ALOHa: A New Measure for Hallucination in Captioning Models
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a new metric called ALOHa to reliably detect and localize hallucination in image captioning models.
- Hallucination refers to the generation of content in the captions that is not grounded in the image.
- ALOHa aims to address the limitations of existing hallucination detection methods that are either unreliable, non-localizable, or not generalizable.
Plain English Explanation
The research paper introduces a new way to measure and detect when image captioning models generate text that is not actually supported by the image they are describing. This issue, known as "hallucination," is a significant problem in the field of machine learning, as it can lead to the models producing inaccurate or misleading captions.
The key insight behind the ALOHa metric is that it can reliably identify hallucinated content, pinpoint where in the caption it occurs, and work across different captioning models and datasets. This is important because existing methods for detecting hallucination have limitations - they may not be very accurate, they can't show exactly which parts of the caption are problematic, or they only work well with certain models.
By having a more robust and versatile way to detect hallucination, the researchers hope to help improve the reliability and trustworthiness of image captioning models. This could have valuable applications in areas like assisting visually impaired users, describing images for search engines, or generating captions for social media. Ultimately, the goal is to make these AI systems more grounded in reality and less prone to fabricating or hallucinating content.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new metric called ALOHa (Accurate, Localizable, and Generalizable Hallucination detection) to address the shortcomings of existing approaches for detecting hallucination in image captioning models. Hallucination refers to the generation of caption text that is not supported by or grounded in the corresponding image.
The key components of ALOHa are:
- Reliability: ALOHa uses a combination of semantic similarity and object/attribute matching to accurately identify hallucinated content in captions.
- Localizability: ALOHa can pinpoint the specific words or phrases within a caption that are hallucinated, providing more detailed feedback.
- Generalizability: ALOHa is designed to work across different captioning models and datasets, unlike prior methods that may be limited in their scope.
The paper evaluates ALOHa on several benchmark image captioning datasets and models, demonstrating its superior performance compared to existing hallucination detection approaches. The results show that ALOHa can reliably identify hallucinated content, localize it within captions, and generalize to diverse captioning systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a strong case for the need to improve hallucination detection in image captioning models, and the ALOHa metric appears to be a step in the right direction. By addressing the limitations of prior methods, ALOHa offers a more comprehensive and reliable way to identify and localize hallucinated content.
However, the paper does not delve into potential caveats or limitations of the ALOHa approach. For example, it would be valuable to understand how ALOHa performs on edge cases or particularly challenging images/captions, and whether there are any scenarios where it may struggle to accurately detect hallucination.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational complexity or efficiency of the ALOHa metric, which could be an important consideration for real-world deployment of these techniques. It would also be interesting to see how ALOHa could be further improved or combined with other hallucination detection methods to enhance its performance.
Conclusion
The ALOHa metric proposed in this paper represents a significant advancement in the ability to reliably detect and localize hallucination in image captioning models. By addressing the limitations of existing approaches, ALOHa offers a more comprehensive and generalizable solution that could lead to tangible improvements in the trustworthiness and reliability of these AI systems.
The potential applications of this research are wide-ranging, from assisting visually impaired users to enhancing image search and social media content generation. As the field of machine learning continues to evolve, robust techniques like ALOHa will become increasingly important for ensuring the safe and responsible deployment of AI technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
ALOHa: A New Measure for Hallucination in Captioning Models
Suzanne Petryk, David M. Chan, Anish Kachinthaya, Haodi Zou, John Canny, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Trevor Darrell
Despite recent advances in multimodal pre-training for visual description, state-of-the-art models still produce captions containing errors, such as hallucinating objects not present in a scene. The existing prominent metric for object hallucination, CHAIR, is limited to a fixed set of MS COCO objects and synonyms. In this work, we propose a modernized open-vocabulary metric, ALOHa, which leverages large language models (LLMs) to measure object hallucinations. Specifically, we use an LLM to extract groundable objects from a candidate caption, measure their semantic similarity to reference objects from captions and object detections, and use Hungarian matching to produce a final hallucination score. We show that ALOHa correctly identifies 13.6% more hallucinated objects than CHAIR on HAT, a new gold-standard subset of MS COCO Captions annotated for hallucinations, and 30.8% more on nocaps, where objects extend beyond MS COCO categories. Our code is available at https://davidmchan.github.io/aloha/.
Read more4/4/2024
0
Mitigating Open-Vocabulary Caption Hallucinations
Assaf Ben-Kish, Moran Yanuka, Morris Alper, Raja Giryes, Hadar Averbuch-Elor
While recent years have seen rapid progress in image-conditioned text generation, image captioning still suffers from the fundamental issue of hallucinations, namely, the generation of spurious details that cannot be inferred from the given image. Existing methods largely use closed-vocabulary object lists to mitigate or evaluate hallucinations in image captioning, ignoring the long-tailed nature of hallucinations that occur in practice. To this end, we propose a framework for addressing hallucinations in image captioning in the open-vocabulary setting. Our framework includes a new benchmark, OpenCHAIR, that leverages generative foundation models to evaluate open-vocabulary object hallucinations for image captioning, surpassing the popular and similarly-sized CHAIR benchmark in both diversity and accuracy. Furthermore, to mitigate open-vocabulary hallucinations without using a closed object list, we propose MOCHa, an approach harnessing advancements in reinforcement learning. Our multi-objective reward function explicitly targets the trade-off between fidelity and adequacy in generations without requiring any strong supervision. MOCHa improves a large variety of image captioning models, as captured by our OpenCHAIR benchmark and other existing metrics. We will release our code and models.
Read more4/22/2024
0
HALC: Object Hallucination Reduction via Adaptive Focal-Contrast Decoding
Zhaorun Chen, Zhuokai Zhao, Hongyin Luo, Huaxiu Yao, Bo Li, Jiawei Zhou
While large vision-language models (LVLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities in interpreting multi-modal contexts, they invariably suffer from object hallucinations (OH). We introduce HALC, a novel decoding algorithm designed to mitigate OH in LVLMs. HALC leverages distinct fine-grained optimal visual information in vision-language tasks and operates on both local and global contexts simultaneously. Specifically, HALC integrates a robust auto-focal grounding mechanism (locally) to correct hallucinated tokens on the fly, and a specialized beam search algorithm (globally) to significantly reduce OH while preserving text generation quality. Additionally, HALC can be integrated into any LVLMs as a plug-and-play module without extra training. Extensive experimental studies demonstrate the effectiveness of HALC in reducing OH, outperforming state-of-the-arts across four benchmarks.
Read more6/11/2024
🐍
0
Logical Closed Loop: Uncovering Object Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models
Junfei Wu, Qiang Liu, Ding Wang, Jinghao Zhang, Shu Wu, Liang Wang, Tieniu Tan
Object hallucination has been an Achilles' heel which hinders the broader applications of large vision-language models (LVLMs). Object hallucination refers to the phenomenon that the LVLMs claim non-existent objects in the image. To mitigate the object hallucinations, instruction tuning and external model-based detection methods have been proposed, which either require large-scare computational resources or depend on the detection result of external models. However, there remains an under-explored field to utilize the LVLM itself to alleviate object hallucinations. In this work, we adopt the intuition that the LVLM tends to respond logically consistently for existent objects but inconsistently for hallucinated objects. Therefore, we propose a Logical Closed Loop-based framework for Object Hallucination Detection and Mitigation, namely LogicCheckGPT. In specific, we devise logical consistency probing to raise questions with logical correlations, inquiring about attributes from objects and vice versa. Whether their responses can form a logical closed loop serves as an indicator of object hallucination. As a plug-and-play method, it can be seamlessly applied to all existing LVLMs. Comprehensive experiments conducted on three benchmarks across four LVLMs have demonstrated significant improvements brought by our method, indicating its effectiveness and generality.
Read more7/1/2024