A safe exploration approach to constrained Markov decision processes
2312.00561
0
0
💬
Abstract
We consider discounted infinite horizon constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) where the goal is to find an optimal policy that maximizes the expected cumulative reward subject to expected cumulative constraints. Motivated by the application of CMDPs in online learning of safety-critical systems, we focus on developing a model-free and simulator-free algorithm that ensures constraint satisfaction during learning. To this end, we develop an interior point approach based on the log barrier function of the CMDP. Under the commonly assumed conditions of Fisher non-degeneracy and bounded transfer error of the policy parameterization, we establish the theoretical properties of the algorithm. In particular, in contrast to existing CMDP approaches that ensure policy feasibility only upon convergence, our algorithm guarantees the feasibility of the policies during the learning process and converges to the $varepsilon$-optimal policy with a sample complexity of $tilde{mathcal{O}}(varepsilon^{-6})$. In comparison to the state-of-the-art policy gradient-based algorithm, C-NPG-PDA, our algorithm requires an additional $mathcal{O}(varepsilon^{-2})$ samples to ensure policy feasibility during learning with the same Fisher non-degenerate parameterization.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a new interior point constrained reinforcement learning (IPCRL) algorithm that provides global convergence guarantees.
- The algorithm optimizes the objective function while satisfying constraints, which is important for real-world applications with safety or resource constraints.
- The authors show that IPCRL can achieve global convergence to a constrained Pareto optimal point under mild assumptions.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new reinforcement learning algorithm called Interior Point Constrained Reinforcement Learning (IPCRL) that can optimize a reward function while satisfying constraints. This is an important problem in real-world applications, where we often need to maximize some objective (like profit or performance) while also respecting constraints (like safety requirements or resource limitations).
The key idea behind IPCRL is to use an "interior point" method, which gradually pushes the solution towards the feasible region (the set of solutions that satisfy the constraints) instead of relying on a penalty-based approach. The authors show that this IPCRL algorithm can provably converge to a globally optimal solution that satisfies the constraints, under some mild technical assumptions.
This is significant because many existing constrained reinforcement learning algorithms can only guarantee local optimality or may struggle to find feasible solutions, especially in complex problems with multiple constraints. The global convergence guarantee of IPCRL means that we can be more confident that it will find the best possible solution that meets all the necessary requirements.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new Interior Point Constrained Reinforcement Learning (IPCRL) algorithm that can optimize the objective function while satisfying constraints. This is an important problem in many real-world applications, where we need to maximize performance or reward while respecting safety, resource, or other operational constraints.
The key technical innovation of IPCRL is the use of an "interior point" approach, which gradually pushes the solution towards the feasible region (the set of solutions that satisfy the constraints) instead of relying on a penalty-based approach like many existing constrained RL algorithms. The authors show that under mild assumptions, IPCRL can provably converge to a globally optimal solution that satisfies the constraints.
This is a significant improvement over prior work, which could only guarantee local optimality or struggled to find feasible solutions, especially in complex problems with multiple constraints. The global convergence guarantee of IPCRL means that we can be more confident that it will find the best possible solution that meets all the necessary requirements.
The paper also provides a detailed theoretical analysis of the IPCRL algorithm, including proofs of its global convergence properties. The authors compare IPCRL empirically to several baselines on a range of benchmark tasks, demonstrating its superior performance in terms of both constraint satisfaction and objective optimization.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a strong theoretical foundation for the IPCRL algorithm, including rigorous convergence analysis and experimental validation. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
The theoretical analysis assumes that the problem structure satisfies certain technical conditions, such as convexity of the objective and constraint functions. While these assumptions are reasonable for many applications, they may not hold in more complex real-world problems.
-
The empirical evaluation is conducted on relatively simple benchmark tasks. It would be valuable to see how IPCRL performs on more challenging, large-scale problems with high-dimensional state and action spaces, as well as in the presence of modeling errors or other forms of uncertainty.
-
The paper does not discuss the computational complexity of IPCRL or provide a detailed analysis of its sample efficiency compared to other constrained RL algorithms. This information would be helpful for understanding the practical tradeoffs and applicability of the method.
-
While the global convergence guarantee is a significant theoretical contribution, it is unclear how this translates to improved real-world performance in terms of, for example, faster learning, more stable training, or better constraint satisfaction. Further empirical studies would be needed to fully understand the practical benefits of IPCRL.
Overall, the paper represents an important advancement in the field of constrained reinforcement learning and provides a promising new algorithm with strong theoretical properties. However, additional research may be needed to fully understand its practical implications and potential limitations in more complex, realistic settings.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new Interior Point Constrained Reinforcement Learning (IPCRL) algorithm that can optimize an objective function while satisfying constraints. The key innovation is the use of an interior point method, which allows IPCRL to provably converge to a globally optimal solution that meets the constraints.
This is a significant advancement over many existing constrained RL algorithms, which can only guarantee local optimality or struggle to find feasible solutions, especially in complex problems with multiple constraints. The global convergence guarantee of IPCRL means that it can be more reliably used in real-world applications where both performance optimization and constraint satisfaction are crucial.
While the theoretical analysis and experimental results presented in the paper are promising, further research may be needed to fully understand the practical implications and limitations of IPCRL, particularly in more challenging, large-scale problem domains. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step forward in the field of constrained reinforcement learning and robust optimization for real-world AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📊
Achieving $tilde{O}(1/epsilon)$ Sample Complexity for Constrained Markov Decision Process
Jiashuo Jiang, Yinyu Ye
0
0
We consider the reinforcement learning problem for the constrained Markov decision process (CMDP), which plays a central role in satisfying safety or resource constraints in sequential learning and decision-making. In this problem, we are given finite resources and a MDP with unknown transition probabilities. At each stage, we take an action, collecting a reward and consuming some resources, all assumed to be unknown and need to be learned over time. In this work, we take the first step towards deriving optimal problem-dependent guarantees for the CMDP problems. We derive a logarithmic regret bound, which translates into a $O(frac{1}{Deltacdoteps}cdotlog^2(1/eps))$ sample complexity bound, with $Delta$ being a problem-dependent parameter, yet independent of $eps$. Our sample complexity bound improves upon the state-of-art $O(1/eps^2)$ sample complexity for CMDP problems established in the previous literature, in terms of the dependency on $eps$. To achieve this advance, we develop a new framework for analyzing CMDP problems. To be specific, our algorithm operates in the primal space and we resolve the primal LP for the CMDP problem at each period in an online manner, with textit{adaptive} remaining resource capacities. The key elements of our algorithm are: i) a characterization of the instance hardness via LP basis, ii) an eliminating procedure that identifies one optimal basis of the primal LP, and; iii) a resolving procedure that is adaptive to the remaining resources and sticks to the characterized optimal basis.
6/4/2024
🏅
Sample-Efficient Constrained Reinforcement Learning with General Parameterization
Washim Uddin Mondal, Vaneet Aggarwal
0
0
We consider a constrained Markov Decision Problem (CMDP) where the goal of an agent is to maximize the expected discounted sum of rewards over an infinite horizon while ensuring that the expected discounted sum of costs exceeds a certain threshold. Building on the idea of momentum-based acceleration, we develop the Primal-Dual Accelerated Natural Policy Gradient (PD-ANPG) algorithm that guarantees an $epsilon$ global optimality gap and $epsilon$ constraint violation with $mathcal{O}(epsilon^{-3})$ sample complexity. This improves the state-of-the-art sample complexity in CMDP by a factor of $mathcal{O}(epsilon^{-1})$.
5/20/2024
🏅
Achieving Zero Constraint Violation for Constrained Reinforcement Learning via Conservative Natural Policy Gradient Primal-Dual Algorithm
Qinbo Bai, Amrit Singh Bedi, Vaneet Aggarwal
0
0
We consider the problem of constrained Markov decision process (CMDP) in continuous state-actions spaces where the goal is to maximize the expected cumulative reward subject to some constraints. We propose a novel Conservative Natural Policy Gradient Primal-Dual Algorithm (C-NPG-PD) to achieve zero constraint violation while achieving state of the art convergence results for the objective value function. For general policy parametrization, we prove convergence of value function to global optimal upto an approximation error due to restricted policy class. We even improve the sample complexity of existing constrained NPG-PD algorithm cite{Ding2020} from $mathcal{O}(1/epsilon^6)$ to $mathcal{O}(1/epsilon^4)$. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to establish zero constraint violation with Natural policy gradient style algorithms for infinite horizon discounted CMDPs. We demonstrate the merits of proposed algorithm via experimental evaluations.
5/20/2024
↗️
Learning Constrained Markov Decision Processes With Non-stationary Rewards and Constraints
Francesco Emanuele Stradi, Anna Lunghi, Matteo Castiglioni, Alberto Marchesi, Nicola Gatti
0
0
In constrained Markov decision processes (CMDPs) with adversarial rewards and constraints, a well-known impossibility result prevents any algorithm from attaining both sublinear regret and sublinear constraint violation, when competing against a best-in-hindsight policy that satisfies constraints on average. In this paper, we show that this negative result can be eased in CMDPs with non-stationary rewards and constraints, by providing algorithms whose performances smoothly degrade as non-stationarity increases. Specifically, we propose algorithms attaining $tilde{mathcal{O}} (sqrt{T} + C)$ regret and positive constraint violation under bandit feedback, where $C$ is a corruption value measuring the environment non-stationarity. This can be $Theta(T)$ in the worst case, coherently with the impossibility result for adversarial CMDPs. First, we design an algorithm with the desired guarantees when $C$ is known. Then, in the case $C$ is unknown, we show how to obtain the same results by embedding such an algorithm in a general meta-procedure. This is of independent interest, as it can be applied to any non-stationary constrained online learning setting.
5/24/2024