Examining and Comparing the Effectiveness of Virtual Reality Serious Games and LEGO Serious Play for Learning Scrum

Overview

• Examines the effectiveness of two game-based learning approaches - virtual reality serious games and LEGO Serious Play - for teaching Scrum and agile practices
• Uses a quasi-experimental design with pre- and post-tests, and a perceptions questionnaire
• Compares learning performance and motivation between the two approaches

Plain English Explanation

This research paper explores the use of two different game-based learning methods to teach Scrum and agile software development practices. The first approach involves a virtual reality serious game, where students play through a simulation. The second approach uses the LEGO Serious Play methodology, where students build physical models with LEGO bricks to represent their understanding.

The study had two groups of software engineering students - one group used the virtual reality game, while the other group participated in the LEGO Serious Play activity. Both groups took pre- and post-tests to measure their learning, and also filled out a questionnaire about their perceptions and motivation.

The results show that both game-based approaches were effective for learning Scrum and agile practices. However, the students who played the virtual reality game performed better on the learning tests compared to the LEGO Serious Play group. This suggests that virtual reality may be a more effective medium for this type of educational content.

The research provides insights into how different game-based learning techniques can be used to teach complex technical subjects like software development methodologies. By making the learning process more engaging and interactive, these approaches may help students better understand and retain the material.

Technical Explanation

The study used a quasi-experimental design with two groups - Group A played the virtual reality serious game, while Group B participated in the LEGO Serious Play activity. Both groups took pre- and post-tests to measure their learning of Scrum and agile practices, as well as a questionnaire to assess their perceptions and motivation.

The virtual reality serious game was developed specifically for this research, and allowed students to take on different roles within a Scrum team and experience the process of planning and executing a software project. The LEGO Serious Play activity involved students building physical models to represent their understanding of Scrum concepts.

The results showed that both game-based learning approaches were effective, with students in both groups demonstrating improved learning performance from the pre-test to the post-test. However, the students in the virtual reality group outperformed their peers in the LEGO Serious Play group on the learning tests.

The researchers suggest that the immersive and interactive nature of the virtual reality simulation may have contributed to the stronger learning outcomes, as it allowed students to actively engage with the Scrum process in a more realistic and embodied way. In contrast, the LEGO Serious Play activity, while still engaging, may have been more abstract and less directly applicable to the specific learning objectives.

Critical Analysis

The research provides a valuable comparison of two game-based learning approaches for teaching Scrum and agile practices. However, the study is limited by its relatively small sample size of 59 students, which may affect the generalizability of the findings.

Additionally, the researchers acknowledge that the virtual reality serious game was specifically designed for this study, while the LEGO Serious Play methodology is a more established approach. This raises questions about the comparability of the two interventions and the potential for bias in the results.

Further research could explore the use of virtual reality serious games and LEGO Serious Play in other educational contexts, as well as investigate the physiological and cognitive responses of students engaged in these game-based learning activities. Longitudinal studies could also examine the long-term retention and transfer of knowledge gained through these approaches.

Conclusion

This research paper provides valuable insights into the use of virtual reality serious games and LEGO Serious Play as game-based learning approaches for teaching Scrum and agile practices. The findings suggest that both methods can be effective in improving learning performance and motivation, but that virtual reality may offer a more immersive and engaging experience that leads to better learning outcomes.

The study highlights the potential of game-based learning to make complex technical subjects more accessible and interactive for students. As game-based learning continues to evolve, further research in this area could lead to innovative pedagogical approaches that better prepare students for the demands of the modern workforce.