Aligning Diffusion Models by Optimizing Human Utility
2404.04465
0
0
Abstract
We present Diffusion-KTO, a novel approach for aligning text-to-image diffusion models by formulating the alignment objective as the maximization of expected human utility. Since this objective applies to each generation independently, Diffusion-KTO does not require collecting costly pairwise preference data nor training a complex reward model. Instead, our objective requires simple per-image binary feedback signals, e.g. likes or dislikes, which are abundantly available. After fine-tuning using Diffusion-KTO, text-to-image diffusion models exhibit superior performance compared to existing techniques, including supervised fine-tuning and Diffusion-DPO, both in terms of human judgment and automatic evaluation metrics such as PickScore and ImageReward. Overall, Diffusion-KTO unlocks the potential of leveraging readily available per-image binary signals and broadens the applicability of aligning text-to-image diffusion models with human preferences.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel approach to aligning diffusion models with human preferences and utility.
- The authors introduce a framework for optimizing diffusion models to better match human-desired outputs, rather than just maximizing the likelihood of the training data.
- The method involves fine-tuning diffusion models using a hybrid loss function that combines a standard diffusion objective with a term that encourages the model to generate outputs that are more aligned with human preferences.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several text-to-image generation tasks, showing that the optimized models produce images that are better aligned with human utility compared to standard diffusion models.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a way to improve the performance of text-to-image generative models by making them better align with what humans actually want and find useful.
Typically, these models are trained to simply mimic the data they were trained on, without considering whether the outputs are actually useful or desirable from a human perspective. The authors propose a new training approach that incorporates feedback on what humans find useful, allowing the models to optimize directly for human preferences, rather than just maximizing the likelihood of the training data.
The key idea is to fine-tune the diffusion models using a hybrid loss function that balances the standard diffusion objective with an additional term that encourages the model to generate outputs that are more aligned with human utility. This allows the model to find a sweet spot between generating realistic-looking images and producing outputs that humans actually find valuable.
The authors demonstrate that this approach leads to significant improvements on several text-to-image generation tasks, with the optimized models generating images that are rated as more useful and desirable by human evaluators compared to standard diffusion models.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel framework for optimizing diffusion models to better align with human preferences. The authors propose a hybrid loss function that combines a standard diffusion objective with an additional term that encourages the model to generate outputs that are more aligned with human utility.
Specifically, the authors fine-tune pre-trained diffusion models using a loss function that is a weighted sum of the standard negative log-likelihood (NLL) diffusion objective and a human utility term. The human utility term is computed based on human ratings or preferences obtained through crowdsourcing or other methods.
The authors experiment with several ways of computing the human utility term, including using binary classifiers to predict human preferences and adaptive weighting schemes to adjust the relative importance of the two loss terms during training.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several text-to-image generation tasks, showing that the optimized diffusion models outperform standard diffusion models in terms of generating images that are more aligned with human preferences and utility. They also provide qualitative and quantitative analyses to support their findings.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for aligning diffusion models with human preferences, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
The authors rely on human ratings or preferences collected through crowdsourcing, which can be subjective and may not fully capture the nuances of human utility. Exploring more robust and scalable ways of eliciting human feedback could further improve the approach.
-
The proposed method assumes that human utility can be adequately represented by a single scalar value. In reality, human preferences may be more complex and multidimensional, and incorporating richer models of human utility could lead to even better alignment.
-
The authors only evaluate their approach on text-to-image generation tasks. Extending the method to other domains, such as text generation or multi-modal tasks, could provide further insights and broaden the applicability of the technique.
Overall, the paper presents an important step towards aligning generative models with human preferences and utility, and the proposed approach could have significant implications for the development of more trustworthy and socially beneficial AI systems.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel framework for optimizing diffusion models to better align with human preferences and utility. By incorporating human feedback into the training process through a hybrid loss function, the authors demonstrate that the resulting models can generate outputs that are more useful and desirable from a human perspective, compared to standard diffusion models.
The key contribution of the work is the introduction of this optimization-based approach to aligning generative models with human utility, which could have broad applications in the development of AI systems that are more closely tailored to human needs and preferences. The authors provide a thorough evaluation of their method on text-to-image generation tasks, and the results suggest that this approach could lead to significant improvements in the field of generative AI.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Diffusion-RPO: Aligning Diffusion Models through Relative Preference Optimization
Yi Gu, Zhendong Wang, Yueqin Yin, Yujia Xie, Mingyuan Zhou
0
0
Aligning large language models with human preferences has emerged as a critical focus in language modeling research. Yet, integrating preference learning into Text-to-Image (T2I) generative models is still relatively uncharted territory. The Diffusion-DPO technique made initial strides by employing pairwise preference learning in diffusion models tailored for specific text prompts. We introduce Diffusion-RPO, a new method designed to align diffusion-based T2I models with human preferences more effectively. This approach leverages both prompt-image pairs with identical prompts and those with semantically related content across various modalities. Furthermore, we have developed a new evaluation metric, style alignment, aimed at overcoming the challenges of high costs, low reproducibility, and limited interpretability prevalent in current evaluations of human preference alignment. Our findings demonstrate that Diffusion-RPO outperforms established methods such as Supervised Fine-Tuning and Diffusion-DPO in tuning Stable Diffusion versions 1.5 and XL-1.0, achieving superior results in both automated evaluations of human preferences and style alignment. Our code is available at https://github.com/yigu1008/Diffusion-RPO
6/11/2024
🔗
A Dense Reward View on Aligning Text-to-Image Diffusion with Preference
Shentao Yang, Tianqi Chen, Mingyuan Zhou
0
0
Aligning text-to-image diffusion model (T2I) with preference has been gaining increasing research attention. While prior works exist on directly optimizing T2I by preference data, these methods are developed under the bandit assumption of a latent reward on the entire diffusion reverse chain, while ignoring the sequential nature of the generation process. This may harm the efficacy and efficiency of preference alignment. In this paper, we take on a finer dense reward perspective and derive a tractable alignment objective that emphasizes the initial steps of the T2I reverse chain. In particular, we introduce temporal discounting into DPO-style explicit-reward-free objectives, to break the temporal symmetry therein and suit the T2I generation hierarchy. In experiments on single and multiple prompt generation, our method is competitive with strong relevant baselines, both quantitatively and qualitatively. Further investigations are conducted to illustrate the insight of our approach.
5/14/2024
KTO: Model Alignment as Prospect Theoretic Optimization
Kawin Ethayarajh, Winnie Xu, Niklas Muennighoff, Dan Jurafsky, Douwe Kiela
0
0
Kahneman & Tversky's $textit{prospect theory}$ tells us that humans perceive random variables in a biased but well-defined manner (1992); for example, humans are famously loss-averse. We show that objectives for aligning LLMs with human feedback implicitly incorporate many of these biases -- the success of these objectives (e.g., DPO) over cross-entropy minimization can partly be ascribed to them belonging to a family of loss functions that we call $textit{human-aware losses}$ (HALOs). However, the utility functions these methods attribute to humans still differ from those in the prospect theory literature. Using a Kahneman-Tversky model of human utility, we propose a HALO that directly maximizes the utility of generations instead of maximizing the log-likelihood of preferences, as current methods do. We call this approach KTO, and it matches or exceeds the performance of preference-based methods at scales from 1B to 30B, despite only learning from a binary signal of whether an output is desirable. More broadly, our work suggests that there is no one HALO that is universally superior; the best loss depends on the inductive biases most appropriate for a given setting, an oft-overlooked consideration.
6/4/2024
Boost Your Own Human Image Generation Model via Direct Preference Optimization with AI Feedback
Sanghyeon Na, Yonggyu Kim, Hyunjoon Lee
0
0
The generation of high-quality human images through text-to-image (T2I) methods is a significant yet challenging task. Distinct from general image generation, human image synthesis must satisfy stringent criteria related to human pose, anatomy, and alignment with textual prompts, making it particularly difficult to achieve realistic results. Recent advancements in T2I generation based on diffusion models have shown promise, yet challenges remain in meeting human-specific preferences. In this paper, we introduce a novel approach tailored specifically for human image generation utilizing Direct Preference Optimization (DPO). Specifically, we introduce an efficient method for constructing a specialized DPO dataset for training human image generation models without the need for costly human feedback. We also propose a modified loss function that enhances the DPO training process by minimizing artifacts and improving image fidelity. Our method demonstrates its versatility and effectiveness in generating human images, including personalized text-to-image generation. Through comprehensive evaluations, we show that our approach significantly advances the state of human image generation, achieving superior results in terms of natural anatomies, poses, and text-image alignment.
5/31/2024