Automata-based constraints for language model decoding
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel approach to constrain the decoding of language models using finite-state automata (FSA).
- By incorporating FSA-based constraints, the authors aim to improve the coherence and consistency of the model's output, especially for tasks that require adherence to specific rules or formats.
- The paper explores the integration of FSA constraints into the decoding process of large language models, highlighting the potential advantages and challenges of this technique.
Plain English Explanation
Language models are powerful AI systems that can generate human-like text, but sometimes their output can be inconsistent or deviate from desired formats or rules. This paper presents a way to address this by using finite-state automata (FSA) - a type of mathematical model that can represent and enforce certain rules or patterns.
The key idea is to integrate these FSA-based constraints directly into the decoding process of language models. This means the model not only tries to generate text that sounds natural, but also ensures it follows specific rules or constraints that are defined by the FSA. For example, if you're using a language model to generate a computer program, you could use an FSA to make sure the output always adheres to the syntax and structure of a programming language.
By combining the language model's natural text generation capabilities with the rule-enforcing power of FSA, the authors aim to produce output that is both fluent and consistent with desired formats or guidelines. This could have applications in areas like formal language integration with natural language, code generation and evaluation, and grammar-aligned decoding.
The paper explores the technical details of how to incorporate these FSA constraints into the decoding process, as well as experiments to evaluate the effectiveness of this approach. Overall, it presents a promising direction for improving the coherence and reliability of language model outputs, especially for applications that require strict adherence to certain rules or formats.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel approach to incorporate finite-state automata (FSA) into the decoding process of large language models. FSA are mathematical models that can represent and enforce specific rules or patterns, and the authors explore how to leverage these constraints to improve the coherence and consistency of language model outputs.
The core idea is to define FSA that encode the desired rules or formats for the target task, and then integrate these FSA-based constraints directly into the language model's decoding algorithm. This is achieved by modifying the beam search procedure used in standard language model decoding, such that the model not only considers the most likely next tokens, but also ensures the resulting sequence satisfies the constraints defined by the FSA.
The authors present several technical innovations to enable this integration, including efficient algorithms for FSA intersection and composition, as well as techniques to handle the computational challenges that arise when combining complex FSA constraints with large-scale language models.
The paper also includes extensive experiments to evaluate the effectiveness of this approach across a variety of tasks, such as extracting finite-state automata from transformer models, generating code that satisfies specified constraints, and ensuring consistency in the output of large language models. The results demonstrate that the FSA-based constraints can significantly improve the coherence and reliability of the language model's outputs, while maintaining strong performance on standard language modeling benchmarks.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to improving the consistency and reliability of language model outputs by incorporating finite-state automata-based constraints. The authors have carefully designed the technical integration of these constraints into the decoding process, and the experimental results are compelling.
One potential limitation of the approach is the overhead involved in defining and composing the FSA constraints, which could become computationally expensive for complex tasks or large-scale models. The paper acknowledges this challenge and proposes several optimization techniques, but further research may be needed to streamline the integration of FSA constraints, especially for real-world applications.
Additionally, the paper focuses primarily on the technical aspects of the approach and does not delve deeply into the broader implications or potential societal impacts of this technology. As language models become more powerful and widely deployed, it will be important to consider ethical and responsible AI principles, such as transparency, accountability, and fairness, when developing techniques to constrain and control their outputs.
Overall, this paper presents an innovative and promising approach to enhancing the coherence and consistency of language model outputs. The integration of formal methods like FSA into language modeling is an exciting area of research that could have significant implications for a wide range of applications, from code generation to grammar-aligned text generation. As the field continues to evolve, it will be crucial to address the technical challenges and consider the broader societal implications of these advancements.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach to constrain the decoding of large language models using finite-state automata (FSA). By integrating FSA-based constraints directly into the decoding process, the authors aim to improve the coherence and consistency of the model's output, particularly for tasks that require adherence to specific rules or formats.
The technical innovations presented in this work, such as efficient algorithms for FSA intersection and composition, demonstrate the feasibility of this approach and its potential impact on various applications, from code generation to grammar-aligned text generation.
While the paper focuses primarily on the technical aspects, it also highlights the broader implications of this research, particularly in the context of responsible AI development and the need to address ethical considerations, such as transparency and fairness, as language models become more powerful and widely deployed.
Overall, this paper presents an exciting and promising direction for enhancing the reliability and consistency of language model outputs, with potential applications across various domains that require adherence to specific rules or formats. As the field continues to evolve, the integration of formal methods like FSA into language modeling could significantly impact the way we develop and deploy these powerful AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Automata-based constraints for language model decoding
Terry Koo, Frederick Liu, Luheng He
LMs are often expected to generate strings in some formal language; for example, structured data, API calls, or code snippets. Although LMs can be tuned to improve their adherence to formal syntax, this does not guarantee conformance, especially with smaller LMs suitable for large-scale deployment. In addition, tuning requires significant resources, making it impractical for uncommon or task-specific formats. To prevent downstream parsing errors we would ideally constrain the LM to only produce valid output, but this is severely complicated by tokenization, which is typically both ambiguous and misaligned with the formal grammar. We solve these issues through the application of automata theory, deriving an efficient closed-form solution for the regular languages, a broad class of formal languages with many practical applications, including API calls or schema-guided JSON and YAML. We also discuss pragmatic extensions for coping with the issue of high branching factor. Finally, we extend our techniques to deterministic context-free languages, which similarly admit an efficient closed-form solution. In spite of its flexibility and representative power, our approach only requires access to per-token decoding logits and lowers into simple calculations that are independent of LM size, making it both efficient and easy to apply to almost any LM architecture.
Read more7/15/2024
0
Automata Extraction from Transformers
Yihao Zhang, Zeming Wei, Meng Sun
In modern machine (ML) learning systems, Transformer-based architectures have achieved milestone success across a broad spectrum of tasks, yet understanding their operational mechanisms remains an open problem. To improve the transparency of ML systems, automata extraction methods, which interpret stateful ML models as automata typically through formal languages, have proven effective for explaining the mechanism of recurrent neural networks (RNNs). However, few works have been applied to this paradigm to Transformer models. In particular, understanding their processing of formal languages and identifying their limitations in this area remains unexplored. In this paper, we propose an automata extraction algorithm specifically designed for Transformer models. Treating the Transformer model as a black-box system, we track the model through the transformation process of their internal latent representations during their operations, and then use classical pedagogical approaches like L* algorithm to interpret them as deterministic finite-state automata (DFA). Overall, our study reveals how the Transformer model comprehends the structure of formal languages, which not only enhances the interpretability of the Transformer-based ML systems but also marks a crucial step toward a deeper understanding of how ML systems process formal languages. Code and data are available at https://github.com/Zhang-Yihao/Transfomer2DFA.
Read more6/11/2024
💬
0
Formal-LLM: Integrating Formal Language and Natural Language for Controllable LLM-based Agents
Zelong Li, Wenyue Hua, Hao Wang, He Zhu, Yongfeng Zhang
Recent advancements on Large Language Models (LLMs) enable AI Agents to automatically generate and execute multi-step plans to solve complex tasks. However, since LLM's content generation process is hardly controllable, current LLM-based agents frequently generate invalid or non-executable plans, which jeopardizes the performance of the generated plans and corrupts users' trust in LLM-based agents. In response, this paper proposes a novel Formal-LLM framework for LLM-based agents by integrating the expressiveness of natural language and the precision of formal language. Specifically, the framework allows agent developers to express their requirements or constraints for the planning process as an automaton. A stack-based LLM plan generation process is then conducted under the supervision of the automaton to ensure that the generated plan satisfies the constraints, making the planning process controllable. We conduct experiments on both benchmark tasks and practical real-life tasks, and our framework achieves over 50% overall performance increase, which validates the feasibility and effectiveness of employing Formal-LLM to guide the plan generation of agents, preventing the agents from generating invalid and unsuccessful plans. Further, more controllable LLM-based agents can facilitate the broader utilization of LLM in application scenarios where high validity of planning is essential. The source code of this work is available at https://github.com/agiresearch/Formal-LLM.
Read more8/13/2024
💬
0
ConCodeEval: Evaluating Large Language Models for Code Constraints in Domain-Specific Languages
Mehant Kammakomati, Sameer Pimparkhede, Srikanth Tamilselvam, Prince Kumar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
Recent work shows Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle to understand natural language constraints for various text generation tasks in zero- and few-shot settings. While, in the code domain, there is wide usage of constraints in code format to maintain the integrity of code written in Domain-Specific Languages (DSLs) like JSON and YAML which are widely used for system-level programming tasks in enterprises. Given that LLMs are increasingly used for system-level code tasks, evaluating if they can comprehend these code constraints is crucial. However, no work has been done to evaluate their controllability over code constraints. Hence, we introduce ConCodeEval, a first-of-its-kind benchmark having two novel tasks for code constraints across five representations. Our findings suggest that language models struggle with code constraints. Code languages that perform excellently for normal code tasks do not perform well when the same languages represent fine-grained constraints.
Read more9/2/2024