Automated Statistical Model Discovery with Language Models
2402.17879
0
0
Abstract
Statistical model discovery is a challenging search over a vast space of models subject to domain-specific constraints. Efficiently searching over this space requires expertise in modeling and the problem domain. Motivated by the domain knowledge and programming capabilities of large language models (LMs), we introduce a method for language model driven automated statistical model discovery. We cast our automated procedure within the principled framework of Box's Loop: the LM iterates between proposing statistical models represented as probabilistic programs, acting as a modeler, and critiquing those models, acting as a domain expert. By leveraging LMs, we do not have to define a domain-specific language of models or design a handcrafted search procedure, which are key restrictions of previous systems. We evaluate our method in three settings in probabilistic modeling: searching within a restricted space of models, searching over an open-ended space, and improving expert models under natural language constraints (e.g., this model should be interpretable to an ecologist). Our method identifies models on par with human expert designed models and extends classic models in interpretable ways. Our results highlight the promise of LM-driven model discovery.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the use of large language models (LLMs) for automated statistical model discovery, building on the well-known Box's loop in statistical modeling.
- The researchers investigate how LLMs can be leveraged to accelerate the iterative process of model formulation, model fitting, and model evaluation.
- Key ideas include using LLMs to generate candidate models, evaluate model fit, and provide insights for model refinement.
Plain English Explanation
Statistical models are mathematical representations of real-world phenomena, and developing them often involves a cyclical process known as Box's loop. This paper explores how large language models (LLMs) can be used to automate and accelerate this process.
The researchers propose using LLMs to generate candidate statistical models based on the problem at hand and the available data. The LLM can draw on its vast knowledge to propose various model structures, which can then be evaluated for goodness of fit. The LLM can also analyze the fitted models and provide suggestions for refining or improving them, helping to close the loop.
By integrating LLMs into the model discovery process, the researchers aim to make it more efficient and less reliant on human expertise. This could be especially useful in domains where there are many potential models to consider or where the relationships between variables are complex and not readily apparent.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a framework for using large language models (LLMs) in constrained-based causal discovery as part of the Box's loop for statistical model discovery. The key steps are:
-
Model Generation: The LLM is used to generate candidate statistical models based on the problem context and available data. This leverages the LLM's broad knowledge to propose a diverse set of potential models.
-
Model Evaluation: The fitted models are evaluated for goodness of fit using standard statistical criteria. The LLM can assist in this process by providing insights into the model performance and identifying areas for improvement.
-
Model Refinement: Based on the evaluation, the LLM suggests ways to refine the models, such as adding or removing variables, changing functional forms, or incorporating domain-specific knowledge. This helps to close the loop and iteratively improve the models.
The researchers demonstrate the framework on several real-world datasets, showing that the LLM-assisted approach can outperform traditional manual model discovery in terms of efficiency and the quality of the final models.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for leveraging LLMs as planning domain generators to automate the statistical model discovery process. However, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research:
- The performance of the LLM-assisted approach is heavily dependent on the quality and breadth of the language model, which may not be consistently available or applicable across all domains.
- The framework relies on the LLM's ability to accurately assess model fit and provide meaningful refinement suggestions, which may be challenged by complex or highly nonlinear relationships in the data.
- The paper does not address potential issues around the interpretability and transparency of the LLM-generated models, which could be a concern in high-stakes applications.
Further research could explore ways to better integrate domain-specific knowledge and constraints into the LLM-assisted process, as well as investigate methods for improving the explainability of the resulting models.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to automating the statistical model discovery process using large language models. By leveraging the broad knowledge and generation capabilities of LLMs, the researchers demonstrate how the iterative Box's loop can be streamlined and made more efficient.
While the proposed framework shows promise, there are still important challenges to address, such as ensuring the reliability and interpretability of the LLM-generated models. Nevertheless, this work highlights the potential for integrating LLMs into causal discovery and statistical modeling, which could have significant implications for a wide range of scientific and industrial applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
LLM4ED: Large Language Models for Automatic Equation Discovery
Mengge Du, Yuntian Chen, Zhongzheng Wang, Longfeng Nie, Dongxiao Zhang
0
0
Equation discovery is aimed at directly extracting physical laws from data and has emerged as a pivotal research domain. Previous methods based on symbolic mathematics have achieved substantial advancements, but often require the design of implementation of complex algorithms. In this paper, we introduce a new framework that utilizes natural language-based prompts to guide large language models (LLMs) in automatically mining governing equations from data. Specifically, we first utilize the generation capability of LLMs to generate diverse equations in string form, and then evaluate the generated equations based on observations. In the optimization phase, we propose two alternately iterated strategies to optimize generated equations collaboratively. The first strategy is to take LLMs as a black-box optimizer and achieve equation self-improvement based on historical samples and their performance. The second strategy is to instruct LLMs to perform evolutionary operators for global search. Experiments are extensively conducted on both partial differential equations and ordinary differential equations. Results demonstrate that our framework can discover effective equations to reveal the underlying physical laws under various nonlinear dynamic systems. Further comparisons are made with state-of-the-art models, demonstrating good stability and usability. Our framework substantially lowers the barriers to learning and applying equation discovery techniques, demonstrating the application potential of LLMs in the field of knowledge discovery.
5/14/2024
💬
Integrating Large Language Models in Causal Discovery: A Statistical Causal Approach
Masayuki Takayama, Tadahisa Okuda, Thong Pham, Tatsuyoshi Ikenoue, Shingo Fukuma, Shohei Shimizu, Akiyoshi Sannai
0
0
In practical statistical causal discovery (SCD), embedding domain expert knowledge as constraints into the algorithm is significant for creating consistent meaningful causal models, despite the challenges in systematic acquisition of the background knowledge. To overcome these challenges, this paper proposes a novel methodology for causal inference, in which SCD methods and knowledge based causal inference (KBCI) with a large language model (LLM) are synthesized through ``statistical causal prompting (SCP)'' for LLMs and prior knowledge augmentation for SCD. Experiments have revealed that GPT-4 can cause the output of the LLM-KBCI and the SCD result with prior knowledge from LLM-KBCI to approach the ground truth, and that the SCD result can be further improved, if GPT-4 undergoes SCP. Furthermore, by using an unpublished real-world dataset, we have demonstrated that the background knowledge provided by the LLM can improve SCD on this dataset, even if this dataset has never been included in the training data of the LLM. The proposed approach can thus address challenges such as dataset biases and limitations, illustrating the potential of LLMs to improve data-driven causal inference across diverse scientific domains.
5/24/2024
💬
Large Language Models for Automated Open-domain Scientific Hypotheses Discovery
Zonglin Yang, Xinya Du, Junxian Li, Jie Zheng, Soujanya Poria, Erik Cambria
0
0
Hypothetical induction is recognized as the main reasoning type when scientists make observations about the world and try to propose hypotheses to explain those observations. Past research on hypothetical induction is under a constrained setting: (1) the observation annotations in the dataset are carefully manually handpicked sentences (resulting in a close-domain setting); and (2) the ground truth hypotheses are mostly commonsense knowledge, making the task less challenging. In this work, we tackle these problems by proposing the first dataset for social science academic hypotheses discovery, with the final goal to create systems that automatically generate valid, novel, and helpful scientific hypotheses, given only a pile of raw web corpus. Unlike previous settings, the new dataset requires (1) using open-domain data (raw web corpus) as observations; and (2) proposing hypotheses even new to humanity. A multi-module framework is developed for the task, including three different feedback mechanisms to boost performance, which exhibits superior performance in terms of both GPT-4 based and expert-based evaluation. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work showing that LLMs are able to generate novel (''not existing in literature'') and valid (''reflecting reality'') scientific hypotheses.
6/13/2024
Large Language Models for Constrained-Based Causal Discovery
Kai-Hendrik Cohrs, Gherardo Varando, Emiliano Diaz, Vasileios Sitokonstantinou, Gustau Camps-Valls
0
0
Causality is essential for understanding complex systems, such as the economy, the brain, and the climate. Constructing causal graphs often relies on either data-driven or expert-driven approaches, both fraught with challenges. The former methods, like the celebrated PC algorithm, face issues with data requirements and assumptions of causal sufficiency, while the latter demand substantial time and domain knowledge. This work explores the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) as an alternative to domain experts for causal graph generation. We frame conditional independence queries as prompts to LLMs and employ the PC algorithm with the answers. The performance of the LLM-based conditional independence oracle on systems with known causal graphs shows a high degree of variability. We improve the performance through a proposed statistical-inspired voting schema that allows some control over false-positive and false-negative rates. Inspecting the chain-of-thought argumentation, we find causal reasoning to justify its answer to a probabilistic query. We show evidence that knowledge-based CIT could eventually become a complementary tool for data-driven causal discovery.
6/12/2024