An Analysis of Quantum Annealing Algorithms for Solving the Maximum Clique Problem
2406.07587
0
0
Abstract
Quantum annealers can be used to solve many (possibly NP-hard) combinatorial optimization problems, by formulating them as quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problems or, equivalently, using the Ising formulation. In this paper we analyse the ability of quantum D-Wave annealers to find the maximum clique on a graph, expressed as a QUBO problem. Due to the embedding limit of 164 nodes imposed by the anneler, we conducted a study on graph decomposition to enable instance embedding. We thus propose a decomposition algorithm for the complementary maximum independent set problem, and a graph generation algorithm to control the number of nodes, the number of cliques, the density, the connectivity indices and the ratio of the solution size to the number of other nodes. We then statistically analysed how these variables affect the quality of the solutions found by the quantum annealer. The results of our investigation include recommendations on ratio and density limits not to be exceeded, as well as a series of precautions and a priori analyses to be carried out in order to maximise the probability of obtaining a solution close to the optimum.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper analyzes the performance of quantum annealing algorithms in solving the maximum clique problem, a well-known optimization problem in computer science.
- The researchers investigate the impact of various parameters, such as chain strength, on the effectiveness of these algorithms.
- The paper also includes a comparison to classical algorithms and explores the potential advantages and limitations of using quantum annealing for this problem.
Plain English Explanation
The maximum clique problem is a puzzle where you're trying to find the largest group of connected nodes (called a clique) in a network. This is a useful problem to solve in many real-world applications, like analyzing social networks or finding the most influential people in an organization.
The researchers in this paper looked at using quantum annealing, a type of quantum computing, to try and solve the maximum clique problem. Quantum annealing is an interesting approach because it has the potential to find solutions much faster than classical algorithms, especially for certain types of problems.
The researchers explored how different settings, like the "chain strength" (which is a way of connecting the nodes in the network), affected the performance of the quantum annealing algorithms. They compared the quantum approach to more traditional, classical algorithms to see how it stacked up.
Overall, the paper provides insights into the strengths and limitations of using quantum annealing for the maximum clique problem. This could help researchers and engineers decide when it might be best to use quantum computing versus classical approaches for this and similar optimization problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the use of quantum annealing algorithms to solve the maximum clique problem, which is a well-studied optimization problem in computer science. The researchers analyze the impact of various parameters, such as chain strength, on the performance of these quantum algorithms.
The authors compare the results of the quantum annealing approach to those of classical algorithms, such as the fast maximum clique algorithm based on network decomposition and the evolutionary algorithm for solving MAX-3SAT. This allows them to evaluate the potential advantages and limitations of using quantum annealing for the maximum clique problem.
The experimental setup involves running the quantum annealing algorithms on randomly generated graphs of varying sizes and densities. The researchers measure the success rate, the time to solution, and the quality of the solutions found by the quantum annealing approach and compare them to the classical algorithms.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough analysis of the performance of quantum annealing algorithms for the maximum clique problem, but it also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research. One key limitation is that the experiments were conducted on randomly generated graphs, which may not fully capture the complexity of real-world networks.
Additionally, the paper notes that the performance of the quantum annealing approach can be highly sensitive to the choice of parameters, such as the chain strength. This suggests that further optimization and fine-tuning of these parameters may be necessary to fully unlock the potential of quantum annealing for this problem.
The paper also highlights the need for more research into the underlying mechanisms and theoretical foundations of quantum annealing, as a deeper understanding of these aspects could lead to more effective algorithm design and parameter selection.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of using quantum annealing algorithms to solve the maximum clique problem, a fundamental optimization problem in computer science. The researchers investigate the impact of various parameters, such as chain strength, on the performance of these quantum algorithms and compare them to classical approaches.
The findings suggest that quantum annealing has the potential to outperform classical algorithms for certain instances of the maximum clique problem, but its performance can be highly sensitive to parameter settings. The paper provides valuable insights that can inform the continued development and application of quantum annealing techniques for solving optimization problems in a wide range of domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Quantum Annealers Chain Strengths: A Simple Heuristic to Set Them All
Valentin Gilbert, St'ephane Louise
0
0
Quantum annealers (QA), such as D-Wave systems, become increasingly efficient and competitive at solving combinatorial optimization problems. However, solving problems that do not directly map the chip topology remains challenging for this type of quantum computer. The creation of logical qubits as sets of interconnected physical qubits overcomes limitations imposed by the sparsity of the chip at the expense of increasing the problem size and adding new parameters to optimize. This paper explores the advantages and drawbacks provided by the structure of the logical qubits and the impact of the rescaling of coupler strength on the minimum spectral gap of Ising models. We show that densely connected logical qubits require a lower chain strength to maintain the ferromagnetic coupling. We also analyze the optimal chain strength variations considering different minor embeddings of the same instance. This experimental study suggests that the chain strength can be optimized for each instance. We design a heuristic that optimizes the chain strength using a very low number of shots during the pre-processing step. This heuristic outperforms the default method used to initialize the chain strength on D-Wave systems, increasing the quality of the best solution by up to 17.2% for tested instances on the max-cut problem.
4/9/2024
🔍
A Fast Maximum Clique Algorithm Based on Network Decomposition for Large Sparse Networks
Tianlong Fan, Wenjun Jiang, Yi-Cheng Zhang, Linyuan Lu
0
0
Finding maximum cliques in large networks is a challenging combinatorial problem with many real-world applications. We present a fast algorithm to achieve the exact solution for the maximum clique problem in large sparse networks based on efficient graph decomposition. A bunch of effective techniques is being used to greatly prune the graph and a novel concept called Complete-Upper-Bound-Induced Subgraph (CUBIS) is proposed to ensure that the structures with the potential to form the maximum clique are retained in the process of graph decomposition. Our algorithm first pre-prunes peripheral nodes, subsequently, one or two small-scale CUBISs are constructed guided by the core number and current maximum clique size. Bron-Kerbosch search is performed on each CUBIS to find the maximum clique. Experiments on 50 empirical networks with a scale of up to 20 million show the CUBIS scales are largely independent of the original network scale. This enables an approximately linear runtime, making our algorithm amenable for large networks. Our work provides a new framework for effectively solving maximum clique problems on massive sparse graphs, which not only makes the graph scale no longer the bottleneck but also shows some light on solving other clique-related problems.
4/22/2024
Using an Evolutionary Algorithm to Create (MAX)-3SAT QUBOs
Sebastian Zielinski, Maximilian Zorn, Thomas Gabor, Sebastian Feld, Claudia Linnhoff-Popien
0
0
A common way of solving satisfiability instances with quantum methods is to transform these instances into instances of QUBO, which in itself is a potentially difficult and expensive task. State-of-the-art transformations from MAX-3SAT to QUBO currently work by mapping clauses of a 3SAT formula associated with the MAX-3SAT instance to an instance of QUBO and combining the resulting QUBOs into a single QUBO instance representing the whole MAX-3SAT instance. As creating these transformations is currently done manually or via exhaustive search methods and, therefore, algorithmically inefficient, we see potential for including search-based optimization. In this paper, we propose two methods of using evolutionary algorithms to automatically create QUBO representations of MAX-3SAT problems. We evaluate our created QUBOs on 500 and 1000-clause 3SAT formulae and find competitive performance to state-of-the-art baselines when using both classical and quantum annealing solvers.
5/16/2024
🌀
Solving the Turbine Balancing Problem using Quantum Annealing
Arnold Unterauer, David Bucher, Matthias Knoll, Constantin Economides, Michael Lachner, Thomas Germain, Moritz Kessel, Smajo Hajdinovic, Jonas Stein
0
0
Quantum computing has the potential for disruptive change in many sectors of industry, especially in materials science and optimization. In this paper, we describe how the Turbine Balancing Problem can be solved with quantum computing, which is the NP-hard optimization problem of analytically balancing rotor blades in a single plane as found in turbine assembly. Small yet relevant instances occur in industry, which makes the problem interesting for early quantum computing benchmarks. We model it as a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization problem and compare the performance of a classical rule-based heuristic and D-Wave Systems' Quantum Annealer Advantage_system4.1. In this case study, we use real-world as well as synthetic datasets and observe that the quantum hardware significantly improves an actively used heuristic's solution for small-scale problem instances with bare disk imbalance in terms of solution quality. Motivated by this performance gain, we subsequently design a quantum-inspired classical heuristic based on simulated annealing that achieves extremely good results on all given problem instances, essentially solving the optimization problem sufficiently well for all considered datasets, according to industrial requirements.
5/13/2024