Benchmarking changepoint detection algorithms on cardiac time series
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper benchmarks the performance of different changepoint detection algorithms on cardiac time series data.
- The researchers used both artificial and real-world heart rate data to evaluate the accuracy and speed of several popular changepoint detection methods.
- The findings provide insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each algorithm, which can guide researchers and clinicians in selecting the most appropriate technique for their cardiac monitoring applications.
Plain English Explanation
Changepoint detection is a technique used to identify the points in time where a significant change occurs in a data stream, such as a patient's heart rate. This is an important tool for cardiac monitoring applications and anomaly detection in electrocardiograms.
In this study, the researchers wanted to compare how well different changepoint detection algorithms perform on heart rate data. They used both artificially generated heart rate data and real-world data from patients to test the accuracy and speed of several popular changepoint detection methods.
The key findings from this benchmarking exercise can help researchers and clinicians choose the most appropriate changepoint detection algorithm for their specific cardiac monitoring needs. For example, some algorithms may be faster but less accurate, while others may be more reliable but slower. Understanding the trade-offs between these different approaches is crucial for real-time adaptive sampling of cardiac signals and detecting changes in remote sensing data.
Technical Explanation
The researchers used both artificially generated heart rate data and real-world heart rate data from patients to benchmark the performance of several changepoint detection algorithms. The artificial data allowed them to precisely control the timing and magnitude of changepoints, while the real-world data provided a more realistic and challenging test scenario.
For the artificial data, they simulated heart rate time series with known changepoints that varied in terms of the number, timing, and size of the changes. This allowed them to systematically evaluate the accuracy of each changepoint detection method in identifying the true changepoints.
On the real-world data, the researchers used heart rate recordings from patients with Alzheimer's disease and healthy controls. They assessed the ability of the changepoint detection algorithms to identify clinically relevant changes in heart rate, such as those associated with changes in physical activity or autonomic nervous system function.
In addition to accuracy, the researchers also measured the computational time and memory usage of each changepoint detection method. This is important for real-time applications where the speed and efficiency of the algorithm are critical.
The results of the benchmarking exercise provided insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each changepoint detection algorithm, helping researchers and clinicians choose the most appropriate method for their specific cardiac monitoring needs.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledged several limitations of their study, including the fact that they only tested a subset of available changepoint detection algorithms and that the real-world data may not have been fully representative of all cardiac monitoring scenarios.
Additionally, the study did not explore the impact of different preprocessing steps, such as filtering or normalization, on the performance of the changepoint detection algorithms. These preprocessing choices can significantly affect the results and should be considered in future research.
Another potential area for further investigation is the robustness of the changepoint detection methods to noise and artifacts in the cardiac time series data. Real-world heart rate recordings often contain various types of noise that can challenge the accuracy of these algorithms.
Despite these limitations, the benchmarking approach used in this study provides a valuable framework for evaluating the performance of changepoint detection algorithms on cardiac data. The insights gained from this work can inform the development of more advanced techniques and their application in real-world clinical settings.
Conclusion
This paper presents a comprehensive benchmarking of changepoint detection algorithms on cardiac time series data, using both artificial and real-world heart rate recordings. The findings provide valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of different changepoint detection methods, which can guide researchers and clinicians in selecting the most appropriate technique for their specific cardiac monitoring applications.
The results highlight the importance of carefully evaluating the performance of these algorithms on realistic data, as the accuracy and efficiency of changepoint detection can have significant implications for real-time adaptive sampling, anomaly detection in electrocardiograms, and other cardiac monitoring applications. This work lays the foundation for further research and development in this critical area of biomedical signal processing.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Benchmarking changepoint detection algorithms on cardiac time series
Ayse Cakmak, Erik Reinertsen, Shamim Nemati, Gari D. Clifford
The pattern of state changes in a biomedical time series can be related to health or disease. This work presents a principled approach for selecting a changepoint detection algorithm for a specific task, such as disease classification. Eight key algorithms were compared, and the performance of each algorithm was evaluated as a function of temporal tolerance, noise, and abnormal conduction (ectopy) on realistic artificial cardiovascular time series data. All algorithms were applied to real data (cardiac time series of 22 patients with REM-behavior disorder (RBD) and 15 healthy controls) using the parameters selected on artificial data. Finally, features were derived from the detected changepoints to classify RBD patients from healthy controls using a K-Nearest Neighbors approach. On artificial data, Modified Bayesian Changepoint Detection algorithm provided superior positive predictive value for state change identification while Recursive Mean Difference Maximization (RMDM) achieved the highest true positive rate. For the classification task, features derived from the RMDM algorithm provided the highest leave one out cross validated accuracy of 0.89 and true positive rate of 0.87. Automatically detected changepoints provide useful information about subject's physiological state which cannot be directly observed. However, the choice of change point detection algorithm depends on the nature of the underlying data and the downstream application, such as a classification task. This work represents the first time change point detection algorithms have been compared in a meaningful way and utilized in a classification task, which demonstrates the effect of changepoint algorithm choice on application performance.
Read more4/22/2024
🔎
0
Causal Discovery-Driven Change Point Detection in Time Series
Shanyun Gao, Raghavendra Addanki, Tong Yu, Ryan A. Rossi, Murat Kocaoglu
Change point detection in time series seeks to identify times when the probability distribution of time series changes. It is widely applied in many areas, such as human-activity sensing and medical science. In the context of multivariate time series, this typically involves examining the joint distribution of high-dimensional data: If any one variable changes, the whole time series is assumed to have changed. However, in practical applications, we may be interested only in certain components of the time series, exploring abrupt changes in their distributions in the presence of other time series. Here, assuming an underlying structural causal model that governs the time-series data generation, we address this problem by proposing a two-stage non-parametric algorithm that first learns parts of the causal structure through constraint-based discovery methods. The algorithm then uses conditional relative Pearson divergence estimation to identify the change points. The conditional relative Pearson divergence quantifies the distribution disparity between consecutive segments in the time series, while the causal discovery method enables a focus on the causal mechanism, facilitating access to independent and identically distributed (IID) samples. Theoretically, the typical assumption of samples being IID in conventional change point detection methods can be relaxed based on the Causal Markov Condition. Through experiments on both synthetic and real-world datasets, we validate the correctness and utility of our approach.
Read more7/11/2024
🔎
0
Predictive change point detection for heterogeneous data
Anna-Christina Glock, Florian Sobieczky, Johannes Furnkranz, Peter Filzmoser, Martin Jech
A change point detection (CPD) framework assisted by a predictive machine learning model called Predict and Compare is introduced and characterised in relation to other state-of-the-art online CPD routines which it outperforms in terms of false positive rate and out-of-control average run length. The method's focus is on improving standard methods from sequential analysis such as the CUSUM rule in terms of these quality measures. This is achieved by replacing typically used trend estimation functionals such as the running mean with more sophisticated predictive models (Predict step), and comparing their prognosis with actual data (Compare step). The two models used in the Predict step are the ARIMA model and the LSTM recursive neural network. However, the framework is formulated in general terms, so as to allow the use of other prediction or comparison methods than those tested here. The power of the method is demonstrated in a tribological case study in which change points separating the run-in, steady-state, and divergent wear phases are detected in the regime of very few false positives.
Read more5/6/2024
0
Bayesian Autoregressive Online Change-Point Detection with Time-Varying Parameters
Ioanna-Yvonni Tsaknaki, Fabrizio Lillo, Piero Mazzarisi
Change points in real-world systems mark significant regime shifts in system dynamics, possibly triggered by exogenous or endogenous factors. These points define regimes for the time evolution of the system and are crucial for understanding transitions in financial, economic, social, environmental, and technological contexts. Building upon the Bayesian approach introduced in cite{c:07}, we devise a new method for online change point detection in the mean of a univariate time series, which is well suited for real-time applications and is able to handle the general temporal patterns displayed by data in many empirical contexts. We first describe time series as an autoregressive process of an arbitrary order. Second, the variance and correlation of the data are allowed to vary within each regime driven by a scoring rule that updates the value of the parameters for a better fit of the observations. Finally, a change point is detected in a probabilistic framework via the posterior distribution of the current regime length. By modeling temporal dependencies and time-varying parameters, the proposed approach enhances both the estimate accuracy and the forecasting power. Empirical validations using various datasets demonstrate the method's effectiveness in capturing memory and dynamic patterns, offering deeper insights into the non-stationary dynamics of real-world systems.
Read more7/24/2024