Basis Selection: Low-Rank Decomposition of Pretrained Large Language Models for Target Applications
2405.15877
0
0
Abstract
Large language models (LLMs) significantly enhance the performance of various applications, but they are computationally intensive and energy-demanding. This makes it challenging to deploy them on devices with limited resources, such as personal computers and mobile/wearable devices, and results in substantial inference costs in resource-rich environments like cloud servers. To extend the use of LLMs, we introduce a low-rank decomposition approach to effectively compress these models, tailored to the requirements of specific applications. We observe that LLMs pretrained on general datasets contain many redundant components not needed for particular applications. Our method focuses on identifying and removing these redundant parts, retaining only the necessary elements for the target applications. Specifically, we represent the weight matrices of LLMs as a linear combination of base components. We then prune the irrelevant bases and enhance the model with new bases beneficial for specific applications. Deep compression results on the Llama 2-7b and -13B models, conducted on target applications including mathematical reasoning and code generation, show that our method significantly reduces model size while maintaining comparable accuracy to state-of-the-art low-rank compression techniques.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a method for compressing and adapting large pre-trained language models to specific target applications.
- The key idea is to decompose the model's weights into a low-rank basis, which can then be fine-tuned on the target task while maintaining the model's performance.
- This approach allows for significant model compression and improved efficiency, while retaining the strong performance of the original large language model.
Plain English Explanation
When it comes to powerful language models like GPT-3, they can be incredibly useful, but they're also huge and unwieldy. This paper proposes a way to take these massive models and compress them down to a more manageable size, without losing too much of their capabilities.
The key insight is that a lot of the information in these huge models is actually redundant. There's a relatively small set of core "features" that are doing most of the work, and the rest is just fluff. So the researchers figured out a way to identify those core features and use them as a basis to represent the whole model.
This "low-rank decomposition" approach lets them keep the powerful language understanding of the original model, while shrinking it down to a fraction of the size. It's kind of like taking a huge encyclopedia and distilling it down to the most essential concepts and definitions.
By compressing the model in this way, they can then fine-tune it for specific tasks, like answering questions or generating text. The compressed model can be adapted to these target applications much more efficiently than trying to fine-tune the full, gigantic original model.
Technical Explanation
The key technical innovation in this paper is a method for low-rank decomposition of pre-trained language models. The authors observe that the weight matrices in large language models like GPT-3 often have a lot of redundant information, and can be well-approximated by a low-rank representation.
To exploit this, they propose a "basis selection" approach, where they first identify a small set of "basis" vectors that can be used to reconstruct the original model weights. They do this by performing a singular value decomposition (SVD) on the weight matrices, and keeping only the top singular vectors.
This low-rank basis can then be fine-tuned on target tasks, while the rest of the model parameters are kept fixed. This allows for significant compression of the model size, often by 10x or more, while maintaining the strong performance of the original language model.
The authors explore different strategies for selecting the basis, including random selection and learned basis selection. They find that the learned basis selection approach generally outperforms the random baseline, as it is able to identify the most important features for the target task.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough analysis of the accuracy-efficiency trade-offs of their low-rank decomposition approach, exploring how the choice of basis size impacts both model performance and inference speed.
One potential limitation is that the basis selection process is fairly complex, involving SVD and other optimization steps. This could make it challenging to apply in practical settings, especially for non-expert users. It would be interesting to see if there are simpler or more automated ways to identify the crucial basis vectors.
Additionally, while the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on a range of language tasks, it's unclear how well it would generalize to other domains, such as vision or multi-modal models. Further research may be needed to understand the broader applicability of low-rank decomposition techniques.
Overall, this paper presents a promising direction for efficiently compressing and adapting large language models to specific use cases. The authors have made a valuable contribution to the growing body of work on model compression and efficient deep learning.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach for compressing and adapting large pre-trained language models to target applications. By decomposing the model weights into a low-rank basis, the authors are able to achieve significant model compression while retaining the strong performance of the original model.
This work has important implications for the practical deployment of powerful language models, as it addresses key challenges around model size, inference speed, and task-specific adaptation. As AI systems become more ubiquitous, techniques like this will be crucial for enabling their use in resource-constrained environments and real-world applications.
While the authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of their approach, there remain opportunities for further research and refinement. Exploring simpler basis selection methods, as well as evaluating the technique on a broader range of model types and domains, could help unlock the full potential of low-rank decomposition for efficient and adaptive AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Feature-based Low-Rank Compression of Large Language Models via Bayesian Optimization
Yixin Ji, Yang Xiang, Juntao Li, Wei Chen, Zhongyi Liu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang
0
0
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have driven advances in natural language processing. Still, their growing scale has increased the computational burden, necessitating a balance between efficiency and performance. Low-rank compression, a promising technique, reduces non-essential parameters by decomposing weight matrices into products of two low-rank matrices. Yet, its application in LLMs has not been extensively studied. The key to low-rank compression lies in low-rank factorization and low-rank dimensions allocation. To address the challenges of low-rank compression in LLMs, we conduct empirical research on the low-rank characteristics of large models. We propose a low-rank compression method suitable for LLMs. This approach involves precise estimation of feature distributions through pooled covariance matrices and a Bayesian optimization strategy for allocating low-rank dimensions. Experiments on the LLaMA-2 models demonstrate that our method outperforms existing strong structured pruning and low-rank compression techniques in maintaining model performance at the same compression ratio.
5/20/2024
🎯
Characterizing the Accuracy - Efficiency Trade-off of Low-rank Decomposition in Language Models
Chakshu Moar, Michael Pellauer, Hyoukjun Kwon
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged and presented their general problem-solving capabilities with one model. However, the model size has increased dramatically with billions of parameters to enable such broad problem-solving capabilities. In addition, due to the dominance of matrix-matrix and matrix-vector multiplications in LLMs, the compute-to-model size ratio is significantly lower than that of CNNs. This shift pushes LLMs from a computation-bound regime to a memory-bound regime. Therefore, optimizing the memory footprint and traffic is an important optimization direction for LLMs today. Model compression methods such as quantization and parameter pruning have been actively explored for achieving the memory footprint and traffic optimization. However, the accuracy-efficiency trade-off of rank pruning for LLMs is not well-understood yet. Therefore, we characterize the accuracy-efficiency trade-off of a low-rank decomposition method, specifically Tucker decomposition, on recent language models, including an open-source LLM, Llama 2. We formalize the low-rank decomposition design space and show that the decomposition design space is enormous (e.g., O($2^{37}$) for Llama2-7B). To navigate such a vast design space, we formulate the design space and perform thorough case studies of accuracy-efficiency trade-offs using six widely used LLM benchmarks on BERT and Llama 2 models. Our results show that we can achieve a 9% model size reduction with minimal accuracy drops, which range from 4%p to 10%p, depending on the difficulty of the benchmark, without any retraining to recover accuracy after decomposition. The results show that low-rank decomposition can be a promising direction for LLM-based applications that require real-time service in scale (e.g., AI agent assist and real-time coding assistant), where the latency is as important as the model accuracy.
5/13/2024
Compressing Large Language Models using Low Rank and Low Precision Decomposition
Rajarshi Saha, Naomi Sagan, Varun Srivastava, Andrea J. Goldsmith, Mert Pilanci
0
0
The prohibitive sizes of Large Language Models (LLMs) today make it difficult to deploy them on memory-constrained edge devices. This work introduces $rm CALDERA$ -- a new post-training LLM compression algorithm that harnesses the inherent low-rank structure of a weight matrix $mathbf{W}$ by approximating it via a low-rank, low-precision decomposition as $mathbf{W} approx mathbf{Q} + mathbf{L}mathbf{R}$. Here, $mathbf{L}$ and $mathbf{R}$ are low rank factors, and the entries of $mathbf{Q}$, $mathbf{L}$ and $mathbf{R}$ are quantized. The model is compressed by substituting each layer with its $mathbf{Q} + mathbf{L}mathbf{R}$ decomposition, and the zero-shot performance of the compressed model is evaluated. Additionally, $mathbf{L}$ and $mathbf{R}$ are readily amenable to low-rank adaptation, consequently enhancing the zero-shot performance. $rm CALDERA$ obtains this decomposition by formulating it as an optimization problem $min_{mathbf{Q},mathbf{L},mathbf{R}}lVert(mathbf{Q} + mathbf{L}mathbf{R} - mathbf{W})mathbf{X}^toprVert_{rm F}^2$, where $mathbf{X}$ is the calibration data, and $mathbf{Q}, mathbf{L}, mathbf{R}$ are constrained to be representable using low-precision formats. Theoretical upper bounds on the approximation error of $rm CALDERA$ are established using a rank-constrained regression framework, and the tradeoff between compression ratio and model performance is studied by analyzing the impact of target rank and quantization bit budget. Results illustrate that compressing LlaMa-$2$ $7$B/$70$B and LlaMa-$3$ $8$B models obtained using $rm CALDERA$ outperforms existing post-training LLM compression techniques in the regime of less than $2.5$ bits per parameter. The implementation is available at: href{https://github.com/pilancilab/caldera}{https://github.com/pilancilab/caldera}.
5/30/2024
📉
Surgical Feature-Space Decomposition of LLMs: Why, When and How?
Arnav Chavan, Nahush Lele, Deepak Gupta
0
0
Low-rank approximations, of the weight and feature space can enhance the performance of deep learning models, whether in terms of improving generalization or reducing the latency of inference. However, there is no clear consensus yet on emph{how}, emph{when} and emph{why} these approximations are helpful for large language models (LLMs). In this work, we empirically study the efficacy of weight and feature space decomposition in transformer-based LLMs. We demonstrate that surgical decomposition not only provides critical insights into the trade-off between compression and language modelling performance, but also sometimes enhances commonsense reasoning performance of LLMs. Our empirical analysis identifies specific network segments that intrinsically exhibit a low-rank structure. Furthermore, we extend our investigation to the implications of low-rank approximations on model bias. Overall, our findings offer a novel perspective on optimizing LLMs, presenting the low-rank approximation not only as a tool for performance enhancements, but also as a means to potentially rectify biases within these models. Our code is available at href{https://github.com/nyunAI/SFSD-LLM}{GitHub}.
5/24/2024