Applying Action Masking and Curriculum Learning Techniques to Improve Data Efficiency and Overall Performance in Operational Technology Cyber Security using Reinforcement Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Applying action masking and curriculum learning techniques to improve data efficiency and overall performance in operational technology cyber security using reinforcement learning
- Aims to address the challenges of data scarcity and poor sample efficiency in applying reinforcement learning to cyber security tasks in operational technology (OT) environments
- Proposes two key techniques: action masking and curriculum learning, to enhance the learning process and improve performance
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores using reinforcement learning to improve cyber security in operational technology (OT) systems, which are the industrial control systems that power critical infrastructure like power grids and manufacturing plants.
One of the key challenges in applying reinforcement learning to cyber security tasks in OT environments is the data scarcity problem - there simply isn't enough labeled data available to train the models effectively. The researchers propose two techniques to address this:
-
Action Masking: This involves restricting the actions the reinforcement learning agent can take at any given state, effectively focusing its exploration on the most relevant and productive actions. This helps the agent learn more efficiently from the limited data.
-
Curriculum Learning: Instead of training the agent on the full, complex task right away, the researchers break it down into a series of simpler sub-tasks that gradually increase in difficulty. This "curriculum" allows the agent to build up the necessary skills and knowledge in a stepwise fashion, again improving sample efficiency.
By combining these two techniques, the researchers aim to enhance the data efficiency and overall performance of the reinforcement learning agent when applied to cyber security tasks in OT environments. This could lead to more robust and effective security solutions for critical infrastructure systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a reinforcement learning framework for operational technology (OT) cyber security that leverages action masking and curriculum learning techniques to improve data efficiency and overall performance.
Action Masking: The researchers design an action masking mechanism that restricts the set of available actions for the reinforcement learning agent at each state. This helps the agent focus its exploration on the most relevant and productive actions, leading to more efficient and effective learning from the limited training data typically available in OT cyber security tasks.
Curriculum Learning: The researchers propose a curriculum learning approach that gradually increases the complexity of the task faced by the reinforcement learning agent. The agent first trains on simpler sub-tasks, building up the necessary skills and knowledge, before progressing to more challenging scenarios. This stepwise learning process enhances sample efficiency compared to training on the full, complex task from the start.
The paper evaluates the proposed techniques on a simulated OT cyber security environment, demonstrating significant improvements in data efficiency and overall performance compared to baseline reinforcement learning approaches. The results suggest that the combination of action masking and curriculum learning can be an effective way to apply reinforcement learning to cyber security tasks in resource-constrained OT settings.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to applying reinforcement learning to OT cyber security, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
Generalization to Real-World OT Systems: The experiments are conducted on a simulated environment, so the performance on actual OT systems may differ. Further validation on real-world OT infrastructure would be needed to fully assess the effectiveness of the proposed techniques.
-
Scalability and Adaptability: The paper focuses on a specific cyber security task in the OT domain. Exploring how the action masking and curriculum learning approaches could be generalized to handle a broader range of OT cyber security challenges would be valuable.
-
Interpretability and Explainability: Reinforcement learning models can be opaque "black boxes," making it difficult to understand their decision-making process. Investigating ways to improve the interpretability and explainability of the proposed approach could enhance trust and adoption in critical OT environments.
-
Robustness to Adversarial Attacks: Cyber security systems must be resilient to adversarial attacks that aim to fool or compromise the underlying models. Evaluating the robustness of the reinforcement learning framework to such attacks would be an important area for future research.
Despite these potential limitations, the paper presents a compelling approach to addressing the data efficiency and performance challenges in applying reinforcement learning to OT cyber security. Further research and development in this direction could lead to significant advancements in securing critical infrastructure systems.
Conclusion
This paper explores the use of action masking and curriculum learning techniques to improve the data efficiency and overall performance of reinforcement learning models applied to operational technology (OT) cyber security tasks. By focusing the agent's exploration on the most relevant actions and gradually increasing the complexity of the learning process, the proposed approach aims to overcome the challenges of data scarcity and poor sample efficiency inherent in many OT cyber security scenarios.
The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, suggesting that the combination of action masking and curriculum learning can be a valuable tool for enhancing the application of reinforcement learning to critical infrastructure security. As the OT landscape continues to evolve and the threats to these systems become more sophisticated, innovative solutions like the one presented in this paper will be increasingly important in ensuring the resilience and protection of our vital industrial systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Applying Action Masking and Curriculum Learning Techniques to Improve Data Efficiency and Overall Performance in Operational Technology Cyber Security using Reinforcement Learning
Alec Wilson, William Holmes, Ryan Menzies, Kez Smithson Whitehead
In previous work, the IPMSRL environment (Integrated Platform Management System Reinforcement Learning environment) was developed with the aim of training defensive RL agents in a simulator representing a subset of an IPMS on a maritime vessel under a cyber-attack. This paper extends the use of IPMSRL to enhance realism including the additional dynamics of false positive alerts and alert delay. Applying curriculum learning, in the most difficult environment tested, resulted in an episode reward mean increasing from a baseline result of -2.791 to -0.569. Applying action masking, in the most difficult environment tested, resulted in an episode reward mean increasing from a baseline result of -2.791 to -0.743. Importantly, this level of performance was reached in less than 1 million timesteps, which was far more data efficient than vanilla PPO which reached a lower level of performance after 2.5 million timesteps. The training method which resulted in the highest level of performance observed in this paper was a combination of the application of curriculum learning and action masking, with a mean episode reward of 0.137. This paper also introduces a basic hardcoded defensive agent encoding a representation of cyber security best practice, which provides context to the episode reward mean figures reached by the RL agents. The hardcoded agent managed an episode reward mean of -1.895. This paper therefore shows that applications of curriculum learning and action masking, both independently and in tandem, present a way to overcome the complex real-world dynamics that are present in operational technology cyber security threat remediation.
Read more9/18/2024
0
Efficient Reinforcement Learning of Task Planners for Robotic Palletization through Iterative Action Masking Learning
Zheng Wu, Yichuan Li, Wei Zhan, Changliu Liu, Yun-Hui Liu, Masayoshi Tomizuka
The development of robotic systems for palletization in logistics scenarios is of paramount importance, addressing critical efficiency and precision demands in supply chain management. This paper investigates the application of Reinforcement Learning (RL) in enhancing task planning for such robotic systems. Confronted with the substantial challenge of a vast action space, which is a significant impediment to efficiently apply out-of-the-shelf RL methods, our study introduces a novel method of utilizing supervised learning to iteratively prune and manage the action space effectively. By reducing the complexity of the action space, our approach not only accelerates the learning phase but also ensures the effectiveness and reliability of the task planning in robotic palletization. The experimental results underscore the efficacy of this method, highlighting its potential in improving the performance of RL applications in complex and high-dimensional environments like logistics palletization.
Read more4/9/2024
0
Excluding the Irrelevant: Focusing Reinforcement Learning through Continuous Action Masking
Roland Stolz, Hanna Krasowski, Jakob Thumm, Michael Eichelbeck, Philipp Gassert, Matthias Althoff
Continuous action spaces in reinforcement learning (RL) are commonly defined as interval sets. While intervals usually reflect the action boundaries for tasks well, they can be challenging for learning because the typically large global action space leads to frequent exploration of irrelevant actions. Yet, little task knowledge can be sufficient to identify significantly smaller state-specific sets of relevant actions. Focusing learning on these relevant actions can significantly improve training efficiency and effectiveness. In this paper, we propose to focus learning on the set of relevant actions and introduce three continuous action masking methods for exactly mapping the action space to the state-dependent set of relevant actions. Thus, our methods ensure that only relevant actions are executed, enhancing the predictability of the RL agent and enabling its use in safety-critical applications. We further derive the implications of the proposed methods on the policy gradient. Using Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO), we evaluate our methods on three control tasks, where the relevant action set is computed based on the system dynamics and a relevant state set. Our experiments show that the three action masking methods achieve higher final rewards and converge faster than the baseline without action masking.
Read more6/7/2024
0
Reverse Forward Curriculum Learning for Extreme Sample and Demonstration Efficiency in Reinforcement Learning
Stone Tao, Arth Shukla, Tse-kai Chan, Hao Su
Reinforcement learning (RL) presents a promising framework to learn policies through environment interaction, but often requires an infeasible amount of interaction data to solve complex tasks from sparse rewards. One direction includes augmenting RL with offline data demonstrating desired tasks, but past work often require a lot of high-quality demonstration data that is difficult to obtain, especially for domains such as robotics. Our approach consists of a reverse curriculum followed by a forward curriculum. Unique to our approach compared to past work is the ability to efficiently leverage more than one demonstration via a per-demonstration reverse curriculum generated via state resets. The result of our reverse curriculum is an initial policy that performs well on a narrow initial state distribution and helps overcome difficult exploration problems. A forward curriculum is then used to accelerate the training of the initial policy to perform well on the full initial state distribution of the task and improve demonstration and sample efficiency. We show how the combination of a reverse curriculum and forward curriculum in our method, RFCL, enables significant improvements in demonstration and sample efficiency compared against various state-of-the-art learning-from-demonstration baselines, even solving previously unsolvable tasks that require high precision and control.
Read more5/7/2024