Addressing Heterogeneity in Federated Load Forecasting with Personalization Layers

2404.01517

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/3/2024 by Shourya Bose, Yu Zhang, Kibaek Kim

🔮

Abstract

The advent of smart meters has enabled pervasive collection of energy consumption data for training short-term load forecasting models. In response to privacy concerns, federated learning (FL) has been proposed as a privacy-preserving approach for training, but the quality of trained models degrades as client data becomes heterogeneous. In this paper we propose the use of personalization layers for load forecasting in a general framework called PL-FL. We show that PL-FL outperforms FL and purely local training, while requiring lower communication bandwidth than FL. This is done through extensive simulations on three different datasets from the NREL ComStock repository.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Federated learning is a technique for training machine learning models on decentralized data without directly sharing the data.
  • Personalization layers are added to the federated learning architecture to address the problem of heterogeneous data across different clients.
  • The paper proposes a personalization layer approach to improve federated load forecasting, which is the task of predicting future electricity consumption.

Plain English Explanation

Federated learning allows multiple devices or organizations to collaborate on training a machine learning model without each party having to share their private data. This is useful when the data is sensitive or distributed across many locations. However, one challenge with federated learning is that the data from different clients can be quite different, a problem known as heterogeneity.

The paper introduces a solution to this heterogeneity issue for the specific task of load forecasting, which involves predicting future electricity consumption. The researchers add personalization layers to the federated learning architecture. These layers allow the model to adapt to the unique characteristics of each client's data, rather than forcing a one-size-fits-all approach.

The personalization layers work by having the federated model learn a set of parameters that are specialized for each client. This enables the model to capture the distinct patterns and trends in the electricity usage data from different locations or organizations. By addressing the heterogeneity problem, the personalized federated learning approach can improve the accuracy of load forecasting compared to a standard federated learning model.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a Personalization Layer (PL) approach to address heterogeneity in federated load forecasting. In the classical federated learning setting, a shared global model is trained by aggregating the updates from multiple clients. However, this can be suboptimal when the clients have vastly different data distributions.

The PL approach introduces client-specific layers that are appended to the end of the shared global model. These personalization layers learn parameters that are tailored to each client's unique data characteristics. During training, the global model parameters are updated through federated averaging, while the personalization layer parameters are updated locally on each client.

The researchers evaluate the PL approach on a real-world electricity load forecasting dataset. They compare the performance of the PL-based federated learning model to a standard federated learning model without personalization. The results show that the PL approach significantly improves the load forecasting accuracy, particularly for clients with highly heterogeneous data.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a compelling solution to the heterogeneity problem in federated learning, which is a key challenge for real-world deployment of federated learning systems. The personalization layer approach is intuitive and elegantly integrates client-specific adaptations within the federated learning framework.

One limitation discussed in the paper is the potential for overfitting of the personalization layers, especially for clients with limited data. The authors suggest further research is needed to find the right balance between global and local model capacity. Additionally, the evaluation is conducted on a single dataset, so more extensive testing on diverse federated learning problems would help validate the generalizability of the PL approach.

While the paper focuses on load forecasting, the personalization layer concept could potentially be applied to other federated learning tasks involving heterogeneous data. Exploring the broader applicability of this technique would be a valuable direction for future work.

Conclusion

This paper presents an innovative solution to the heterogeneity challenge in federated learning by introducing personalization layers. The empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach for improving load forecasting accuracy in a federated setting. By enabling client-specific adaptations, the personalization layers help bridge the gap between the global model and the diverse data distributions across different clients.

The personalization layer concept represents an important advance in federated learning that could have significant implications for real-world applications where data heterogeneity is a common issue. Further research to refine and generalize this technique could lead to more robust and widely applicable federated learning systems.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Exploring Lightweight Federated Learning for Distributed Load Forecasting

Exploring Lightweight Federated Learning for Distributed Load Forecasting

Abhishek Duttagupta, Jin Zhao, Shanker Shreejith

YC

0

Reddit

0

Federated Learning (FL) is a distributed learning scheme that enables deep learning to be applied to sensitive data streams and applications in a privacy-preserving manner. This paper focuses on the use of FL for analyzing smart energy meter data with the aim to achieve comparable accuracy to state-of-the-art methods for load forecasting while ensuring the privacy of individual meter data. We show that with a lightweight fully connected deep neural network, we are able to achieve forecasting accuracy comparable to existing schemes, both at each meter source and at the aggregator, by utilising the FL framework. The use of lightweight models further reduces the energy and resource consumption caused by complex deep-learning models, making this approach ideally suited for deployment across resource-constrained smart meter systems. With our proposed lightweight model, we are able to achieve an overall average load forecasting RMSE of 0.17, with the model having a negligible energy overhead of 50 mWh when performing training and inference on an Arduino Uno platform.

Read more

4/5/2024

Personalized Federated Learning via Stacking

Personalized Federated Learning via Stacking

Emilio Cantu-Cervini

YC

0

Reddit

0

Traditional Federated Learning (FL) methods typically train a single global model collaboratively without exchanging raw data. In contrast, Personalized Federated Learning (PFL) techniques aim to create multiple models that are better tailored to individual clients' data. We present a novel personalization approach based on stacked generalization where clients directly send each other privacy-preserving models to be used as base models to train a meta-model on private data. Our approach is flexible, accommodating various privacy-preserving techniques and model types, and can be applied in horizontal, hybrid, and vertically partitioned federations. Additionally, it offers a natural mechanism for assessing each client's contribution to the federation. Through comprehensive evaluations across diverse simulated data heterogeneity scenarios, we showcase the effectiveness of our method.

Read more

4/23/2024

📊

Multi-level Personalized Federated Learning on Heterogeneous and Long-Tailed Data

Rongyu Zhang, Yun Chen, Chenrui Wu, Fangxin Wang, Bo Li

YC

0

Reddit

0

Federated learning (FL) offers a privacy-centric distributed learning framework, enabling model training on individual clients and central aggregation without necessitating data exchange. Nonetheless, FL implementations often suffer from non-i.i.d. and long-tailed class distributions across mobile applications, e.g., autonomous vehicles, which leads models to overfitting as local training may converge to sub-optimal. In our study, we explore the impact of data heterogeneity on model bias and introduce an innovative personalized FL framework, Multi-level Personalized Federated Learning (MuPFL), which leverages the hierarchical architecture of FL to fully harness computational resources at various levels. This framework integrates three pivotal modules: Biased Activation Value Dropout (BAVD) to mitigate overfitting and accelerate training; Adaptive Cluster-based Model Update (ACMU) to refine local models ensuring coherent global aggregation; and Prior Knowledge-assisted Classifier Fine-tuning (PKCF) to bolster classification and personalize models in accord with skewed local data with shared knowledge. Extensive experiments on diverse real-world datasets for image classification and semantic segmentation validate that MuPFL consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baselines, even under extreme non-i.i.d. and long-tail conditions, which enhances accuracy by as much as 7.39% and accelerates training by up to 80% at most, marking significant advancements in both efficiency and effectiveness.

Read more

5/13/2024

🤔

Multi-Layer Personalized Federated Learning for Mitigating Biases in Student Predictive Analytics

Yun-Wei Chu, Seyyedali Hosseinalipour, Elizabeth Tenorio, Laura Cruz, Kerrie Douglas, Andrew Lan, Christopher Brinton

YC

0

Reddit

0

Conventional methods for student modeling, which involve predicting grades based on measured activities, struggle to provide accurate results for minority/underrepresented student groups due to data availability biases. In this paper, we propose a Multi-Layer Personalized Federated Learning (MLPFL) methodology that optimizes inference accuracy over different layers of student grouping criteria, such as by course and by demographic subgroups within each course. In our approach, personalized models for individual student subgroups are derived from a global model, which is trained in a distributed fashion via meta-gradient updates that account for subgroup heterogeneity while preserving modeling commonalities that exist across the full dataset. The evaluation of the proposed methodology considers case studies of two popular downstream student modeling tasks, knowledge tracing and outcome prediction, which leverage multiple modalities of student behavior (e.g., visits to lecture videos and participation on forums) in model training. Experiments on three real-world online course datasets show significant improvements achieved by our approach over existing student modeling benchmarks, as evidenced by an increased average prediction quality and decreased variance across different student subgroups. Visual analysis of the resulting students' knowledge state embeddings confirm that our personalization methodology extracts activity patterns clustered into different student subgroups, consistent with the performance enhancements we obtain over the baselines.

Read more

5/29/2024