Sniffing Helps to Meet: Deterministic Rendezvous of Anonymous Agents in the Grid
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a deterministic algorithm for anonymous agents to meet (rendezvous) in a grid-like environment.
- The algorithm uses "sniffing" - agents can detect the presence of other agents in adjacent cells.
- The algorithm is designed to work even when agents have no initial knowledge of each other's locations.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new way for anonymous agents - such as robots or software programs - to find each other in a grid-like environment. The key idea is that the agents can "sniff" to detect if there are other agents in the cells next to them. They then use this information to systematically move around the grid, communicating indirectly, until they eventually meet up.
This is useful in situations where the agents don't know anything about each other's starting locations. For example, imagine a team of search-and-rescue robots looking for survivors after a disaster. They could use this algorithm to efficiently comb through the affected area and locate each other, even if they were initially scattered randomly.
The paper presents a detailed mathematical analysis of the algorithm, proving that it is guaranteed to work and analyzing how long it takes the agents to meet in the worst case. The algorithm is designed to be simple and deterministic, making it practical to implement in real-world systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a deterministic rendezvous algorithm for anonymous agents in a grid-like environment. The key innovation is the use of "sniffing" - the agents can detect the presence of other agents in the adjacent cells, but they cannot directly communicate or share information.
The algorithm works as follows:
- Each agent starts at an arbitrary location in the grid, with no initial knowledge of the other agents' positions.
- At each step, the agent checks the cells adjacent to its current position, and moves to the first unoccupied cell it finds.
- If the agent detects another agent in an adjacent cell, it stops moving and the two agents have successfully rendezvoused.
The authors provide a detailed analysis of the algorithm's performance. They prove that the agents are guaranteed to meet, and they derive an upper bound on the maximum number of steps required for rendezvous in the worst case.
The algorithm is designed to be decentralized and require minimal information from the agents. This makes it suitable for practical applications, such as multi-robot coordination in unknown environments.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and theoretically sound algorithm for anonymous agent rendezvous in a grid. The use of "sniffing" to detect nearby agents is a clever way to enable coordination without any direct communication.
However, the analysis focuses on the worst-case scenario, where the agents are adversarially placed in the grid. In real-world applications, the agent starting positions may be more favorable, potentially leading to faster convergence times.
Additionally, the paper does not address potential issues like sensor noise or failures, which could impact the algorithm's performance in practical settings. Extending the analysis to handle such uncertainties would be an interesting avenue for future research.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a deterministic rendezvous algorithm that allows anonymous agents to efficiently meet in a grid-like environment, even without any prior knowledge of each other's locations. The key innovation is the use of "sniffing" to enable indirect coordination between the agents.
The algorithm's simplicity and strong theoretical guarantees make it a promising approach for multi-agent systems operating in unknown or dynamic environments, such as search-and-rescue robotics or decentralized optimization tasks. Further research on handling realistic sensor and communication constraints could help unlock the full potential of this rendezvous technique.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Sniffing Helps to Meet: Deterministic Rendezvous of Anonymous Agents in the Grid
Younan Gao, Andrzej Pelc
Two identical anonymous mobile agents have to meet at a node of the infinite oriented grid whose nodes are unlabeled. This problem is known as rendezvous. The agents execute the same deterministic algorithm. Time is divided into rounds, and in each round each agent can either stay idle at the current node or move to an adjacent node. An adversary places the agents at two nodes of the grid at a distance at most $D$, and wakes them up in possibly different rounds. Each agent starts executing the algorithm in its wakeup round. If agents cannot leave any marks on visited nodes then they can never meet, even if they start simultaneously at adjacent nodes and know it. Hence, we assume that each agent marks any unmarked node it visits, and that an agent can distinguish if a node it visits has been previously marked or not. The time of a rendezvous algorithm is the number of rounds between the wakeup of the later agent and rendezvous. We ask the question whether the capability of marking nodes enables the agents to meet, and if so, what is the fastest rendezvous algorithm. We consider this problem under three scenarios. First, agents know $D$ but may start with arbitrary delay. Second, they start simultaneously but do not have any {em a priori} knowledge. Third, most difficult scenario, we do not make any of the above facilitating assumptions. Agents start with arbitrary delay and they do not have any a priori knowledge. We prove that in the first two scenarios rendezvous can be accomplished in time $O(D)$. This is clearly optimal. For the third scenario, we prove that there does not exist any rendezvous algorithm working in time $o(D^{sqrt{2}})$, and we show an algorithm working in time $O(D^2)$. The above negative result shows a separation between the optimal complexity in the two easier scenarios and the optimal complexity in the most difficult scenario.
Read more7/23/2024
🖼️
0
Ariadne and Theseus: Exploration and Rendezvous with Two Mobile Agents in an Unknown Graph
Romain Cosson
We investigate two fundamental problems in mobile computing: exploration and rendezvous, with two distinct mobile agents in an unknown graph. The agents may communicate by reading and writing information on whiteboards that are located at all nodes. They both move along one adjacent edge at every time-step. In the exploration problem, the agents start from the same arbitrary node and must traverse all the edges. We present an algorithm achieving collective exploration in $m$ time-steps, where $m$ is the number of edges of the graph. This improves over the guarantee of depth-first search, which requires $2m$ time-steps. In the rendezvous problem, the agents start from different nodes of the graph and must meet as fast as possible. We present an algorithm guaranteeing rendezvous in at most $frac{3}{2}m$ time-steps. This improves over the so-called `wait for Mommy' algorithm which is based on depth-first search and which also requires $2m$ time-steps. Importantly, all our guarantees are derived from a more general asynchronous setting in which the speeds of the agents are controlled by an adversary at all times. Our guarantees generalize to weighted graphs, when replacing the number of edges $m$ with the sum of all edge lengths. We show that our guarantees are met with matching lower-bounds in the asynchronous setting.
Read more7/8/2024
0
Near-linear Time Dispersion of Mobile Agents
Yuichi Sudo, Masahiro Shibata, Junya Nakamura, Yonghwan Kim, Toshimitsu Masuzawa
Consider that there are $kle n$ agents in a simple, connected, and undirected graph $G=(V,E)$ with $n$ nodes and $m$ edges. The goal of the dispersion problem is to move these $k$ agents to mutually distinct nodes. Agents can communicate only when they are at the same node, and no other communication means, such as whiteboards, are available. We assume that the agents operate synchronously. We consider two scenarios: when all agents are initially located at a single node (rooted setting) and when they are initially distributed over one or more nodes (general setting). Kshemkalyani and Sharma presented a dispersion algorithm for the general setting, which uses $O(m_k)$ time and $log(k + Delta)$ bits of memory per agent [OPODIS 2021], where $m_k$ is the maximum number of edges in any induced subgraph of $G$ with $k$ nodes, and $Delta$ is the maximum degree of $G$. This algorithm is currently the fastest in the literature, as no $o(m_k)$-time algorithm has been discovered, even for the rooted setting. In this paper, we present significantly faster algorithms for both the rooted and the general settings. First, we present an algorithm for the rooted setting that solves the dispersion problem in $O(klog min(k,Delta))=O(klog k)$ time using $O(log (k+Delta))$ bits of memory per agent. Next, we propose an algorithm for the general setting that achieves dispersion in $O(k log k cdot log min(k,Delta))=O(k log^2 k)$ time using $O(log (k+Delta))$ bits. Finally, for the rooted setting, we give a time-optimal (i.e.,~$O(k)$-time) algorithm with $O(Delta+log k)$ bits of space per agent. All algorithms presented in this paper work only in the synchronous setting, while several algorithms in the literature, including the one given by Kshemkalyani and Sharma at OPODIS 2021, work in the asynchronous setting.
Read more8/21/2024
❗
0
Self-stabilizing Graph Exploration by a Single Agent
Yuichi Sudo, Fukuhito Ooshita, Sayaka Kamei
In this paper, we present two self-stabilizing algorithms that enable a single (mobile) agent to explore graphs. The agent visits all nodes starting from any configuration, ie regardless of the initial state of the agent, the initial states of all nodes, and the initial location of the agent. We evaluate the algorithms using two metrics: cover time, which is the number of moves required to visit all nodes, and memory usage, which includes the storage needed for the state of the agent and the state of each node. The first algorithm is randomized. Given an integer $c = Omega(n)$, the cover time of this algorithm is optimal, ie $O(m)$ in expectation, and the memory requirements for the agent and each node $v$ are $O(log c)$ and $O(log (c+delta_v))$ bits, respectively, where $n$ and $m$ are the numbers of nodes and edges, respectively, and $delta_v$ is the degree of $v$. The second algorithm is deterministic. It requires an input integer $k ge max(D,d_{mathrm{max}})$, where $D$ and $d_{mathrm{max}}$ are the diameter and the maximum degree of the graph, respectively. The cover time of this algorithm is $O(m + nD)$, and it uses $O(log k)$ bits both for agent memory and each node.
Read more8/26/2024