Multi-level Personalized Federated Learning on Heterogeneous and Long-Tailed Data
2405.06413
0
0
📊
Abstract
Federated learning (FL) offers a privacy-centric distributed learning framework, enabling model training on individual clients and central aggregation without necessitating data exchange. Nonetheless, FL implementations often suffer from non-i.i.d. and long-tailed class distributions across mobile applications, e.g., autonomous vehicles, which leads models to overfitting as local training may converge to sub-optimal. In our study, we explore the impact of data heterogeneity on model bias and introduce an innovative personalized FL framework, Multi-level Personalized Federated Learning (MuPFL), which leverages the hierarchical architecture of FL to fully harness computational resources at various levels. This framework integrates three pivotal modules: Biased Activation Value Dropout (BAVD) to mitigate overfitting and accelerate training; Adaptive Cluster-based Model Update (ACMU) to refine local models ensuring coherent global aggregation; and Prior Knowledge-assisted Classifier Fine-tuning (PKCF) to bolster classification and personalize models in accord with skewed local data with shared knowledge. Extensive experiments on diverse real-world datasets for image classification and semantic segmentation validate that MuPFL consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baselines, even under extreme non-i.i.d. and long-tail conditions, which enhances accuracy by as much as 7.39% and accelerates training by up to 80% at most, marking significant advancements in both efficiency and effectiveness.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the impact of data heterogeneity on model bias in federated learning (FL) and introduces an innovative personalized FL framework called Multi-level Personalized Federated Learning (MuPFL).
- MuPFL leverages the hierarchical architecture of FL to harness computational resources at various levels and integrates three key modules to address the challenges of non-i.i.d. and long-tailed class distributions in mobile applications.
Plain English Explanation
Federated learning is a way of training machine learning models that doesn't require sharing the original data. Instead, the data stays on individual devices (like smartphones or autonomous vehicles), and the model is trained on that local data. Then, the updated models from all the devices are combined to create a single, improved model.
However, this approach can run into problems when the data on the different devices is quite different (known as "non-i.i.d. data"). For example, if some devices are used for urban driving and others are used for rural driving, the data and patterns the model sees will be very different. This can cause the model to become biased or perform poorly on certain types of data.
The MuPFL framework aims to address this by introducing three key innovations:
- Biased Activation Value Dropout (BAVD): This technique helps mitigate overfitting and accelerate the training process by selectively dropping out certain activation values in the neural network.
- Adaptive Cluster-based Model Update (ACMU): This module refines the local models to ensure coherent global aggregation, helping to address the challenges posed by non-i.i.d. and long-tailed data distributions.
- Prior Knowledge-assisted Classifier Fine-tuning (PKCF): This component bolsters the classification performance and personalizes the models based on the skewed local data, while also leveraging shared knowledge across devices.
By integrating these three innovations, the MuPFL framework aims to improve the accuracy and efficiency of federated learning, even in the face of challenging data heterogeneity, such as that found in autonomous vehicles or other mobile applications.
Technical Explanation
The MuPFL framework builds on the hierarchical structure of federated learning to address the challenges of non-i.i.d. and long-tailed data distributions. The authors introduce three key modules:
-
Biased Activation Value Dropout (BAVD): This technique selectively drops out certain activation values in the neural network to mitigate overfitting and accelerate the training process. By identifying and masking biased activations, BAVD helps the model generalize better and converge faster, even in the presence of non-i.i.d. data.
-
Adaptive Cluster-based Model Update (ACMU): This module refines the local models to ensure coherent global aggregation. ACMU dynamically clusters the client models based on their similarities and updates them accordingly, helping to address the challenges posed by long-tailed class distributions.
-
Prior Knowledge-assisted Classifier Fine-tuning (PKCF): This component bolsters the classification performance and personalizes the models based on the skewed local data. PKCF leverages shared knowledge across devices to fine-tune the local classifiers, improving accuracy on the clients' unique data distributions.
The authors evaluate the MuPFL framework on diverse real-world datasets for image classification and semantic segmentation, comparing it to state-of-the-art baselines. The results show that MuPFL consistently outperforms the baselines, even under extreme non-i.i.d. and long-tail conditions, improving accuracy by up to 7.39% and accelerating training by up to 80%.
Critical Analysis
The MuPFL framework presents a promising approach to addressing the challenges of data heterogeneity in federated learning. By leveraging the hierarchical structure of FL and integrating innovative modules, the authors demonstrate significant improvements in both efficiency and effectiveness.
However, the paper does not address the potential computational and communication overhead associated with the additional modules, which could be a concern for resource-constrained devices. Additionally, the authors mention the need for further research on the scalability of the framework and its applicability to other domains beyond image and semantic segmentation tasks.
The paper also does not discuss the potential privacy implications of the personalization techniques, as the sharing of certain model parameters or classifier fine-tuning information could raise privacy concerns. Addressing these aspects in future research would help strengthen the practical applicability of the MuPFL framework.
Conclusion
The MuPFL framework presented in this paper offers a promising solution to the challenges of data heterogeneity in federated learning. By leveraging the hierarchical structure of FL and integrating innovative modules like BAVD, ACMU, and PKCF, the authors demonstrate significant improvements in both accuracy and training efficiency, even under extreme non-i.i.d. and long-tail conditions.
This research represents an important step forward in enhancing the robustness and personalization capabilities of federated learning, which could have far-reaching implications for a wide range of applications, from autonomous vehicles to personalized language models and adaptive feature mixtures. As the field of federated learning continues to evolve, the MuPFL framework and its underlying principles could serve as a valuable foundation for inclusive non-i.i.d. data handling and enhancing the efficiency of multi-device federated learning.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤔
Multi-Layer Personalized Federated Learning for Mitigating Biases in Student Predictive Analytics
Yun-Wei Chu, Seyyedali Hosseinalipour, Elizabeth Tenorio, Laura Cruz, Kerrie Douglas, Andrew Lan, Christopher Brinton
0
0
Conventional methods for student modeling, which involve predicting grades based on measured activities, struggle to provide accurate results for minority/underrepresented student groups due to data availability biases. In this paper, we propose a Multi-Layer Personalized Federated Learning (MLPFL) methodology that optimizes inference accuracy over different layers of student grouping criteria, such as by course and by demographic subgroups within each course. In our approach, personalized models for individual student subgroups are derived from a global model, which is trained in a distributed fashion via meta-gradient updates that account for subgroup heterogeneity while preserving modeling commonalities that exist across the full dataset. The evaluation of the proposed methodology considers case studies of two popular downstream student modeling tasks, knowledge tracing and outcome prediction, which leverage multiple modalities of student behavior (e.g., visits to lecture videos and participation on forums) in model training. Experiments on three real-world online course datasets show significant improvements achieved by our approach over existing student modeling benchmarks, as evidenced by an increased average prediction quality and decreased variance across different student subgroups. Visual analysis of the resulting students' knowledge state embeddings confirm that our personalization methodology extracts activity patterns clustered into different student subgroups, consistent with the performance enhancements we obtain over the baselines.
5/29/2024
FedMAP: Unlocking Potential in Personalized Federated Learning through Bi-Level MAP Optimization
Fan Zhang, Carlos Esteve-Yague, Soren Dittmer, Carola-Bibiane Schonlieb, Michael Roberts
0
0
Federated Learning (FL) enables collaborative training of machine learning models on decentralized data while preserving data privacy. However, data across clients often differs significantly due to class imbalance, feature distribution skew, sample size imbalance, and other phenomena. Leveraging information from these not identically distributed (non-IID) datasets poses substantial challenges. FL methods based on a single global model cannot effectively capture the variations in client data and underperform in non-IID settings. Consequently, Personalized FL (PFL) approaches that adapt to each client's data distribution but leverage other clients' data are essential but currently underexplored. We propose a novel Bayesian PFL framework using bi-level optimization to tackle the data heterogeneity challenges. Our proposed framework utilizes the global model as a prior distribution within a Maximum A Posteriori (MAP) estimation of personalized client models. This approach facilitates PFL by integrating shared knowledge from the prior, thereby enhancing local model performance, generalization ability, and communication efficiency. We extensively evaluated our bi-level optimization approach on real-world and synthetic datasets, demonstrating significant improvements in model accuracy compared to existing methods while reducing communication overhead. This study contributes to PFL by establishing a solid theoretical foundation for the proposed method and offering a robust, ready-to-use framework that effectively addresses the challenges posed by non-IID data in FL.
5/30/2024
📈
MH-pFLID: Model Heterogeneous personalized Federated Learning via Injection and Distillation for Medical Data Analysis
Luyuan Xie, Manqing Lin, Tianyu Luan, Cong Li, Yuejian Fang, Qingni Shen, Zhonghai Wu
0
0
Federated learning is widely used in medical applications for training global models without needing local data access. However, varying computational capabilities and network architectures (system heterogeneity), across clients pose significant challenges in effectively aggregating information from non-independently and identically distributed (non-IID) data. Current federated learning methods using knowledge distillation require public datasets, raising privacy and data collection issues. Additionally, these datasets require additional local computing and storage resources, which is a burden for medical institutions with limited hardware conditions. In this paper, we introduce a novel federated learning paradigm, named Model Heterogeneous personalized Federated Learning via Injection and Distillation (MH-pFLID). Our framework leverages a lightweight messenger model that carries concentrated information to collect the information from each client. We also develop a set of receiver and transmitter modules to receive and send information from the messenger model, so that the information could be injected and distilled with efficiency.
5/14/2024
Personalized Federated Learning via Stacking
Emilio Cantu-Cervini
0
0
Traditional Federated Learning (FL) methods typically train a single global model collaboratively without exchanging raw data. In contrast, Personalized Federated Learning (PFL) techniques aim to create multiple models that are better tailored to individual clients' data. We present a novel personalization approach based on stacked generalization where clients directly send each other privacy-preserving models to be used as base models to train a meta-model on private data. Our approach is flexible, accommodating various privacy-preserving techniques and model types, and can be applied in horizontal, hybrid, and vertically partitioned federations. Additionally, it offers a natural mechanism for assessing each client's contribution to the federation. Through comprehensive evaluations across diverse simulated data heterogeneity scenarios, we showcase the effectiveness of our method.
4/23/2024