Align and Distill: Unifying and Improving Domain Adaptive Object Detection

Read original: arXiv:2403.12029 - Published 8/27/2024 by Justin Kay, Timm Haucke, Suzanne Stathatos, Siqi Deng, Erik Young, Pietro Perona, Sara Beery, Grant Van Horn
Total Score

0

Align and Distill: Unifying and Improving Domain Adaptive Object Detection

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper presents a new method called Align and Distill (ALDI) for improving domain adaptive object detection.
  • ALDI unifies two key approaches - alignment and distillation - to address the challenges of adapting object detectors to new domains.
  • The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art performance on several benchmark datasets for domain adaptive object detection.

Plain English Explanation

Align and Distill: Unifying and Improving Domain Adaptive Object Detection tackles the problem of domain adaptation in object detection. When an object detector is trained on one dataset (the source domain), its performance often degrades when applied to a different dataset (the target domain) due to differences in things like camera angles, lighting, and object appearances.

The key idea behind ALDI is to combine two powerful techniques - alignment and distillation - to bridge the gap between the source and target domains. Alignment means finding a shared feature representation between the two domains, while distillation involves taking the knowledge from a powerful teacher model and transferring it to a student model. By aligning the feature spaces and distilling knowledge, ALDI is able to significantly improve the performance of the object detector on the target domain.

The paper demonstrates that ALDI outperforms previous state-of-the-art methods on several standard benchmarks for domain adaptive object detection. This suggests ALDI is an effective and versatile approach for making object detectors more robust to domain shifts, which is an important practical challenge.

Technical Explanation

Align and Distill (ALDI): Unifying DAOD is the core contribution of the paper. ALDI combines two complementary strategies:

  1. Alignment: The model learns a shared feature representation between the source and target domains by minimizing the discrepancy between their feature distributions. This enables the detector to recognize objects in a similar way across domains.

  2. Distillation: The model learns from a powerful "teacher" object detector trained on the source domain, transferring its knowledge to a "student" detector for the target domain. This allows the student to benefit from the teacher's strong performance on the source data.

The specific implementation of ALDI involves several loss functions and architectural components:

  • Spatial alignment: Minimizing the discrepancy between the spatial feature maps of the source and target domains.
  • Semantic alignment: Matching the class-specific feature representations across domains.
  • Knowledge distillation: Transferring knowledge from the source-trained teacher detector to the target-specific student detector.

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of ALDI through extensive experiments on multiple domain adaptive object detection benchmarks, showing consistent improvements over prior state-of-the-art methods.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough evaluation of ALDI and compares it against several baselines and prior work. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:

  • Dataset Bias: The paper evaluates ALDI on standard benchmark datasets, but these may not fully capture the diverse range of real-world domain shifts that object detectors need to handle. Further testing on more varied datasets would strengthen the conclusions.

  • Computational Complexity: The combination of alignment and distillation introduces additional computational overhead compared to simpler domain adaptation methods. The trade-off between performance gains and computational cost is not extensively explored.

  • Interpretability: The paper does not provide much insight into why the specific alignment and distillation techniques work well together. A more in-depth analysis of the learned representations and their properties could lead to further improvements.

  • Generalization: While ALDI demonstrates strong results, it is unclear how well the approach would generalize to other computer vision tasks beyond object detection. Investigating the broader applicability of the core ideas could be an interesting direction for future work.

Conclusion

Align and Distill: Unifying and Improving Domain Adaptive Object Detection presents a novel method called ALDI that combines alignment and distillation to significantly improve the performance of object detectors on target domains. By unifying these two complementary strategies, ALDI achieves state-of-the-art results on several benchmarks for domain adaptive object detection.

The core ideas behind ALDI - leveraging both feature alignment and knowledge transfer - offer a promising direction for making computer vision systems more robust to dataset biases and domain shifts, which is an important practical challenge. While the paper has a few limitations, it provides a strong foundation for further research in this area.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Align and Distill: Unifying and Improving Domain Adaptive Object Detection
Total Score

0

Align and Distill: Unifying and Improving Domain Adaptive Object Detection

Justin Kay, Timm Haucke, Suzanne Stathatos, Siqi Deng, Erik Young, Pietro Perona, Sara Beery, Grant Van Horn

Object detectors often perform poorly on data that differs from their training set. Domain adaptive object detection (DAOD) methods have recently demonstrated strong results on addressing this challenge. Unfortunately, we identify systemic benchmarking pitfalls that call past results into question and hamper further progress: (a) Overestimation of performance due to underpowered baselines, (b) Inconsistent implementation practices preventing transparent comparisons of methods, and (c) Lack of generality due to outdated backbones and lack of diversity in benchmarks. We address these problems by introducing: (1) A unified benchmarking and implementation framework, Align and Distill (ALDI), enabling comparison of DAOD methods and supporting future development, (2) A fair and modern training and evaluation protocol for DAOD that addresses benchmarking pitfalls, (3) A new DAOD benchmark dataset, CFC-DAOD, enabling evaluation on diverse real-world data, and (4) A new method, ALDI++, that achieves state-of-the-art results by a large margin. ALDI++ outperforms the previous state-of-the-art by +3.5 AP50 on Cityscapes to Foggy Cityscapes, +5.7 AP50 on Sim10k to Cityscapes (where ours is the only method to outperform a fair baseline), and +0.6 AP50 on CFC Kenai to Channel. Our framework, dataset, and state-of-the-art method offer a critical reset for DAOD and provide a strong foundation for future research. Code and data are available: https://github.com/justinkay/aldi and https://github.com/visipedia/caltech-fish-counting.

Read more

8/27/2024

🔎

Total Score

0

DSD-DA: Distillation-based Source Debiasing for Domain Adaptive Object Detection

Yongchao Feng, Shiwei Li, Yingjie Gao, Ziyue Huang, Yanan Zhang, Qingjie Liu, Yunhong Wang

Though feature-alignment based Domain Adaptive Object Detection (DAOD) methods have achieved remarkable progress, they ignore the source bias issue, i.e., the detector tends to acquire more source-specific knowledge, impeding its generalization capabilities in the target domain. Furthermore, these methods face a more formidable challenge in achieving consistent classification and localization in the target domain compared to the source domain. To overcome these challenges, we propose a novel Distillation-based Source Debiasing (DSD) framework for DAOD, which can distill domain-agnostic knowledge from a pre-trained teacher model, improving the detector's performance on both domains. In addition, we design a Target-Relevant Object Localization Network (TROLN), which can mine target-related localization information from source and target-style mixed data. Accordingly, we present a Domain-aware Consistency Enhancing (DCE) strategy, in which these information are formulated into a new localization representation to further refine classification scores in the testing stage, achieving a harmonization between classification and localization. Extensive experiments have been conducted to manifest the effectiveness of this method, which consistently improves the strong baseline by large margins, outperforming existing alignment-based works.

Read more

5/20/2024

Few-Shot Domain Adaptive Object Detection for Microscopic Images
Total Score

0

Few-Shot Domain Adaptive Object Detection for Microscopic Images

Sumayya Inayat, Nimra Dilawar, Waqas Sultani, Mohsen Ali

In recent years, numerous domain adaptive strategies have been proposed to help deep learning models overcome the challenges posed by domain shift. However, even unsupervised domain adaptive strategies still require a large amount of target data. Medical imaging datasets are often characterized by class imbalance and scarcity of labeled and unlabeled data. Few-shot domain adaptive object detection (FSDAOD) addresses the challenge of adapting object detectors to target domains with limited labeled data. Existing works struggle with randomly selected target domain images that may not accurately represent the real population, resulting in overfitting to small validation sets and poor generalization to larger test sets. Medical datasets exhibit high class imbalance and background similarity, leading to increased false positives and lower mean Average Precision (map) in target domains. To overcome these challenges, we propose a novel FSDAOD strategy for microscopic imaging. Our contributions include a domain adaptive class balancing strategy for few-shot scenarios, multi-layer instance-level inter and intra-domain alignment to enhance similarity between class instances regardless of domain, and an instance-level classification loss applied in the middle layers of the object detector to enforce feature retention necessary for correct classification across domains. Extensive experimental results with competitive baselines demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, achieving state-of-the-art results on two public microscopic datasets. Code available at https://github.co/intelligentMachinesLab/few-shot-domain-adaptive-microscopy

Read more

7/11/2024

Semi-Supervised Domain Adaptation Using Target-Oriented Domain Augmentation for 3D Object Detection
Total Score

0

Semi-Supervised Domain Adaptation Using Target-Oriented Domain Augmentation for 3D Object Detection

Yecheol Kim, Junho Lee, Changsoo Park, Hyoung won Kim, Inho Lim, Christopher Chang, Jun Won Choi

3D object detection is crucial for applications like autonomous driving and robotics. However, in real-world environments, variations in sensor data distribution due to sensor upgrades, weather changes, and geographic differences can adversely affect detection performance. Semi-Supervised Domain Adaptation (SSDA) aims to mitigate these challenges by transferring knowledge from a source domain, abundant in labeled data, to a target domain where labels are scarce. This paper presents a new SSDA method referred to as Target-Oriented Domain Augmentation (TODA) specifically tailored for LiDAR-based 3D object detection. TODA efficiently utilizes all available data, including labeled data in the source domain, and both labeled data and unlabeled data in the target domain to enhance domain adaptation performance. TODA consists of two stages: TargetMix and AdvMix. TargetMix employs mixing augmentation accounting for LiDAR sensor characteristics to facilitate feature alignment between the source-domain and target-domain. AdvMix applies point-wise adversarial augmentation with mixing augmentation, which perturbs the unlabeled data to align the features within both labeled and unlabeled data in the target domain. Our experiments conducted on the challenging domain adaptation tasks demonstrate that TODA outperforms existing domain adaptation techniques designed for 3D object detection by significant margins. The code is available at: https://github.com/rasd3/TODA.

Read more

6/18/2024