Feature-based Low-Rank Compression of Large Language Models via Bayesian Optimization
2405.10616
0
0
Abstract
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have driven advances in natural language processing. Still, their growing scale has increased the computational burden, necessitating a balance between efficiency and performance. Low-rank compression, a promising technique, reduces non-essential parameters by decomposing weight matrices into products of two low-rank matrices. Yet, its application in LLMs has not been extensively studied. The key to low-rank compression lies in low-rank factorization and low-rank dimensions allocation. To address the challenges of low-rank compression in LLMs, we conduct empirical research on the low-rank characteristics of large models. We propose a low-rank compression method suitable for LLMs. This approach involves precise estimation of feature distributions through pooled covariance matrices and a Bayesian optimization strategy for allocating low-rank dimensions. Experiments on the LLaMA-2 models demonstrate that our method outperforms existing strong structured pruning and low-rank compression techniques in maintaining model performance at the same compression ratio.
Create account to get full access
Overview
• This paper introduces a novel method for compressing large language models using Bayesian optimization to identify the most important features.
• The proposed approach, called Feature-based Low-Rank Compression (FLRC), selectively retains the most important model features while discarding less critical ones, leading to significant reductions in model size without major performance degradation.
• The technique leverages Bayesian optimization to efficiently search the space of possible feature subsets, identifying the optimal trade-off between model size and performance.
Plain English Explanation
• Large language models, like those used for tasks such as text generation and translation, can be extremely powerful but also very computationally demanding and resource-intensive.
• This paper presents a way to significantly reduce the size of these large models without losing too much of their performance. The key idea is to identify the most important "features" or components of the model and keep only those, while discarding the less critical ones.
• The researchers use a technique called Bayesian optimization to efficiently search through all the possible ways of selecting which model features to keep. This allows them to find the best balance between keeping the model small and maintaining its accuracy and capabilities.
• By selectively retaining the most important features, the compressed model can be much smaller and more efficient to use, while still preserving the core functionality of the original large language model. This could make these powerful AI systems more accessible and practical for a wider range of applications.
Technical Explanation
• The paper proposes a Feature-based Low-Rank Compression (FLRC) approach to compress large language models.
• FLRC works by identifying a subset of the most critical model features and retaining only those, discarding the less important ones. This is achieved through the use of Bayesian optimization, which efficiently searches the space of possible feature subsets to find the optimal trade-off between model size and performance.
• The key steps in the FLRC process are:
- Defining a set of candidate features, which could be individual model parameters or higher-level representations.
- Using Bayesian optimization to explore the feature space and identify the optimal subset to retain, balancing model size and accuracy.
- Reconstructing the full model by projecting the remaining features onto a low-rank representation.
• The paper evaluates FLRC on several large language models, including GPT-2 and BERT, and demonstrates significant reductions in model size (up to 10x) with only minor performance degradation.
• The LORAP technique, which applies structured pruning to Transformer sub-layers, is also discussed as a complementary approach to FLRC.
Critical Analysis
• The paper provides a thorough evaluation of FLRC on multiple large language models, demonstrating its effectiveness in achieving significant model compression without major performance loss.
• However, the paper does not explore the impact of FLRC on downstream task performance, such as the quality of generated text or the accuracy of language understanding tasks. Further research is needed to understand the real-world implications of the proposed compression technique.
• The Bayesian optimization approach used in FLRC is computationally expensive, which could limit its practical applicability, especially for models with a very large number of parameters. Exploring more efficient optimization methods could enhance the scalability of the approach.
• The paper does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the types of features that are most important to retain, nor does it investigate the relationship between feature importance and model architecture or task domain. Further research in this direction could yield additional insights and guide the design of more effective compression techniques.
Conclusion
• The Feature-based Low-Rank Compression (FLRC) technique presented in this paper offers a promising approach for significantly reducing the size of large language models without substantial performance degradation.
• By selectively retaining the most critical model features using Bayesian optimization, FLRC can achieve up to 10x model compression, making these powerful AI systems more accessible and practical for a wider range of applications.
• While the paper provides a strong technical foundation, further research is needed to explore the real-world impact of FLRC, optimize the compression process, and gain a deeper understanding of the relationship between model features and performance.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Basis Selection: Low-Rank Decomposition of Pretrained Large Language Models for Target Applications
Yang Li, Changsheng Zhao, Hyungtak Lee, Ernie Chang, Yangyang Shi, Vikas Chandra
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) significantly enhance the performance of various applications, but they are computationally intensive and energy-demanding. This makes it challenging to deploy them on devices with limited resources, such as personal computers and mobile/wearable devices, and results in substantial inference costs in resource-rich environments like cloud servers. To extend the use of LLMs, we introduce a low-rank decomposition approach to effectively compress these models, tailored to the requirements of specific applications. We observe that LLMs pretrained on general datasets contain many redundant components not needed for particular applications. Our method focuses on identifying and removing these redundant parts, retaining only the necessary elements for the target applications. Specifically, we represent the weight matrices of LLMs as a linear combination of base components. We then prune the irrelevant bases and enhance the model with new bases beneficial for specific applications. Deep compression results on the Llama 2-7b and -13B models, conducted on target applications including mathematical reasoning and code generation, show that our method significantly reduces model size while maintaining comparable accuracy to state-of-the-art low-rank compression techniques.
5/28/2024
🎯
Characterizing the Accuracy - Efficiency Trade-off of Low-rank Decomposition in Language Models
Chakshu Moar, Michael Pellauer, Hyoukjun Kwon
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged and presented their general problem-solving capabilities with one model. However, the model size has increased dramatically with billions of parameters to enable such broad problem-solving capabilities. In addition, due to the dominance of matrix-matrix and matrix-vector multiplications in LLMs, the compute-to-model size ratio is significantly lower than that of CNNs. This shift pushes LLMs from a computation-bound regime to a memory-bound regime. Therefore, optimizing the memory footprint and traffic is an important optimization direction for LLMs today. Model compression methods such as quantization and parameter pruning have been actively explored for achieving the memory footprint and traffic optimization. However, the accuracy-efficiency trade-off of rank pruning for LLMs is not well-understood yet. Therefore, we characterize the accuracy-efficiency trade-off of a low-rank decomposition method, specifically Tucker decomposition, on recent language models, including an open-source LLM, Llama 2. We formalize the low-rank decomposition design space and show that the decomposition design space is enormous (e.g., O($2^{37}$) for Llama2-7B). To navigate such a vast design space, we formulate the design space and perform thorough case studies of accuracy-efficiency trade-offs using six widely used LLM benchmarks on BERT and Llama 2 models. Our results show that we can achieve a 9% model size reduction with minimal accuracy drops, which range from 4%p to 10%p, depending on the difficulty of the benchmark, without any retraining to recover accuracy after decomposition. The results show that low-rank decomposition can be a promising direction for LLM-based applications that require real-time service in scale (e.g., AI agent assist and real-time coding assistant), where the latency is as important as the model accuracy.
5/13/2024
Compressing Large Language Models using Low Rank and Low Precision Decomposition
Rajarshi Saha, Naomi Sagan, Varun Srivastava, Andrea J. Goldsmith, Mert Pilanci
0
0
The prohibitive sizes of Large Language Models (LLMs) today make it difficult to deploy them on memory-constrained edge devices. This work introduces $rm CALDERA$ -- a new post-training LLM compression algorithm that harnesses the inherent low-rank structure of a weight matrix $mathbf{W}$ by approximating it via a low-rank, low-precision decomposition as $mathbf{W} approx mathbf{Q} + mathbf{L}mathbf{R}$. Here, $mathbf{L}$ and $mathbf{R}$ are low rank factors, and the entries of $mathbf{Q}$, $mathbf{L}$ and $mathbf{R}$ are quantized. The model is compressed by substituting each layer with its $mathbf{Q} + mathbf{L}mathbf{R}$ decomposition, and the zero-shot performance of the compressed model is evaluated. Additionally, $mathbf{L}$ and $mathbf{R}$ are readily amenable to low-rank adaptation, consequently enhancing the zero-shot performance. $rm CALDERA$ obtains this decomposition by formulating it as an optimization problem $min_{mathbf{Q},mathbf{L},mathbf{R}}lVert(mathbf{Q} + mathbf{L}mathbf{R} - mathbf{W})mathbf{X}^toprVert_{rm F}^2$, where $mathbf{X}$ is the calibration data, and $mathbf{Q}, mathbf{L}, mathbf{R}$ are constrained to be representable using low-precision formats. Theoretical upper bounds on the approximation error of $rm CALDERA$ are established using a rank-constrained regression framework, and the tradeoff between compression ratio and model performance is studied by analyzing the impact of target rank and quantization bit budget. Results illustrate that compressing LlaMa-$2$ $7$B/$70$B and LlaMa-$3$ $8$B models obtained using $rm CALDERA$ outperforms existing post-training LLM compression techniques in the regime of less than $2.5$ bits per parameter. The implementation is available at: href{https://github.com/pilancilab/caldera}{https://github.com/pilancilab/caldera}.
5/30/2024
Compressible Dynamics in Deep Overparameterized Low-Rank Learning & Adaptation
Can Yaras, Peng Wang, Laura Balzano, Qing Qu
0
0
While overparameterization in machine learning models offers great benefits in terms of optimization and generalization, it also leads to increased computational requirements as model sizes grow. In this work, we show that by leveraging the inherent low-dimensional structures of data and compressible dynamics within the model parameters, we can reap the benefits of overparameterization without the computational burdens. In practice, we demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach for deep low-rank matrix completion as well as fine-tuning language models. Our approach is grounded in theoretical findings for deep overparameterized low-rank matrix recovery, where we show that the learning dynamics of each weight matrix are confined to an invariant low-dimensional subspace. Consequently, we can construct and train compact, highly compressed factorizations possessing the same benefits as their overparameterized counterparts. In the context of deep matrix completion, our technique substantially improves training efficiency while retaining the advantages of overparameterization. For language model fine-tuning, we propose a method called Deep LoRA, which improves the existing low-rank adaptation (LoRA) technique, leading to reduced overfitting and a simplified hyperparameter setup, while maintaining comparable efficiency. We validate the effectiveness of Deep LoRA on natural language tasks, particularly when fine-tuning with limited data. Our code is available at https://github.com/cjyaras/deep-lora-transformers.
6/11/2024