Adaptive Federated Learning in Heterogeneous Wireless Networks with Independent Sampling

Overview

• Federated Learning (FL) algorithms often sample a subset of clients to address the straggler issue and improve communication efficiency.
• Recent works have proposed various client sampling methods, but they have limitations in jointly addressing system and data heterogeneity.
• This paper advocates a new independent client sampling strategy to minimize the wall-clock training time of FL, considering both data and system heterogeneity.

Plain English Explanation

Federated Learning (FL) is a way for multiple devices, like phones or computers, to collaboratively train a machine learning model without sharing their private data. In traditional FL, a central server will randomly select a subset of devices to participate in each training round, to avoid slow or unreliable devices (known as "stragglers") from slowing down the overall training process.

However, the current client selection methods don't fully account for the fact that different devices may have very different computing power and network speeds (system heterogeneity), as well as different types of data (data heterogeneity). This can still impact the overall training time and performance.

This paper proposes a new independent client sampling strategy that tries to address both system and data heterogeneity. The key idea is to carefully select which devices participate in each round, based on an analysis of how long each device is likely to take to complete a training round and how much their data differs from the average. This allows the system to minimize the total training time while still respecting the privacy constraints of Federated Learning.

Technical Explanation

The paper first derives a new convergence bound for non-convex loss functions with independent client sampling. This provides a theoretical foundation for understanding the impacts of the proposed sampling strategy.

The authors then propose an adaptive bandwidth allocation scheme, which dynamically adjusts the network resources assigned to each participating client based on their system characteristics. This helps mitigate the impact of system heterogeneity.

Building on these insights, the paper introduces an efficient independent client sampling algorithm. This algorithm selects clients to participate in each round based on upper bounds for the convergence rounds and expected per-round training time. The goal is to minimize the overall wall-clock training time while accounting for both data and system heterogeneity.

The proposed approach is evaluated under practical wireless network settings using real-world prototypes. The experiments show that the independent sampling scheme substantially outperforms current state-of-the-art sampling methods across various training models and datasets. This demonstrates the effectiveness of jointly considering system and data heterogeneity in the client sampling process for Federated Learning.

Critical Analysis

The paper addresses an important practical challenge in Federated Learning - how to effectively sample clients to participate in the training process when there is significant heterogeneity in both the data and system characteristics of the participating devices.

The theoretical analysis and proposed adaptive sampling algorithm provide a solid foundation for tackling this problem. However, the paper does not discuss some potential limitations or caveats:

• The analysis assumes certain simplifying conditions, such as non-convex loss functions, that may not always hold in real-world scenarios.
• The adaptive bandwidth allocation scheme relies on accurate modeling of device characteristics, which may be difficult to obtain in practice.
• The evaluation is limited to simulated wireless network settings and may not fully capture the complexities of real-world deployment.

Further research could explore relaxing some of these assumptions, as well as investigating the performance of the proposed approach in more diverse and realistic deployment settings. Conducting user studies to understand the practical concerns and challenges faced by FL practitioners would also be valuable.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel independent client sampling strategy for Federated Learning that aims to minimize the overall training time by jointly considering system and data heterogeneity. The theoretical analysis, adaptive bandwidth allocation, and efficient sampling algorithm provide a promising approach to improving the practicality and performance of Federated Learning in real-world, resource-constrained environments.

The key contribution is the insight that carefully selecting which clients participate in each training round, based on both their computational/network capabilities and the uniqueness of their data, can lead to significant improvements in the overall training efficiency of Federated Learning systems. This work represents an important step forward in addressing the practical challenges of deploying FL in diverse, heterogeneous settings.