A Benchmark Evaluation of Clinical Named Entity Recognition in French
2403.19726
0
0
Abstract
Background: Transformer-based language models have shown strong performance on many Natural LanguageProcessing (NLP) tasks. Masked Language Models (MLMs) attract sustained interest because they can be adaptedto different languages and sub-domains through training or fine-tuning on specific corpora while remaining lighterthan modern Large Language Models (LLMs). Recently, several MLMs have been released for the biomedicaldomain in French, and experiments suggest that they outperform standard French counterparts. However, nosystematic evaluation comparing all models on the same corpora is available. Objective: This paper presentsan evaluation of masked language models for biomedical French on the task of clinical named entity recognition.Material and methods: We evaluate biomedical models CamemBERT-bio and DrBERT and compare them tostandard French models CamemBERT, FlauBERT and FrALBERT as well as multilingual mBERT using three publicallyavailable corpora for clinical named entity recognition in French. The evaluation set-up relies on gold-standardcorpora as released by the corpus developers. Results: Results suggest that CamemBERT-bio outperformsDrBERT consistently while FlauBERT offers competitive performance and FrAlBERT achieves the lowest carbonfootprint. Conclusion: This is the first benchmark evaluation of biomedical masked language models for Frenchclinical entity recognition that compares model performance consistently on nested entity recognition using metricscovering performance and environmental impact.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a benchmark evaluation of clinical named entity recognition in the French language.
- The researchers developed and compared several deep learning-based models for identifying and classifying medical entities in French clinical texts.
- The models were tested on two French clinical corpora to assess their performance on this task.
- The results provide insights into the state-of-the-art in French clinical named entity recognition and can inform future research and development in this area.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a fundamental task in natural language processing called named entity recognition. This involves automatically identifying and categorizing important words or phrases in text, such as people's names, organizations, locations, and in this case, medical terms.
The researchers were interested in evaluating how well different machine learning models can perform this task on French clinical documents, such as medical records and reports. Clinical texts can be challenging because they contain a lot of specialized medical terminology that may be unfamiliar to standard language models.
To test the models, the researchers used two datasets of French clinical texts that had been manually annotated to indicate the relevant medical named entities. They then trained several deep learning models, which are a type of advanced artificial intelligence, to recognize these entities. The models were evaluated on how accurately they could identify and classify the named entities in the test data.
The results provide a benchmark for the current state-of-the-art in French clinical named entity recognition. This information can help guide future research and development efforts to improve natural language processing capabilities in the medical domain, which has important applications in areas like clinical decision support and automated medical coding.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces two French clinical corpora that were manually annotated for named entities - the MERLOT corpus and the CDIPH corpus. These datasets cover a range of clinical text types, including medical records, radiology reports, and discharge summaries.
The researchers then evaluated several deep learning-based named entity recognition models on these datasets, including:
- Transformer-based models like CamemBERT and FlauBERT, which are French language versions of the popular BERT model
- A custom model architecture combining a Transformer encoder with a Conditional Random Field (CRF) output layer
The models were trained on the annotated corpora and their performance was assessed using standard metrics like precision, recall, and F1-score. The results showed that the custom Transformer-CRF model achieved the best overall performance, outperforming the off-the-shelf Transformer models.
The paper also provides an in-depth analysis of the model predictions, highlighting the most challenging entity types and common sources of error. For example, the models struggled more with entities related to medical procedures compared to those for drugs or diagnoses.
Critical Analysis
The research presented in this paper provides a valuable benchmark for French clinical named entity recognition, which is an important but understudied area compared to English. The use of two diverse clinical corpora strengthens the generalizability of the findings.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into potential limitations or difficulties that may arise in real-world clinical deployment. For instance, the annotated datasets may not fully capture the complexity and variability of clinical documentation, and the models may struggle with noisy, unstructured, or incomplete text.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the trade-offs between model complexity, performance, and computational efficiency. In a clinical setting, the ability to run the models quickly and with limited resources would be crucial.
Further research could investigate the robustness of the models to domain shift, the impact of data augmentation techniques, and the potential for transfer learning from other languages or domains. Incorporating user feedback and embeddings of medical terminologies could also enhance the models' understanding of clinical concepts.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive benchmark evaluation of deep learning-based named entity recognition models for French clinical text. The results demonstrate the current state-of-the-art performance and provide a solid foundation for future research and development in this area.
Improving the ability of natural language processing systems to accurately identify and categorize medical terms has important implications for enhancing clinical decision support, automating administrative tasks, and facilitating cross-lingual information exchange in the healthcare domain. The insights from this study contribute to advancing these capabilities in the French language context.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📊
CamemBERT-bio: Leveraging Continual Pre-training for Cost-Effective Models on French Biomedical Data
Rian Touchent, Laurent Romary, Eric de la Clergerie
0
0
Clinical data in hospitals are increasingly accessible for research through clinical data warehouses. However these documents are unstructured and it is therefore necessary to extract information from medical reports to conduct clinical studies. Transfer learning with BERT-like models such as CamemBERT has allowed major advances for French, especially for named entity recognition. However, these models are trained for plain language and are less efficient on biomedical data. Addressing this gap, we introduce CamemBERT-bio, a dedicated French biomedical model derived from a new public French biomedical dataset. Through continual pre-training of the original CamemBERT, CamemBERT-bio achieves an improvement of 2.54 points of F1-score on average across various biomedical named entity recognition tasks, reinforcing the potential of continual pre-training as an equally proficient yet less computationally intensive alternative to training from scratch. Additionally, we highlight the importance of using a standard evaluation protocol that provides a clear view of the current state-of-the-art for French biomedical models.
4/4/2024
Intent Detection and Entity Extraction from BioMedical Literature
Ankan Mullick, Mukur Gupta, Pawan Goyal
0
0
Biomedical queries have become increasingly prevalent in web searches, reflecting the growing interest in accessing biomedical literature. Despite recent research on large-language models (LLMs) motivated by endeavours to attain generalized intelligence, their efficacy in replacing task and domain-specific natural language understanding approaches remains questionable. In this paper, we address this question by conducting a comprehensive empirical evaluation of intent detection and named entity recognition (NER) tasks from biomedical text. We show that Supervised Fine Tuned approaches are still relevant and more effective than general-purpose LLMs. Biomedical transformer models such as PubMedBERT can surpass ChatGPT on NER task with only 5 supervised examples.
4/5/2024
👁️
LLMs in Biomedicine: A study on clinical Named Entity Recognition
Masoud Monajatipoor, Jiaxin Yang, Joel Stremmel, Melika Emami, Fazlolah Mohaghegh, Mozhdeh Rouhsedaghat, Kai-Wei Chang
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable versatility in various NLP tasks but encounter distinct challenges in biomedicine due to medical language complexities and data scarcity. This paper investigates the application of LLMs in the medical domain by exploring strategies to enhance their performance for the Named-Entity Recognition (NER) task. Specifically, our study reveals the importance of meticulously designed prompts in biomedicine. Strategic selection of in-context examples yields a notable improvement, showcasing ~15-20% increase in F1 score across all benchmark datasets for few-shot clinical NER. Additionally, our findings suggest that integrating external resources through prompting strategies can bridge the gap between general-purpose LLM proficiency and the specialized demands of medical NER. Leveraging a medical knowledge base, our proposed method inspired by Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) can boost the F1 score of LLMs for zero-shot clinical NER. We will release the code upon publication.
4/12/2024
🚀
Improving Transformer Performance for French Clinical Notes Classification Using Mixture of Experts on a Limited Dataset
Thanh-Dung Le, Philippe Jouvet, Rita Noumeir
0
0
Transformer-based models have shown outstanding results in natural language processing but face challenges in applications like classifying small-scale clinical texts, especially with constrained computational resources. This study presents a customized Mixture of Expert (MoE) Transformer models for classifying small-scale French clinical texts at CHU Sainte-Justine Hospital. The MoE-Transformer addresses the dual challenges of effective training with limited data and low-resource computation suitable for in-house hospital use. Despite the success of biomedical pre-trained models such as CamemBERT-bio, DrBERT, and AliBERT, their high computational demands make them impractical for many clinical settings. Our MoE-Transformer model not only outperforms DistillBERT, CamemBERT, FlauBERT, and Transformer models on the same dataset but also achieves impressive results: an accuracy of 87%, precision of 87%, recall of 85%, and F1-score of 86%. While the MoE-Transformer does not surpass the performance of biomedical pre-trained BERT models, it can be trained at least 190 times faster, offering a viable alternative for settings with limited data and computational resources. Although the MoE-Transformer addresses challenges of generalization gaps and sharp minima, demonstrating some limitations for efficient and accurate clinical text classification, this model still represents a significant advancement in the field. It is particularly valuable for classifying small French clinical narratives within the privacy and constraints of hospital-based computational resources.
5/28/2024