All Nodes are created Not Equal: Node-Specific Layer Aggregation and Filtration for GNN
0
↗️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Existing Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) often face two key challenges:
- They are typically shallow due to over-smoothing and gradient vanishing as the network goes deeper
- They rely on the homophily assumption, where connected nodes share the same label, which can be problematic for heterophilic graphs
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new architecture called NoSAF (Node-Specific Layer Aggregation and Filtration) that aims to address these limitations. NoSAF introduces the concept that "all nodes are created not equal" and dynamically optimizes the information passed between layers to improve performance on both shallow and deep GNN models, as well as on heterophilic graphs.
The key idea is to have a sophisticated filtering mechanism that processes information from each individual node, rather than treating all nodes the same. This allows the model to selectively retain the most relevant information as it propagates through the deeper layers of the network. To compensate for potential information loss due to this filtering, the authors also propose a variant called NoSAF-D that includes a compensation mechanism to replenish information at each layer.
By addressing the challenges of over-smoothing, gradient vanishing, and heterophily, the NoSAF and NoSAF-D architectures aim to enhance the robustness and scalability of GNN applications, making them more suitable for real-world deployment.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the Node-Specific Layer Aggregation and Filtration (NoSAF) architecture, which is designed to overcome the limitations of existing shallow GNN models and their reliance on the homophily assumption.
NoSAF incorporates the concept of "all nodes are created not equal" into every layer of the network, allowing for dynamic optimization of the information passed between layers. This is achieved through a filtering mechanism that processes data from each individual node, rather than treating all nodes the same.
To compensate for the potential information loss caused by the continuous filtering in NoSAF, the authors also propose NoSAF-D (Deep), which includes a compensation mechanism that replenishes information in every layer of the model. This allows NoSAF to perform meaningful computations even in very deep layers, overcoming the gradient vanishing problem that often plagues deep GNN models.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of NoSAF and NoSAF-D on both shallow and deep GNN models, as well as their ability to handle heterophilic graphs, where the homophily assumption does not hold.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a comprehensive and systematic approach to addressing the key challenges faced by existing GNN models. The proposed NoSAF and NoSAF-D architectures seem promising in enhancing the robustness and scalability of GNN applications.
However, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the computational complexity and training time of the proposed architectures. This information would be valuable for assessing the practical feasibility of deploying these models in real-world scenarios, especially on resource-constrained devices.
Additionally, the authors could have discussed potential limitations or edge cases where the NoSAF and NoSAF-D architectures may not perform as well, as well as potential avenues for further research to address these limitations.
Conclusion
The paper introduces a novel GNN architecture called NoSAF that addresses two major challenges in the field: the over-smoothing and gradient vanishing problems in deep GNN models, and the reliance on the homophily assumption. By incorporating a node-specific filtering and information compensation mechanism, the NoSAF and NoSAF-D architectures demonstrate improved performance on both shallow and deep GNN models, as well as on heterophilic graphs.
These advancements have the potential to enhance the robustness and scalability of GNN applications, making them more suitable for real-world deployment, particularly in domains where graph-structured data is prevalent and the homophily assumption may not hold.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
↗️
0
All Nodes are created Not Equal: Node-Specific Layer Aggregation and Filtration for GNN
Shilong Wang, Hao Wu, Yifan Duan, Guibin Zhang, Guohao Li, Yuxuan Liang, Shirui Pan, Kun Wang, Yang Wang
The ever-designed Graph Neural Networks, though opening a promising path for the modeling of the graph-structure data, unfortunately introduce two daunting obstacles to their deployment on devices. (I) Most of existing GNNs are shallow, due mostly to the over-smoothing and gradient-vanish problem as they go deeper as convolutional architectures. (II) The vast majority of GNNs adhere to the homophily assumption, where the central node and its adjacent nodes share the same label. This assumption often poses challenges for many GNNs working with heterophilic graphs. Addressing the aforementioned issue has become a looming challenge in enhancing the robustness and scalability of GNN applications. In this paper, we take a comprehensive and systematic approach to overcoming the two aforementioned challenges for the first time. We propose a Node-Specific Layer Aggregation and Filtration architecture, termed NoSAF, a framework capable of filtering and processing information from each individual nodes. NoSAF introduces the concept of All Nodes are Created Not Equal into every layer of deep networks, aiming to provide a reliable information filter for each layer's nodes to sieve out information beneficial for the subsequent layer. By incorporating a dynamically updated codebank, NoSAF dynamically optimizes the optimal information outputted downwards at each layer. This effectively overcomes heterophilic issues and aids in deepening the network. To compensate for the information loss caused by the continuous filtering in NoSAF, we also propose NoSAF-D (Deep), which incorporates a compensation mechanism that replenishes information in every layer of the model, allowing NoSAF to perform meaningful computations even in very deep layers.
Read more5/14/2024
0
SF-GNN: Self Filter for Message Lossless Propagation in Deep Graph Neural Network
Yushan Zhu, Wen Zhang, Yajing Xu, Zhen Yao, Mingyang Chen, Huajun Chen
Graph Neural Network (GNN), with the main idea of encoding graph structure information of graphs by propagation and aggregation, has developed rapidly. It achieved excellent performance in representation learning of multiple types of graphs such as homogeneous graphs, heterogeneous graphs, and more complex graphs like knowledge graphs. However, merely stacking GNN layers may not improve the model's performance and can even be detrimental. For the phenomenon of performance degradation in deep GNNs, we propose a new perspective. Unlike the popular explanations of over-smoothing or over-squashing, we think the issue arises from the interference of low-quality node representations during message propagation. We introduce a simple and general method, SF-GNN, to address this problem. In SF-GNN, we define two representations for each node, one is the node representation that represents the feature of the node itself, and the other is the message representation specifically for propagating messages to neighbor nodes. A self-filter module evaluates the quality of the node representation and decides whether to integrate it into the message propagation based on this quality assessment. Experiments on node classification tasks for both homogeneous and heterogeneous graphs, as well as link prediction tasks on knowledge graphs, demonstrate that our method can be applied to various GNN models and outperforms state-of-the-art baseline methods in addressing deep GNN degradation.
Read more7/4/2024
0
Rethinking Spectral Graph Neural Networks with Spatially Adaptive Filtering
Jingwei Guo, Kaizhu Huang, Xinping Yi, Zixian Su, Rui Zhang
Whilst spectral Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are theoretically well-founded in the spectral domain, their practical reliance on polynomial approximation implies a profound linkage to the spatial domain. As previous studies rarely examine spectral GNNs from the spatial perspective, their spatial-domain interpretability remains elusive, e.g., what information is essentially encoded by spectral GNNs in the spatial domain? In this paper, to answer this question, we establish a theoretical connection between spectral filtering and spatial aggregation, unveiling an intrinsic interaction that spectral filtering implicitly leads the original graph to an adapted new graph, explicitly computed for spatial aggregation. Both theoretical and empirical investigations reveal that the adapted new graph not only exhibits non-locality but also accommodates signed edge weights to reflect label consistency among nodes. These findings thus highlight the interpretable role of spectral GNNs in the spatial domain and inspire us to rethink graph spectral filters beyond the fixed-order polynomials, which neglect global information. Built upon the theoretical findings, we revisit the state-of-the-art spectral GNNs and propose a novel Spatially Adaptive Filtering (SAF) framework, which leverages the adapted new graph by spectral filtering for an auxiliary non-local aggregation. Notably, our proposed SAF comprehensively models both node similarity and dissimilarity from a global perspective, therefore alleviating persistent deficiencies of GNNs related to long-range dependencies and graph heterophily. Extensive experiments over 13 node classification benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of our proposed framework to the state-of-the-art models.
Read more9/17/2024
0
Node-wise Filtering in Graph Neural Networks: A Mixture of Experts Approach
Haoyu Han, Juanhui Li, Wei Huang, Xianfeng Tang, Hanqing Lu, Chen Luo, Hui Liu, Jiliang Tang
Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have proven to be highly effective for node classification tasks across diverse graph structural patterns. Traditionally, GNNs employ a uniform global filter, typically a low-pass filter for homophilic graphs and a high-pass filter for heterophilic graphs. However, real-world graphs often exhibit a complex mix of homophilic and heterophilic patterns, rendering a single global filter approach suboptimal. In this work, we theoretically demonstrate that a global filter optimized for one pattern can adversely affect performance on nodes with differing patterns. To address this, we introduce a novel GNN framework Node-MoE that utilizes a mixture of experts to adaptively select the appropriate filters for different nodes. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of Node-MoE on both homophilic and heterophilic graphs.
Read more6/6/2024