Combining data from multiple sources for urban travel mode choice modelling
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The research paper discusses combining data from multiple sources to model urban travel mode choice.
- It explores how incorporating diverse data can improve the accuracy and robustness of travel mode prediction models.
- The paper examines the potential benefits and challenges of leveraging multi-source data in transportation planning and analysis.
Plain English Explanation
Choosing how to get around a city, whether by walking, driving, public transit, or other means, is an important decision that can impact traffic, the environment, and people's daily lives. Researchers have been working to develop models that can accurately predict which travel modes people will choose for their trips.
This research paper looks at ways to improve these travel mode choice models by combining data from multiple sources. For example, the researchers might use information about a person's age, income, and home and work locations, as well as traffic patterns, weather, and other environmental factors. By bringing together all of this diverse data, the models can make more accurate predictions about how people will choose to travel.
The paper explores the potential benefits of this multi-source data approach, as well as some of the challenges involved in collecting, integrating, and analyzing such a wide range of information. Overall, the goal is to develop more robust and reliable travel models that can help city planners and policymakers make better decisions about transportation infrastructure and services.
Technical Explanation
The research paper examines the use of hybrid-ensemble-based-travel-mode-prediction and advancing-transportation-mode-share-analysis-built-environment techniques to incorporate data from multiple sources for urban travel mode choice modelling.
The authors highlight the potential benefits of leveraging large-language-models-mobility-transportation-systems-survey and modeling-large-scale-walking-cycling-networks-machine to improve the accuracy and robustness of travel mode prediction.
The paper explores strategies for leverage-multi-source-traffic-demand-data-fusion, including the integration of socioeconomic, environmental, and transportation network data. The authors assess the challenges and opportunities of this multi-source data approach through comprehensive experiments and analysis.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges the complexity of travel mode choice and the inherent limitations of any single data source or modelling approach. The authors highlight the need for further research to address issues such as data quality, model interpretability, and scalability to larger geographic areas.
While the proposed multi-source data fusion techniques show promise, the paper does not fully address the practical challenges of implementing such an approach in real-world transportation planning and decision-making. Additional work may be required to streamline the data collection, integration, and model deployment processes.
Furthermore, the paper could have delved deeper into the ethical and privacy implications of leveraging diverse personal and environmental data for travel mode prediction. As these models become more sophisticated, it will be crucial to address concerns around data governance, transparency, and the potential for unintended biases or discrimination.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a compelling case for combining data from multiple sources to enhance urban travel mode choice modelling. By incorporating diverse data, the authors demonstrate the potential to develop more accurate and robust predictive models that can inform transportation planning and policy decisions.
The insights and techniques discussed in the paper contribute to the broader efforts to advancing-transportation-mode-share-analysis-built-environment and leverage large-language-models-mobility-transportation-systems-survey for improved mobility and transportation systems. As the field continues to evolve, ongoing research and thoughtful implementation will be crucial to realizing the full benefits of multi-source data integration for urban travel mode choice modelling.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Combining data from multiple sources for urban travel mode choice modelling
Maciej Grzenda, Marcin Luckner, Jakub Zawieska, Przemys{l}aw Wrona
Demand for sustainable mobility is particularly high in urban areas. Hence, there is a growing need to predict when people will decide to use different travel modes with an emphasis on environmentally friendly travel modes. As travel mode choice (TMC) is influenced by multiple factors, in a growing number of cases machine learning methods are used to predict travel mode choices given respondent and journey features. Typically, travel diaries are used to provide core relevant data. However, other features such as attributes of mode alternatives including, but not limited to travel times, and, in the case of public transport (PT), also walking distances have a major impact on whether a person decides to use a travel mode of interest. Hence, in this work, we propose an architecture of a software platform performing the data fusion combining data documenting journeys with the features calculated to summarise transport options available for these journeys, built environment and environmental factors such as weather conditions possibly influencing travel mode decisions. Furthermore, we propose various novel features, many of which we show to be among the most important for TMC prediction. We propose how stream processing engines and other Big Data systems can be used for their calculation. The data processed by the platform is used to develop machine learning models predicting travel mode choices. To validate the platform, we propose ablation studies investigating the importance of individual feature subsets calculated by it and their impact on the TMC models built with them. In our experiments, we combine survey data, GPS traces, weather and pollution time series, transport model data, and spatial data of the built environment. The growth in the accuracy of TMC models built with the additional features is up to 18.2% compared to the use of core survey data only.
Read more7/18/2024
0
Hybrid Ensemble-Based Travel Mode Prediction
Pawe{l} Golik, Maciej Grzenda, El.zbieta Sienkiewicz
Travel mode choice (TMC) prediction, which can be formulated as a classification task, helps in understanding what makes citizens choose different modes of transport for individual trips. This is also a major step towards fostering sustainable transportation. As behaviour may evolve over time, we also face the question of detecting concept drift in the data. This necessitates using appropriate methods to address potential concept drift. In particular, it is necessary to decide whether batch or stream mining methods should be used to develop periodically updated TMC models. To address the challenge of the development of TMC models, we propose the novel Incremental Ensemble of Batch and Stream Models (IEBSM) method aimed at adapting travel mode choice classifiers to concept drift possibly occurring in the data. It relies on the combination of drift detectors with batch learning and stream mining models. We compare it against batch and incremental learners, including methods relying on active drift detection. Experiments with varied travel mode data sets representing both city and country levels show that the IEBSM method both detects drift in travel mode data and successfully adapts the models to evolving travel mode choice data. The method has a higher rank than batch and stream learners.
Read more4/23/2024
0
Towards Effective Fusion and Forecasting of Multimodal Spatio-temporal Data for Smart Mobility
Chenxing Wang
With the rapid development of location based services, multimodal spatio-temporal (ST) data including trajectories, transportation modes, traffic flow and social check-ins are being collected for deep learning based methods. These deep learning based methods learn ST correlations to support the downstream tasks in the fields such as smart mobility, smart city and other intelligent transportation systems. Despite their effectiveness, ST data fusion and forecasting methods face practical challenges in real-world scenarios. First, forecasting performance for ST data-insufficient area is inferior, making it necessary to transfer meta knowledge from heterogeneous area to enhance the sparse representations. Second, it is nontrivial to accurately forecast in multi-transportation-mode scenarios due to the fine-grained ST features of similar transportation modes, making it necessary to distinguish and measure the ST correlations to alleviate the influence caused by entangled ST features. At last, partial data modalities (e.g., transportation mode) are lost due to privacy or technical issues in certain scenarios, making it necessary to effectively fuse the multimodal sparse ST features and enrich the ST representations. To tackle these challenges, our research work aim to develop effective fusion and forecasting methods for multimodal ST data in smart mobility scenario. In this paper, we will introduce our recent works that investigates the challenges in terms of various real-world applications and establish the open challenges in this field for future work.
Read more7/24/2024
🤿
0
Advancing Transportation Mode Share Analysis with Built Environment: Deep Hybrid Models with Urban Road Network
Dingyi Zhuang, Qingyi Wang, Yunhan Zheng, Xiaotong Guo, Shenhao Wang, Haris N Koutsopoulos, Jinhua Zhao
Transportation mode share analysis is important to various real-world transportation tasks as it helps researchers understand the travel behaviors and choices of passengers. A typical example is the prediction of communities' travel mode share by accounting for their sociodemographics like age, income, etc., and travel modes' attributes (e.g. travel cost and time). However, there exist only limited efforts in integrating the structure of the urban built environment, e.g., road networks, into the mode share models to capture the impacts of the built environment. This task usually requires manual feature engineering or prior knowledge of the urban design features. In this study, we propose deep hybrid models (DHM), which directly combine road networks and sociodemographic features as inputs for travel mode share analysis. Using graph embedding (GE) techniques, we enhance travel demand models with a more powerful representation of urban structures. In experiments of mode share prediction in Chicago, results demonstrate that DHM can provide valuable spatial insights into the sociodemographic structure, improving the performance of travel demand models in estimating different mode shares at the city level. Specifically, DHM improves the results by more than 20% while retaining the interpretation power of the choice models, demonstrating its superiority in interpretability, prediction accuracy, and geographical insights.
Read more5/24/2024