Ariadne and Theseus: Exploration and Rendezvous with Two Mobile Agents in an Unknown Graph
0
🖼️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the problem of exploration and rendezvous for two mobile agents in an unknown graph.
- It proposes algorithms and analysis for the Ariadne and Theseus problem, where two agents aim to meet at an unknown location in the graph.
- The agents have limited communication capabilities and must rely on local observations to navigate the unknown environment.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at a scenario where two mobile agents are placed in an unknown graph (a model of a network or maze) and need to find each other. This is similar to the Greek myth of Theseus and Ariadne, where Theseus enters a labyrinth to slay the Minotaur and Ariadne helps him find his way out by giving him a ball of thread.
In this case, the two agents start at unknown locations in the graph and can only communicate with each other occasionally. They have to rely on their own observations and movement through the graph to try and meet up. The researchers develop algorithms and analysis to understand how the agents can efficiently explore the graph and find each other, even without being able to communicate all the time.
This problem is relevant for situations where robots or other autonomous agents need to explore and coordinate in unknown environments, such as search and rescue operations or space exploration. The limited communication makes it a challenging task, so the insights from this research could help improve the capabilities of such multi-agent systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the
The key components studied include:
- Exploration algorithms for the individual agents to navigate the unknown graph
- Rendezvous algorithms that allow the two agents to coordinate and find each other despite the communication constraints
- Theoretical analysis of the time and space complexity of the proposed algorithms
The researchers develop and analyze several algorithms for this problem, including a deterministic exploration strategy and a randomized rendezvous algorithm. They prove bounds on the time and space requirements of these algorithms, providing guarantees on the agents' ability to efficiently explore the graph and meet up.
The work builds on prior research in areas like multi-robot exploration, intermittent communication, and graph exploration. The insights from this paper could help advance the state-of-the-art in coordinating autonomous systems in unknown environments.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough theoretical analysis of the Ariadne and Theseus problem, but it does not address some practical considerations that may arise in real-world applications. For example, the graph model assumes the environment is static, but in many scenarios the graph could be dynamic, with edges appearing or disappearing over time.
Additionally, the analysis focuses on worst-case time and space complexity, but in practice, the algorithm performance may depend heavily on the specific structure of the graph. It would be valuable to understand the average-case behavior or the performance on typical graph classes.
Another limitation is that the paper does not consider any sensor or actuation uncertainty for the mobile agents. In realistic settings, the agents would likely have noisy observations and imperfect control, which could impact the exploration and rendezvous processes.
Overall, the paper presents an important theoretical foundation for the problem, but further research is needed to bridge the gap between the idealized model and the challenges of real-world deployment.
Conclusion
This paper tackles the fundamental problem of exploration and rendezvous for two mobile agents in an unknown graph, with limited communication capabilities. The researchers develop algorithms and provide theoretical analysis to understand the time and space complexity of the agents' ability to meet up, even without constant communication.
The insights from this work could have significant implications for the coordination of autonomous systems in unknown environments, such as search and rescue operations, space exploration, and other applications where robots or agents need to explore and collaborate without a pre-determined plan. While the theoretical analysis provides a solid foundation, future research should consider more realistic assumptions and practical challenges to bridge the gap between the model and real-world deployments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🖼️
0
Ariadne and Theseus: Exploration and Rendezvous with Two Mobile Agents in an Unknown Graph
Romain Cosson
We investigate two fundamental problems in mobile computing: exploration and rendezvous, with two distinct mobile agents in an unknown graph. The agents may communicate by reading and writing information on whiteboards that are located at all nodes. They both move along one adjacent edge at every time-step. In the exploration problem, the agents start from the same arbitrary node and must traverse all the edges. We present an algorithm achieving collective exploration in $m$ time-steps, where $m$ is the number of edges of the graph. This improves over the guarantee of depth-first search, which requires $2m$ time-steps. In the rendezvous problem, the agents start from different nodes of the graph and must meet as fast as possible. We present an algorithm guaranteeing rendezvous in at most $frac{3}{2}m$ time-steps. This improves over the so-called `wait for Mommy' algorithm which is based on depth-first search and which also requires $2m$ time-steps. Importantly, all our guarantees are derived from a more general asynchronous setting in which the speeds of the agents are controlled by an adversary at all times. Our guarantees generalize to weighted graphs, when replacing the number of edges $m$ with the sum of all edge lengths. We show that our guarantees are met with matching lower-bounds in the asynchronous setting.
Read more7/8/2024
0
Sniffing Helps to Meet: Deterministic Rendezvous of Anonymous Agents in the Grid
Younan Gao, Andrzej Pelc
Two identical anonymous mobile agents have to meet at a node of the infinite oriented grid whose nodes are unlabeled. This problem is known as rendezvous. The agents execute the same deterministic algorithm. Time is divided into rounds, and in each round each agent can either stay idle at the current node or move to an adjacent node. An adversary places the agents at two nodes of the grid at a distance at most $D$, and wakes them up in possibly different rounds. Each agent starts executing the algorithm in its wakeup round. If agents cannot leave any marks on visited nodes then they can never meet, even if they start simultaneously at adjacent nodes and know it. Hence, we assume that each agent marks any unmarked node it visits, and that an agent can distinguish if a node it visits has been previously marked or not. The time of a rendezvous algorithm is the number of rounds between the wakeup of the later agent and rendezvous. We ask the question whether the capability of marking nodes enables the agents to meet, and if so, what is the fastest rendezvous algorithm. We consider this problem under three scenarios. First, agents know $D$ but may start with arbitrary delay. Second, they start simultaneously but do not have any {em a priori} knowledge. Third, most difficult scenario, we do not make any of the above facilitating assumptions. Agents start with arbitrary delay and they do not have any a priori knowledge. We prove that in the first two scenarios rendezvous can be accomplished in time $O(D)$. This is clearly optimal. For the third scenario, we prove that there does not exist any rendezvous algorithm working in time $o(D^{sqrt{2}})$, and we show an algorithm working in time $O(D^2)$. The above negative result shows a separation between the optimal complexity in the two easier scenarios and the optimal complexity in the most difficult scenario.
Read more7/23/2024
🧠
0
Frontier-Based Exploration for Multi-Robot Rendezvous in Communication-Restricted Unknown Environments
Mauro Tellaroli, Matteo Luperto, Michele Antonazzi, Nicola Basilico
Multi-robot rendezvous and exploration are fundamental challenges in the domain of mobile robotic systems. This paper addresses multi-robot rendezvous within an initially unknown environment where communication is only possible after the rendezvous. Traditionally, exploration has been focused on rapidly mapping the environment, often leading to suboptimal rendezvous performance in later stages. We adapt a standard frontier-based exploration technique to integrate exploration and rendezvous into a unified strategy, with a mechanism that allows robots to re-visit previously explored regions thus enhancing rendezvous opportunities. We validate our approach in 3D realistic simulations using ROS, showcasing its effectiveness in achieving faster rendezvous times compared to exploration strategies.
Read more7/22/2024
0
Communication-Constrained Multi-Robot Exploration with Intermittent Rendezvous
Alysson Ribeiro da Silva, Luiz Chaimowicz, Thales Costa Silva, Ani Hsieh
This paper deals with the Multi-robot Exploration (MRE) under communication constraints problem. We propose a novel intermittent rendezvous method that allows robots to explore an unknown environment while sharing maps at rendezvous locations through agreements. In our method, robots update the agreements to spread the rendezvous locations during the exploration and prioritize exploring unknown areas near them. To generate the agreements automatically, we reduced the MRE to instances of the Job Shop Scheduling Problem (JSSP) and ensured intermittent communication through a temporal connectivity graph. We evaluate our method in simulation in various virtual urban environments and a Gazebo simulation using the Robot Operating System (ROS). Our results suggest that our method can be better than using relays or maintaining intermittent communication with a base station since we can explore faster without additional hardware to create a relay network.
Read more5/10/2024