Are Educational Escape Rooms More Effective Than Traditional Lectures for Teaching Software Engineering? A Randomized Controlled Trial

Overview

• This study analyzes the learning effectiveness of a virtual educational escape room for teaching software engineering and compares it to traditional lectures.
• The researchers conducted a randomized controlled trial with 326 software engineering students to evaluate the impact of the educational escape room.
• The results show that students who learned through the escape room had more positive perceptions, significantly increased their knowledge, and outperformed those who learned through a traditional lecture.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers in this study wanted to see if using a virtual escape room could be a more effective way to teach software engineering compared to traditional lectures. Escape rooms are interactive, game-based learning activities that are becoming more popular in education across different subjects.

To test this, the researchers randomly assigned 326 software engineering students to two groups. One group learned about software modeling by playing through a virtual escape room, while the other group learned the same material through a regular lecture. Both groups took tests before and after the lesson to measure how much they learned.

The results showed that the students who used the virtual escape room had very positive opinions about this learning method. They also demonstrated significantly more knowledge gained compared to the students who learned through the lecture. This suggests that game-based learning using educational escape rooms can be more effective than traditional teaching approaches for software engineering education.

The researchers believe this type of virtual educational escape room could be a powerful tool to engage students and help them better understand key software engineering concepts. This builds on previous research showing the motivational impact and effectiveness of game-based learning in educational settings.

Technical Explanation

The study used a randomized controlled trial with a pre- and post-test design. A total of 326 software engineering students participated, with 164 in the experimental group and 162 in the control group.

The experimental group learned software modeling by playing through a custom-built virtual educational escape room. This interactive, game-based learning activity required students to solve puzzles and challenges related to software engineering concepts.

In contrast, the control group learned the same subject matter through a traditional lecture-based format. Both groups took a test before and after the lesson to measure their knowledge gains.

The results showed that the students who learned through the virtual escape room had significantly higher post-test scores compared to the lecture group. The escape room students also reported very positive perceptions and engagement with this learning method.

These findings suggest that game-based learning using virtual escape rooms can be more effective than traditional lectures for teaching software engineering. The interactive, problem-solving nature of the escape room appears to better facilitate knowledge acquisition and retention for these students.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge some limitations to their study. The sample was limited to software engineering students, so the results may not generalize to other disciplines. Additionally, the long-term retention of knowledge was not assessed beyond the immediate post-test.

Further research is needed to evaluate the educational impact of games in different contexts and over longer time periods. It would also be valuable to explore how the specific design elements and mechanics of the virtual escape room contributed to its effectiveness.

Overall, this study provides promising evidence that game-based learning approaches can be a powerful complement to traditional teaching methods in software engineering education. However, more rigorous evaluation is needed to fully understand the benefits and limitations of this innovative instructional approach.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that a virtual educational escape room can be a more effective way to teach software engineering compared to traditional lectures. Students who learned through the interactive, game-based escape room showed greater knowledge gains and more positive perceptions of the learning experience.

These findings suggest that game-based learning approaches like virtual escape rooms have significant potential to enhance software engineering education. By making the learning process more engaging and interactive, these methods may better facilitate the acquisition and retention of critical technical skills.

Further research is needed to explore the design factors and long-term impacts of educational escape rooms. However, this study provides an important proof-of-concept for leveraging game-based learning to improve teaching and learning in software engineering and potentially other technical fields.