Anytime-Constrained Reinforcement Learning
2311.05511
0
0
🏅
Abstract
We introduce and study constrained Markov Decision Processes (cMDPs) with anytime constraints. An anytime constraint requires the agent to never violate its budget at any point in time, almost surely. Although Markovian policies are no longer sufficient, we show that there exist optimal deterministic policies augmented with cumulative costs. In fact, we present a fixed-parameter tractable reduction from anytime-constrained cMDPs to unconstrained MDPs. Our reduction yields planning and learning algorithms that are time and sample-efficient for tabular cMDPs so long as the precision of the costs is logarithmic in the size of the cMDP. However, we also show that computing non-trivial approximately optimal policies is NP-hard in general. To circumvent this bottleneck, we design provable approximation algorithms that efficiently compute or learn an arbitrarily accurate approximately feasible policy with optimal value so long as the maximum supported cost is bounded by a polynomial in the cMDP or the absolute budget. Given our hardness results, our approximation guarantees are the best possible under worst-case analysis.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper introduces and studies constrained Markov Decision Processes (cMDPs) with anytime constraints, where the agent must never violate its budget at any point in time.
- Although Markovian policies are no longer sufficient, the authors show that there exist optimal deterministic policies augmented with cumulative costs.
- They present a fixed-parameter tractable reduction from anytime-constrained cMDPs to unconstrained MDPs, yielding planning and learning algorithms that are time and sample-efficient for tabular cMDPs.
- However, the authors also show that computing non-trivial approximately optimal policies is NP-hard in general.
- To address this, they design provable approximation algorithms that efficiently compute or learn an arbitrarily accurate approximately feasible policy with optimal value.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers introduce a new type of constrained decision-making problem called a "constrained Markov Decision Process" (cMDP) with "anytime constraints." This means that the agent (e.g., a robot or software system) has to make decisions while always staying within a certain budget or constraint, without ever exceeding it at any point in time.
The researchers show that the standard approach of using Markovian policies (where the agent's decision only depends on the current state) is no longer sufficient for these types of problems. However, they've discovered that there are still optimal policies that can be represented as deterministic policies combined with information about the cumulative costs so far.
The key innovation in this paper is a technique to transform these anytime-constrained cMDPs into unconstrained MDPs, which allows them to use efficient planning and learning algorithms to solve the original problem. As long as the cost precision is not too high, these algorithms can find optimal solutions quickly and with a small number of samples.
Unfortunately, the researchers also show that in general, finding good approximate solutions to these constrained problems is a very difficult (NP-hard) problem. To work around this, they've developed special approximation algorithms that can efficiently compute or learn policies that are close to optimal while still satisfying the constraints.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces and studies constrained Markov Decision Processes (cMDPs) with anytime constraints. In these problems, the agent must never violate a budget or constraint at any point in time, rather than just on average. The authors show that Markovian policies are no longer sufficient, but that there exist optimal deterministic policies augmented with cumulative costs.
The key technical contribution is a fixed-parameter tractable reduction from anytime-constrained cMDPs to unconstrained MDPs. This allows the use of efficient planning and learning algorithms for tabular cMDPs, as long as the cost precision is logarithmic in the size of the cMDP.
However, the authors also prove that computing non-trivial approximately optimal policies is NP-hard in general. To address this, they design provable approximation algorithms that efficiently compute or learn an arbitrarily accurate approximately feasible policy with optimal value, as long as the maximum supported cost is bounded by a polynomial.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a strong theoretical foundation for handling constrained Markov Decision Processes with anytime constraints. The reduction to unconstrained MDPs is a clever technique that enables the use of efficient planning and learning algorithms, which is a significant contribution.
However, the hardness result for computing approximate solutions is a notable limitation. While the authors' approximation algorithms are the best possible under worst-case analysis, it would be valuable to explore alternative approaches or identify problem structures where better approximations are possible.
Additionally, the paper does not provide empirical validation of the proposed algorithms on real-world problems. Demonstrating the practical effectiveness and scalability of these methods would further strengthen the impact of this research.
It would also be interesting to see how the anytime constraint formulation compares to other common constraint types, such as average constraints or multi-objective optimization. Understanding the tradeoffs and relative strengths of these different approaches could lead to a more comprehensive understanding of constrained decision-making.
Conclusion
This paper makes important theoretical contributions to the field of constrained Markov Decision Processes. By introducing anytime constraints and developing efficient reduction techniques, the authors have laid the groundwork for planning and learning algorithms that can handle these types of problems.
While the hardness result for approximation is a challenge, the authors' approximation algorithms provide a valuable tool for addressing this limitation. As the field of constrained decision-making continues to evolve, this research can serve as a foundation for further advancements in ensuring that intelligent systems can operate within strict constraints while still achieving high performance.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
A safe exploration approach to constrained Markov decision processes
Tingting Ni, Maryam Kamgarpour
0
0
We consider discounted infinite horizon constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) where the goal is to find an optimal policy that maximizes the expected cumulative reward subject to expected cumulative constraints. Motivated by the application of CMDPs in online learning of safety-critical systems, we focus on developing a model-free and simulator-free algorithm that ensures constraint satisfaction during learning. To this end, we develop an interior point approach based on the log barrier function of the CMDP. Under the commonly assumed conditions of Fisher non-degeneracy and bounded transfer error of the policy parameterization, we establish the theoretical properties of the algorithm. In particular, in contrast to existing CMDP approaches that ensure policy feasibility only upon convergence, our algorithm guarantees the feasibility of the policies during the learning process and converges to the $varepsilon$-optimal policy with a sample complexity of $tilde{mathcal{O}}(varepsilon^{-6})$. In comparison to the state-of-the-art policy gradient-based algorithm, C-NPG-PDA, our algorithm requires an additional $mathcal{O}(varepsilon^{-2})$ samples to ensure policy feasibility during learning with the same Fisher non-degenerate parameterization.
5/24/2024
🏅
Deterministic Policies for Constrained Reinforcement Learning in Polynomial-Time
Jeremy McMahan
0
0
We present a novel algorithm that efficiently computes near-optimal deterministic policies for constrained reinforcement learning (CRL) problems. Our approach combines three key ideas: (1) value-demand augmentation, (2) action-space approximate dynamic programming, and (3) time-space rounding. Under mild reward assumptions, our algorithm constitutes a fully polynomial-time approximation scheme (FPTAS) for a diverse class of cost criteria. This class requires that the cost of a policy can be computed recursively over both time and (state) space, which includes classical expectation, almost sure, and anytime constraints. Our work not only provides provably efficient algorithms to address real-world challenges in decision-making but also offers a unifying theory for the efficient computation of constrained deterministic policies.
5/24/2024
↗️
Learning Constrained Markov Decision Processes With Non-stationary Rewards and Constraints
Francesco Emanuele Stradi, Anna Lunghi, Matteo Castiglioni, Alberto Marchesi, Nicola Gatti
0
0
In constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) with adversarial rewards and constraints, a well-known impossibility result prevents any algorithm from attaining both sublinear regret and sublinear constraint violation, when competing against a best-in-hindsight policy that satisfies constraints on average. In this paper, we show that this negative result can be eased in CMDPs with non-stationary rewards and constraints, by providing algorithms whose performances smoothly degrade as non-stationarity increases. Specifically, we propose algorithms attaining $tilde{mathcal{O}} (sqrt{T} + C)$ regret and positive constraint violation under bandit feedback, where $C$ is a corruption value measuring the environment non-stationarity. This can be $Theta(T)$ in the worst case, coherently with the impossibility result for adversarial CMDPs. First, we design an algorithm with the desired guarantees when $C$ is known. Then, in the case $C$ is unknown, we show how to obtain the same results by embedding such an algorithm in a general meta-procedure. This is of independent interest, as it can be applied to any non-stationary constrained online learning setting.
5/24/2024
🏅
Sample-Efficient Constrained Reinforcement Learning with General Parameterization
Washim Uddin Mondal, Vaneet Aggarwal
0
0
We consider a constrained Markov Decision Problem (CMDP) where the goal of an agent is to maximize the expected discounted sum of rewards over an infinite horizon while ensuring that the expected discounted sum of costs exceeds a certain threshold. Building on the idea of momentum-based acceleration, we develop the Primal-Dual Accelerated Natural Policy Gradient (PD-ANPG) algorithm that guarantees an $epsilon$ global optimality gap and $epsilon$ constraint violation with $mathcal{O}(epsilon^{-3})$ sample complexity. This improves the state-of-the-art sample complexity in CMDP by a factor of $mathcal{O}(epsilon^{-1})$.
5/20/2024