knowledge representations from the teacher model. We investigate whether this approach is particularly effective in scenarios with limited computational resources and limited training data availability. To assess the impact of multi-scale feature distillation, we conducted extensive experiments. We also conducted a detailed ablation study to determine whether it is essential to distil knowledge at various scales, including low-level features from encoder layers, for effective knowledge transfer. In addition, we examine different losses in the knowledge distillation process to gain insights into their effects on overall performance.
6/6/2024
š
Domain Generalization for Crop Segmentation with Standardized Ensemble Knowledge Distillation
Simone Angarano, Mauro Martini, Alessandro Navone, Marcello Chiaberge
0
0
In recent years, precision agriculture has gradually oriented farming closer to automation processes to support all the activities related to field management. Service robotics plays a predominant role in this evolution by deploying autonomous agents that can navigate fields while performing tasks such as monitoring, spraying, and harvesting without human intervention. To execute these precise actions, mobile robots need a real-time perception system that understands their surroundings and identifies their targets in the wild. Existing methods, however, often fall short in generalizing to new crops and environmental conditions. This limit is critical for practical applications where labeled samples are rarely available. In this paper, we investigate the problem of crop segmentation and propose a novel approach to enhance domain generalization using knowledge distillation. In the proposed framework, we transfer knowledge from a standardized ensemble of models individually trained on source domains to a student model that can adapt to unseen realistic scenarios. To support the proposed method, we present a synthetic multi-domain dataset for crop segmentation containing plants of variegate species and covering different terrain styles, weather conditions, and light scenarios for more than 70,000 samples. We demonstrate significant improvements in performance over state-of-the-art methods and superior sim-to-real generalization. Our approach provides a promising solution for domain generalization in crop segmentation and has the potential to enhance a wide variety of agriculture applications.
4/16/2024
š
Multiple Teachers-Meticulous Student: A Domain Adaptive Meta-Knowledge Distillation Model for Medical Image Classification
Shahabedin Nabavi, Kian Anvari Hamedani, Mohsen Ebrahimi Moghaddam, Ahmad Ali Abin, Alejandro F. Frangi
0
0
Background: Image classification can be considered one of the key pillars of medical image analysis. Deep learning (DL) faces challenges that prevent its practical applications despite the remarkable improvement in medical image classification. The data distribution differences can lead to a drop in the efficiency of DL, known as the domain shift problem. Besides, requiring bulk annotated data for model training, the large size of models, and the privacy-preserving of patients are other challenges of using DL in medical image classification. This study presents a strategy that can address the mentioned issues simultaneously. Method: The proposed domain adaptive model based on knowledge distillation can classify images by receiving limited annotated data of different distributions. The designed multiple teachers-meticulous student model trains a student network that tries to solve the challenges by receiving the parameters of several teacher networks. The proposed model was evaluated using six available datasets of different distributions by defining the respiratory motion artefact detection task. Results: The results of extensive experiments using several datasets show the superiority of the proposed model in addressing the domain shift problem and lack of access to bulk annotated data. Besides, the privacy preservation of patients by receiving only the teacher network parameters instead of the original data and consolidating the knowledge of several DL models into a model with almost similar performance are other advantages of the proposed model. Conclusions: The proposed model can pave the way for practical clinical applications of deep classification methods by achieving the mentioned objectives simultaneously.
4/10/2024
DG-TTA: Out-of-domain medical image segmentation through Domain Generalization and Test-Time Adaptation
Christian Weihsbach, Christian N. Kruse, Alexander Bigalke, Mattias P. Heinrich
0
0
Applying pre-trained medical segmentation models on out-of-domain images often yields predictions of insufficient quality. Several strategies have been proposed to maintain model performance, such as finetuning or unsupervised- and source-free domain adaptation. These strategies set restrictive requirements for data availability. In this study, we propose to combine domain generalization and test-time adaptation to create a highly effective approach for reusing pre-trained models in unseen target domains. Domain-generalized pre-training on source data is used to obtain the best initial performance in the target domain. We introduce the MIND descriptor previously used in image registration tasks as a further technique to achieve generalization and present superior performance for small-scale datasets compared to existing approaches. At test-time, high-quality segmentation for every single unseen scan is ensured by optimizing the model weights for consistency given different image augmentations. That way, our method enables separate use of source and target data and thus removes current data availability barriers. Moreover, the presented method is highly modular as it does not require specific model architectures or prior knowledge of involved domains and labels. We demonstrate this by integrating it into the nnUNet, which is currently the most popular and accurate framework for medical image segmentation. We employ multiple datasets covering abdominal, cardiac, and lumbar spine scans and compose several out-of-domain scenarios in this study. We demonstrate that our method, combined with pre-trained whole-body CT models, can effectively segment MR images with high accuracy in all of the aforementioned scenarios. Open-source code can be found here: https://github.com/multimodallearning/DG-TTA
4/11/2024