Automatic Extraction of Linguistic Description from Fuzzy Rule Base
2404.03058
0
0
⛏️
Abstract
Neuro-fuzzy systems are a technique of explainable artificial intelligence (XAI). They elaborate knowledge models as a set of fuzzy rules. Fuzzy sets are crucial components of fuzzy rules. They are used to model linguistic terms. In this paper, we present an automatic extraction of fuzzy rules in the natural English language. Full implementation is available free from a public repository.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Neuro-fuzzy systems are a type of explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) that use fuzzy rules to model knowledge.
- Fuzzy sets are crucial components of these fuzzy rules, used to represent linguistic terms.
- The paper presents an automatic method for extracting fuzzy rules in natural English language.
- The full implementation is freely available in a public repository.
Plain English Explanation
Neuro-fuzzy systems are a way of making AI systems that are more understandable to humans. They use a set of fuzzy rules to represent knowledge, rather than just having a "black box" algorithm. Fuzzy rules are based on fuzzy sets, which can represent concepts like "high," "medium," or "low" in a more natural way than traditional on-off categories.
In this paper, the researchers developed a method to automatically generate these fuzzy rules from data, and express them in plain English. This makes it easier for people to understand how the AI system is making decisions, rather than just seeing the final output. The researchers have also made the full system available for others to use and build upon.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a technique for automatically extracting fuzzy rules from data and expressing them in natural language. Fuzzy sets are a key component of these fuzzy rules, allowing the system to model linguistic concepts like "high," "medium," and "low" in a more nuanced way than traditional binary categorization.
The researchers developed an algorithm to analyze data and automatically generate a set of fuzzy rules that can explain the underlying patterns. These rules are then translated into natural language statements, making the reasoning of the AI system more transparent and interpretable.
The full implementation of this approach is provided in a public repository, enabling others to utilize and build upon this work in developing more explainable AI systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a promising approach for enhancing the interpretability of AI systems through the use of neuro-fuzzy techniques. By automatically extracting fuzzy rules and expressing them in natural language, the method helps to address the "black box" problem that often plagues complex machine learning models.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential limitations or challenges of this approach. For example, it does not discuss how well the automatically generated rules capture the nuances and uncertainties of real-world phenomena, or how the performance of the system compares to other XAI techniques.
Additionally, the paper does not explore potential biases or ethical considerations that may arise from the use of this technology. As with any AI system, there is a risk of amplifying existing societal biases or making decisions that have unintended negative consequences.
Further research and testing would be needed to fully assess the robustness and reliability of this neuro-fuzzy approach to XAI, as well as its broader implications for the development and deployment of AI systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents an innovative technique for enhancing the interpretability of AI systems through the use of neuro-fuzzy methods. By automatically extracting fuzzy rules and expressing them in natural language, the approach offers a promising way to make AI decision-making more transparent and understandable to human users.
The availability of the full implementation in a public repository is a valuable contribution, as it allows others to build upon this work and further explore the potential of neuro-fuzzy systems for explainable AI. As the field of AI continues to advance, approaches like this that prioritize interpretability and trustworthiness will be increasingly important for ensuring the responsible development and deployment of these powerful technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Enabling Regional Explainability by Automatic and Model-agnostic Rule Extraction
Yu Chen, Tianyu Cui, Alexander Capstick, Nan Fletcher-Loyd, Payam Barnaghi
0
0
In Explainable AI, rule extraction translates model knowledge into logical rules, such as IF-THEN statements, crucial for understanding patterns learned by black-box models. This could significantly aid in fields like disease diagnosis, disease progression estimation, or drug discovery. However, such application domains often contain imbalanced data, with the class of interest underrepresented. Existing methods inevitably compromise the performance of rules for the minor class to maximise the overall performance. As the first attempt in this field, we propose a model-agnostic approach for extracting rules from specific subgroups of data, featuring automatic rule generation for numerical features. This method enhances the regional explainability of machine learning models and offers wider applicability compared to existing methods. We additionally introduce a new method for selecting features to compose rules, reducing computational costs in high-dimensional spaces. Experiments across various datasets and models demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods.
6/27/2024
Natural Learning
Hadi Fanaee-T
0
0
We introduce Natural Learning (NL), a novel algorithm that elevates the explainability and interpretability of machine learning to an extreme level. NL simplifies decisions into intuitive rules, like We rejected your loan because your income, employment status, and age collectively resemble a rejected prototype more than an accepted prototype. When applied to real-life datasets, NL produces impressive results. For example, in a colon cancer dataset with 1545 patients and 10935 genes, NL achieves 98.1% accuracy, comparable to DNNs and RF, by analyzing just 3 genes of test samples against 2 discovered prototypes. Similarly, in the UCI's WDBC dataset, NL achieves 98.3% accuracy using only 7 features and 2 prototypes. Even on the MNIST dataset (0 vs. 1), NL achieves 99.5% accuracy with only 3 pixels from 2 prototype images. NL is inspired by prototype theory, an old concept in cognitive psychology suggesting that people learn single sparse prototypes to categorize objects. Leveraging this relaxed assumption, we redesign Support Vector Machines (SVM), replacing its mathematical formulation with a fully nearest-neighbor-based solution, and to address the curse of dimensionality, we utilize locality-sensitive hashing. Following theory's generalizability principle, we propose a recursive method to prune non-core features. As a result, NL efficiently discovers the sparsest prototypes in O(n^2pL) with high parallelization capacity in terms of n. Evaluation of NL with 17 benchmark datasets shows its significant outperformance compared to decision trees and logistic regression, two methods widely favored in healthcare for their interpretability. Moreover, NL achieves performance comparable to finetuned black-box models such as deep neural networks and random forests in 40% of cases, with only a 1-2% lower average accuracy. The code is available via http://natural-learning.cc.
4/10/2024
Doing Experiments and Revising Rules with Natural Language and Probabilistic Reasoning
Wasu Top Piriyakulkij, Kevin Ellis
0
0
We build a computational model of how humans actively infer hidden rules by doing experiments. The basic principles behind the model is that, even if the rule is deterministic, the learner considers a broader space of fuzzy probabilistic rules, which it represents in natural language, and updates its hypotheses online after each experiment according to approximately Bayesian principles. In the same framework we also model experiment design according to information-theoretic criteria. We find that the combination of these three principles -- explicit hypotheses, probabilistic rules, and online updates -- can explain human performance on a Zendo-style task, and that removing any of these components leaves the model unable to account for the data.
5/8/2024
📉
XXAI: Towards eXplicitly eXplainable Artificial Intelligence
V. L. Kalmykov, L. V. Kalmykov
0
0
There are concerns about the reliability and safety of artificial intelligence (AI) based on sub-symbolic neural networks because its decisions cannot be explained explicitly. This is the black box problem of modern AI. At the same time, symbolic AI has the nature of a white box and is able to ensure the reliability and safety of its decisions. However, several problems prevent the widespread use of symbolic AI: the opacity of mathematical models and natural language terms, the lack of a unified ontology, and the combinatorial explosion of search capabilities. To solve the black-box problem of AI, we propose eXplicitly eXplainable AI (XXAI) - a fully transparent white-box AI based on deterministic logical cellular automata whose rules are derived from the first principles of the general theory of the relevant domain. In this case, the general theory of the domain plays the role of a knowledge base for deriving the inferences of the cellular automata. A cellular automaton implements parallel multi-level logical inference at all levels of organization - from local interactions of the element base to the system as a whole. Our verification of several ecological hypotheses sets a precedent for the successful implementation of the proposed solution. XXAI is able to automatically verify the reliability, security and ethics of sub-symbolic neural network solutions in both the final and training phases. In this article, we present precedents for the successful implementation of XXAI, the theoretical and methodological foundations for its further development, and discuss prospects for the future.
5/21/2024