Average Causal Effect Estimation in DAGs with Hidden Variables: Extensions of Back-Door and Front-Door Criteria

Read original: arXiv:2409.03962 - Published 9/9/2024 by Anna Guo, Razieh Nabi

🔍

Overview

The paper introduces novel estimators for causal effects in directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) with hidden variables.
Existing methods face challenges with density estimation, numerical integration, and ensuring estimates stay within the parameter space.
The proposed estimators leverage machine learning to address these issues while maintaining key statistical properties.
The researchers have developed an R package called flexCausal to facilitate practical application of their methods.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on a statistical concept called causal inference, which is about understanding the cause-and-effect relationships between different factors. This is important in many fields, like medicine, social sciences, and economics, where researchers want to know the impact of an intervention or treatment.

The researchers looked at a specific type of causal model called a directed acyclic graph (DAG), which can have hidden or unobserved variables. Previous methods for estimating causal effects in these types of models had some challenges. For example, they struggled with accurately estimating certain statistical quantities, and the estimates they produced could sometimes fall outside the valid range of the causal effect being measured.

To address these issues, the researchers developed new statistical estimators that use machine learning techniques. These new estimators have some desirable properties, like being able to provide accurate estimates even if some of the underlying statistical models are misspecified. The researchers also developed an R software package to make it easier for others to use their methods.

The key innovation in this paper is the development of these new causal effect estimators that can handle the complexities of DAGs with hidden variables, while maintaining good statistical properties. This could lead to improved causal inference in a wide range of application domains.

Technical Explanation

The identification theory for causal effects in directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) with hidden variables is well-developed, but methods for estimating and inferring certain causal parameters (known as "functionals") beyond the g-formula remain limited.

Previous studies have proposed semiparametric estimators for identifiable functionals in a broad class of DAGs with hidden variables. While demonstrating desirable properties like double robustness in some models, these existing estimators face challenges, particularly with density estimation and numerical integration for continuous variables. Their estimates may also fall outside the valid parameter space of the target estimand.

To address these challenges, the researchers introduce novel one-step corrected plug-in and targeted minimum loss-based estimators of causal effects for a class of DAGs that extend classical back-door and front-door criteria. These estimators leverage machine learning to minimize modeling assumptions while ensuring key statistical properties such as asymptotic linearity, double robustness, efficiency, and staying within the bounds of the target parameter space.

The researchers establish conditions for the nuisance functional estimates in terms of L2(P)-norms to achieve root-n consistent causal effect estimates. They have also developed the flexCausal package in R to facilitate the practical application of their methods.

Critical Analysis

The paper addresses important challenges in causal inference for DAGs with hidden variables, and the proposed estimators demonstrate promising statistical properties. However, the paper does not provide a comprehensive evaluation of the methods' performance across a variety of realistic scenarios.

While the researchers establish theoretical conditions for consistent estimation, the practical implications of these conditions, such as the sample sizes required to satisfy them, are not explored in depth. Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational complexity of the proposed methods, which could be a concern when working with large or high-dimensional datasets.

Furthermore, the paper does not investigate the sensitivity of the methods to violations of the underlying assumptions, such as the correctness of the DAG structure or the validity of the treatment primal fixability criterion. Exploring the robustness of the methods to such violations would be valuable for understanding their real-world applicability.

Overall, the paper makes a significant contribution to the field of causal inference, but further empirical evaluation and exploration of the practical limitations of the proposed methods would strengthen the work and its impact.

Conclusion

This paper introduces novel causal effect estimators for a class of directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) with hidden variables, addressing limitations of existing methods. The proposed one-step corrected plug-in and targeted minimum loss-based estimators leverage machine learning to improve upon challenges such as density estimation, numerical integration, and ensuring estimates stay within the parameter space.

By establishing theoretical conditions for consistent estimation and developing an R package to facilitate practical application, the researchers have made an important advancement in the field of causal inference. These methods could have a significant impact on fields that rely on understanding cause-and-effect relationships, such as medicine, social sciences, and economics.

However, the paper would benefit from a more comprehensive evaluation of the methods' performance and practical limitations. Further research is needed to fully understand the strengths and weaknesses of the proposed estimators in realistic scenarios.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🔍

Average Causal Effect Estimation in DAGs with Hidden Variables: Extensions of Back-Door and Front-Door Criteria

Anna Guo, Razieh Nabi

The identification theory for causal effects in directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) with hidden variables is well-developed, but methods for estimating and inferring functionals beyond the g-formula remain limited. Previous studies have proposed semiparametric estimators for identifiable functionals in a broad class of DAGs with hidden variables. While demonstrating double robustness in some models, existing estimators face challenges, particularly with density estimation and numerical integration for continuous variables, and their estimates may fall outside the parameter space of the target estimand. Their asymptotic properties are also underexplored, especially when using flexible statistical and machine learning models for nuisance estimation. This study addresses these challenges by introducing novel one-step corrected plug-in and targeted minimum loss-based estimators of causal effects for a class of DAGs that extend classical back-door and front-door criteria (known as the treatment primal fixability criterion in prior literature). These estimators leverage machine learning to minimize modeling assumptions while ensuring key statistical properties such as asymptotic linearity, double robustness, efficiency, and staying within the bounds of the target parameter space. We establish conditions for nuisance functional estimates in terms of L2(P)-norms to achieve root-n consistent causal effect estimates. To facilitate practical application, we have developed the flexCausal package in R.

9/9/2024

↗️

Toward identifiability of total effects in summary causal graphs with latent confounders: an extension of the front-door criterion

Charles K. Assaad

Conducting experiments to estimate total effects can be challenging due to cost, ethical concerns, or practical limitations. As an alternative, researchers often rely on causal graphs to determine if it is possible to identify these effects from observational data. Identifying total effects in fully specified non-temporal causal graphs has garnered considerable attention, with Pearl's front-door criterion enabling the identification of total effects in the presence of latent confounding even when no variable set is sufficient for adjustment. However, specifying a complete causal graph is challenging in many domains. Extending these identifiability results to partially specified graphs is crucial, particularly in dynamic systems where causal relationships evolve over time. This paper addresses the challenge of identifying total effects using a specific and well-known partially specified graph in dynamic systems called a summary causal graph, which does not specify the temporal lag between causal relations and can contain cycles. In particular, this paper presents sufficient graphical conditions for identifying total effects from observational data, even in the presence of hidden confounding and when no variable set is sufficient for adjustment, contributing to the ongoing effort to understand and estimate causal effects from observational data using summary causal graphs.

6/11/2024

Effective Causal Discovery under Identifiable Heteroscedastic Noise Model

Naiyu Yin, Tian Gao, Yue Yu, Qiang Ji

Capturing the underlying structural causal relations represented by Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) has been a fundamental task in various AI disciplines. Causal DAG learning via the continuous optimization framework has recently achieved promising performance in terms of both accuracy and efficiency. However, most methods make strong assumptions of homoscedastic noise, i.e., exogenous noises have equal variances across variables, observations, or even both. The noises in real data usually violate both assumptions due to the biases introduced by different data collection processes. To address the issue of heteroscedastic noise, we introduce relaxed and implementable sufficient conditions, proving the identifiability of a general class of SEM subject to these conditions. Based on the identifiable general SEM, we propose a novel formulation for DAG learning that accounts for the variation in noise variance across variables and observations. We then propose an effective two-phase iterative DAG learning algorithm to address the increasing optimization difficulties and to learn a causal DAG from data with heteroscedastic variable noise under varying variance. We show significant empirical gains of the proposed approaches over state-of-the-art methods on both synthetic data and real data.

6/11/2024

Estimating Causal Effects from Learned Causal Networks

Anna Raichev, Alexander Ihler, Jin Tian, Rina Dechter

The standard approach to answering an identifiable causal-effect query (e.g., $P(Y|do(X)$) when given a causal diagram and observational data is to first generate an estimand, or probabilistic expression over the observable variables, which is then evaluated using the observational data. In this paper, we propose an alternative paradigm for answering causal-effect queries over discrete observable variables. We propose to instead learn the causal Bayesian network and its confounding latent variables directly from the observational data. Then, efficient probabilistic graphical model (PGM) algorithms can be applied to the learned model to answer queries. Perhaps surprisingly, we show that this emph{model completion} learning approach can be more effective than estimand approaches, particularly for larger models in which the estimand expressions become computationally difficult. We illustrate our method's potential using a benchmark collection of Bayesian networks and synthetically generated causal models.

8/28/2024