Advancing Transportation Mode Share Analysis with Built Environment: Deep Hybrid Models with Urban Road Network
0
🤿
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Transportation mode share analysis helps researchers understand passenger travel behaviors and choices
- Existing models often focus on sociodemographic factors and travel mode attributes, but lack integration of the urban built environment
- This study proposes deep hybrid models (DHM) that combine road networks and sociodemographic features to improve travel mode share prediction
Plain English Explanation
Transportation mode share analysis is important for understanding how people choose to travel, whether by car, public transit, walking, or other options. Researchers often try to predict mode share by looking at factors like a community's age, income, and the characteristics of different travel modes, such as cost and travel time. However, these models don't always capture the impact of the built environment, like the road network, on travel choices.
In this study, the researchers developed a new approach called deep hybrid models (DHM) that directly incorporates information about road networks along with sociodemographic data. By using graph embedding techniques to represent the urban structure, the DHM model can provide more powerful and insightful predictions of travel mode share at the city level. The researchers tested their approach in Chicago and found that DHM improved mode share prediction by over 20% compared to existing models, while also providing valuable spatial insights into how the built environment and demographics influence travel behavior.
Technical Explanation
The researchers propose a deep hybrid model (DHM) that combines road network information and sociodemographic features as inputs for travel mode share analysis. They use graph embedding (GE) techniques to represent the urban built environment in a way that can be integrated with traditional travel demand modeling approaches.
In experiments predicting mode share in Chicago, the DHM model outperformed existing methods by more than 20% in accuracy. Crucially, the DHM approach also retained the interpretability of choice models, allowing the researchers to gain valuable spatial insights into how the sociodemographic structure and urban design features influence travel mode selection across the city.
This integration of graph-based representations of the built environment with sociodemographic data represents an advance over previous travel demand models that have struggled to capture the impacts of urban structure. The improved performance and interpretability of the DHM model demonstrate its potential to provide city planners and transportation agencies with a more powerful tool for understanding and predicting travel behavior.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling demonstration of how incorporating urban built environment features, through the use of graph embedding techniques, can enhance travel mode share prediction models. The authors highlight the importance of going beyond just sociodemographic factors and travel mode attributes to capture the influence of the physical infrastructure on travel choices.
However, the study is limited to a single city context (Chicago), and further research would be needed to assess the generalizability of the DHM approach to other urban areas with potentially different built environments and travel patterns. Additionally, the paper does not address potential biases or limitations in the data sources used to train and evaluate the models.
While the interpretability of the DHM model is cited as a key advantage, the specific mechanisms by which the spatial insights are derived and communicated could be further explored. Readers may be interested in seeing more detailed visualizations or explanations of how the model's internal representations translate to an understanding of travel behavior across the city.
Overall, this study represents an important step forward in integrating the built environment into travel demand modeling, and the DHM approach offers promising directions for future research and application in transportation planning and policy.
Conclusion
This study introduces a deep hybrid model (DHM) that combines road network information and sociodemographic data to improve the prediction of travel mode share at the city level. By leveraging graph embedding techniques to represent the urban built environment, the DHM model outperforms traditional approaches and provides valuable spatial insights into how the physical infrastructure and population characteristics influence travel behaviors.
The successful demonstration of the DHM model in the Chicago context suggests its potential to become a more powerful tool for transportation planning and policy, allowing decision-makers to better understand and anticipate the factors shaping travel mode choices across a city. Further research to evaluate the model's generalizability and interpretability in other urban settings could help unlock new applications and real-world impacts of this innovative approach to transportation mode share analysis.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
0
Advancing Transportation Mode Share Analysis with Built Environment: Deep Hybrid Models with Urban Road Network
Dingyi Zhuang, Qingyi Wang, Yunhan Zheng, Xiaotong Guo, Shenhao Wang, Haris N Koutsopoulos, Jinhua Zhao
Transportation mode share analysis is important to various real-world transportation tasks as it helps researchers understand the travel behaviors and choices of passengers. A typical example is the prediction of communities' travel mode share by accounting for their sociodemographics like age, income, etc., and travel modes' attributes (e.g. travel cost and time). However, there exist only limited efforts in integrating the structure of the urban built environment, e.g., road networks, into the mode share models to capture the impacts of the built environment. This task usually requires manual feature engineering or prior knowledge of the urban design features. In this study, we propose deep hybrid models (DHM), which directly combine road networks and sociodemographic features as inputs for travel mode share analysis. Using graph embedding (GE) techniques, we enhance travel demand models with a more powerful representation of urban structures. In experiments of mode share prediction in Chicago, results demonstrate that DHM can provide valuable spatial insights into the sociodemographic structure, improving the performance of travel demand models in estimating different mode shares at the city level. Specifically, DHM improves the results by more than 20% while retaining the interpretation power of the choice models, demonstrating its superiority in interpretability, prediction accuracy, and geographical insights.
Read more5/24/2024
0
Combining data from multiple sources for urban travel mode choice modelling
Maciej Grzenda, Marcin Luckner, Jakub Zawieska, Przemys{l}aw Wrona
Demand for sustainable mobility is particularly high in urban areas. Hence, there is a growing need to predict when people will decide to use different travel modes with an emphasis on environmentally friendly travel modes. As travel mode choice (TMC) is influenced by multiple factors, in a growing number of cases machine learning methods are used to predict travel mode choices given respondent and journey features. Typically, travel diaries are used to provide core relevant data. However, other features such as attributes of mode alternatives including, but not limited to travel times, and, in the case of public transport (PT), also walking distances have a major impact on whether a person decides to use a travel mode of interest. Hence, in this work, we propose an architecture of a software platform performing the data fusion combining data documenting journeys with the features calculated to summarise transport options available for these journeys, built environment and environmental factors such as weather conditions possibly influencing travel mode decisions. Furthermore, we propose various novel features, many of which we show to be among the most important for TMC prediction. We propose how stream processing engines and other Big Data systems can be used for their calculation. The data processed by the platform is used to develop machine learning models predicting travel mode choices. To validate the platform, we propose ablation studies investigating the importance of individual feature subsets calculated by it and their impact on the TMC models built with them. In our experiments, we combine survey data, GPS traces, weather and pollution time series, transport model data, and spatial data of the built environment. The growth in the accuracy of TMC models built with the additional features is up to 18.2% compared to the use of core survey data only.
Read more7/18/2024
0
Urban traffic analysis and forecasting through shared Koopman eigenmodes
Chuhan Yang, Fares B. Mehouachi, Monica Menendez, Saif Eddin Jabari
Predicting traffic flow in data-scarce cities is challenging due to limited historical data. To address this, we leverage transfer learning by identifying periodic patterns common to data-rich cities using a customized variant of Dynamic Mode Decomposition (DMD): constrained Hankelized DMD (TrHDMD). This method uncovers common eigenmodes (urban heartbeats) in traffic patterns and transfers them to data-scarce cities, significantly enhancing prediction performance. TrHDMD reduces the need for extensive training datasets by utilizing prior knowledge from other cities. By applying Koopman operator theory to multi-city loop detector data, we identify stable, interpretable, and time-invariant traffic modes. Injecting ``urban heartbeats'' into forecasting tasks improves prediction accuracy and has the potential to enhance traffic management strategies for cities with varying data infrastructures. Our work introduces cross-city knowledge transfer via shared Koopman eigenmodes, offering actionable insights and reliable forecasts for data-scarce urban environments.
Read more9/10/2024
0
Modeling Urban Transport Choices: Incorporating Sociocultural Aspects
Kathleen Salazar-Serna, Lorena Cadavid, Carlos J. Franco
This paper introduces an agent-based simulation model aimed at understanding urban commuters mode choices and evaluating the impacts of transport policies to promote sustainable mobility. Crafted for developing countries, where utilitarian travel heavily relies on motorcycles, the model integrates sociocultural factors that influence transport behavior. Multinomial models and inferential statistics applied to survey data from Cali, Colombia, inform the model, revealing significant influences of sociodemographic factors and travel attributes on mode choice. Findings highlight the importance of cost, time, safety, comfort, and personal security, with disparities across socioeconomic groups. Policy simulations demonstrate positive responses to interventions like free public transportation, increased bus frequency, and enhanced security, yet with modest shifts in mode choice. Multifaceted policy approaches are deemed more effective, addressing diverse user preferences. Outputs can be extended to cities with similar sociocultural characteristics and transport dynamics. The methodology applied in this work can be replicated for other territories.
Read more8/1/2024